Erie Metal Roofs, also known as Erie Construction Midwest, Erie Roofing, or Erie Home, is a home remodeling company based in Toledo, Ohio. It specializes in window and roof replacements, but depending on which child company you go with, it can also work on siding, patios, and gutter installations.
Erie is a top choice if you want a well-established roofing contractor with a strong reputation. Read our comprehensive Erie roofing review to discover if this provider is the right fit for your roofing project.
- Erie Metal Roofs uses stamped steel roofing tiles, which provide the longevity and durability of steel with the aesthetic appeal of stone or wood.
- Erie roofs are high-quality and, by all accounts, live up to their advertised 50-year life span.
- Erie roofs cost between $12,000–$27,000, depending on the roof size and materials.
Our Review of Erie Metal Roofs
Ultimately, Erie Metal Roofs is an excellent metal roofing installer. Its products are extremely high-quality, with many customers claiming they’re as long-lasting and durable as advertised. Erie shows confidence in its roofs through its limited lifetime workmanship and product warranty. This warranty protects your roof from structural and workmanship faults. Even better, Erie’s warranty is transferable to new homeowners, making it a great selling point during a home sale.
Regarding Erie’s prices, our research shows that they align with other metal roofers. According to the information posted in its blog and what we could glean by reading customer reviews, most Erie roofs sit within a $12,000 to $27,000 price range. Some customers noted prices as high as $45,000 to $50,000, but these cases were rare and could have resulted from larger-than-average roofs or specialty installations. While these prices are high compared to some roofing materials, they align perfectly with what you could expect to pay for a tin roof.
Two drawbacks of Erie are its lack of selection and limited availability. Erie operates out of 30 states, meaning about one-third of the nation can’t use its services. Additionally, it only offers three kinds of shingles, limiting your customization options.
Pros and Cons of Erie Metal Roofs
Pros
- Long-lasting, high-end materials
- Impressive lifetime warranty
- Provides first-time roof installation and military discounts
- Flexible financing options
Cons
- Limited roof options
- Only available in 30 states
How Does Erie Metal Roofs Stack Up Against The “Big 4”?
When analyzing a roofing company, there are four major criteria that we always check to ensure it’s both reliable and trustworthy:
- Is the company licensed, insured, and GAF certified?
- Can you meet and talk to the company’s owner, and will they be on-site for your roofing job?
- Does it offer a no-leak satisfaction guarantee?
- Does it provide free inspections?
Erie Metal Roofs passes each criterion. It’s certified in 23 states, with state license lookups providing positive results. Additionally, it has shown itself to be bonded and insured. While it may be difficult to speak with the owner of Erie Construction Company, numerous customer reviews mentioned speaking to regional branch managers, who were more than willing to intervene in the event of a problem.
While we didn’t see any direct mention of a leak or satisfaction guarantee on its website, it has consistently addressed those complaints on the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and Trustpilot. Combining this with its lifetime warranty, it’s clear that Erie is dedicated to addressing product and installation issues.
You can check the license of any roofing company through your state’s appropriate regulatory agency, typically a state license board. These agencies usually have a lookup tool that you can find online. Otherwise, you’ll have to call.
What Is Erie’s Pricing for Roofs?
Like many contracting and home improvement companies, Erie Metal Roofs doesn’t supply direct prices on its website. Additionally, its website doesn’t include a price calculator or estimator tool. The only direct pricing information available on the Erie website is through one of its blog posts.
According to Erie, it estimates that you can expect to pay between $7 to $12 per square foot, which is slightly lower than the national average for metal roof systems. Typically, most metal roofs cost $10 to $13 or more, depending on the type of metal you choose. When digging into customer reviews, those that mention pricing indicate that roofs cost between $12,000 to $23,000 — this price range aligns with the estimates Erie put in its blog post.
However, some customers mentioned abnormally high costs, with several putting their roof price over $45,000. These numbers, while high, are not outside the realm of possibility and can be seen for homes with large roofs, multiple tiers of roofs, or other special conditions.
What Kind of Shingles Does Erie Metal Roofs Use?
Erie uses its own brand of steel shingles. These shingles allow homeowners to enjoy the high-end appearance of stone or wooden shake roofs with the lower price point of metal shingles. Erie offers three shingles: metal Spanish tile, stone-coated dimensional, and wood shake. Each type of shingle has the same shelf life of 50 years, requires little maintenance, and is highly durable, standing up to extreme weather conditions easily.
What Underlayment Does Erie Metal Roofs Use?
Erie doesn’t provide much direct information about its installation process on its website. So, there’s no way to know which underlayment type or brand it uses. However, based on our knowledge, we can assume that for most steep-sloped metal roofs, it will go with one of three options: felt underlayment, synthetic peel-and-stick underlayment, or synthetic sheet underlayment.
- Felt underlayment: Also called roofing felt or tar paper, this underlayment is made of tar combined with organic and synthetic materials. Felt underlayment is one of the most popular choices because it’s extremely cheap and easy to install. However, it has a shorter life span and doesn’t stand up to heat well, making it a less-than-optimal choice for hotter climates.
- Synthetic peel-and-stick underlayment: This underlayment is more expensive but performs better under most conditions than felt. It comprises a synthetic sheet (typically polyurethane), modified bitumen, and an adhesive (typically a butyl-based mixture or rubberized asphalt). This material is typically used in roof valleys or other important roof areas. This underlayment stands up to heat but doesn’t handle extremely low temperatures well.
- Synthetic sheet underlayment: This underlayment is made of synthetic polymer sheets (typically polyethylene or polypropylene) and lasts the longest while providing some of the best moisture protection. Instead of having a self-adhering membrane like peel-and–stick, it needs to be mechanically attached to your decking. This underlayment lasts the longest and provides the best overall durability, resisting hot and cold temperatures. However, it’s also the most expensive and difficult to install.
To see the difference between the look of traditional asphalt shingles and Erie’s product, here’s a video showing the before and after of a home Erie worked on.
What Types of Roofs Does Erie Offer?
Erie exclusively provides metal roofs consisting of its trademark metal shingles. When signing up with Erie, you can choose between three shingles for your roof: metal dimensional shingles, metal Spanish tile, and metal wood shake shingles. These roofs last up to 50 years, making them much more long-lasting than traditional asphalt roofs, putting them on par with other metal roofs.
Erie has two major benefits compared to other standard metal roofs: One, the appearance of its shingles mirrors that of other popular roofs. With Erie, you can enjoy the look and aesthetics of other roofs without any of those materials’ inherent downsides, combined with the durability and longevity of metal. Two, Erie’s roofs use shingles and are applied at a slope — this means that Erie roofs avoid many of the pitfalls of traditional metal roofs.
Metal Dimensional Shingles
These are solid steel shingles coated in an outer stone layer. These shingles have the appearance of dimensional asphalt shingles but are more long-lasting and durable. They come in multiple colors and styles and withstand high winds, hail, rain, and other extreme weather better than standard asphalt shingles.
Metal Spanish Tile
These shingles resemble Spanish-style tiles but are made of metal instead of clay. They also have the same life span as traditional Spanish tiles but are more durable and require less maintenance. They’re more resistant to mold, mildew, and moisture than traditional Spanish clay tiles.
Metal Wood Shake
These shingles are functionally similar to the metal Spanish tile, except they resemble traditional wood shake shingles. Wooden shingles provide a unique rustic look but are prone to mold damage and don’t stand up to climates with high moisture. These shingles offer the same rustic appearance but with none of the upkeep or mold problems.
What Is Erie Metal Roof’s Warranty?
Erie has a limited lifetime product and manufacturer warranty for all its metal roofs. Even better, this warranty is transferable, meaning that it increases your home’s resale value and can be used as a selling point when negotiating with buyers. By industry standards, this is one of the best warranties you can get — most other companies offer limited warranties lasting only 12 to 50 years.
According to customer testimonials, Erie consistently honors its warranty when issues arise. However, multiple complaints mentioned long wait times for warranty claims. While disappointing, these kinds of complaints are not uncommon for contracting companies, as most require a thorough inspection and claim evaluation process before work can begin.
What Does the Warranty Cover?
The warranty covers all installation and manufacturing defects, along with damage that directly results from those defects. Specific examples noted on Erie’s website include damage due to hail, high-speed winds, and issues like discoloration, rusting, and dislodged shingles.
How Long Is the Warranty?
The warranty lasts as long as the life span of the roof. It’s also transferable to new homeowners, so it can increase your home’s resale value and be a selling point when negotiating with homebuyers.
How Does Erie Metal Roofs Compare to Other Roofing Companies?
When compared to other industry competitors, Erie Metal Roofs does admirably well, excelling in certain areas while falling in line with industry averages in others. Erie’s materials, workmanship quality, and warranty are particularly impressive. Even in critical customer feedback, few, if any, criticized the quality of Erie’s products or the skill of its workforce.
The only major area where Erie falls short compared to similar companies is its material selection. Erie only provides metal shingle roofs and three kinds of shingles. While Erie has proven to be a specialist in these materials, customers looking for more variety or customization may want to look elsewhere.
| Factor | Erie Metal Roofs | DaBella | One Day Roofing | Power Home | CMR Construction & Roofing |
| Our Rating | 81.5 | 77.5 | 74 | 80 | 74.5 |
| BBB Rating | A+ | A+ | A+ | A+ | A+ |
| Yelp Rating | 1/5 stars | 2.5/5 stars | 1.5/5 stars | 2/5 stars | 1.5/5 stars |
| Average Price | $12,000–$24,000 | $12,000–$30,000 | $8,000–$12,000 | $5,000–$12,000 | $8,000–$12,000 |
| States Serviced | 30 | 30 | 6 | 24 | 50 |
| Roof Types Offered | Metal | Asphalt shingle, architectural, solar glass | Asphalt shingle | Asphalt shingle, architectural | Asphalt shingle, Wood shake, Metal, Clay Tile, Slate |
| Warranty | Lifetime/50+ years | Lifetime/50+ years | Lifetime/50+ years | Lifetime/50+ years | Lifetime/50+ years |
| Additional Services Offered | Windows, patio, siding, gutters | Windows, siding, bath, gutters, etc. | Windows, siding | NA | Siding, windows, gutters, roof repair |
What Is the Process to Work With Erie?
The process for signing on with Erie is very similar to other contractors or roofing companies.
- First, you’ll need to head to its website and either fill out a contact form (providing your email, name, and phone number), send an email, or call.
- Once the previous step is complete, you’ll be contacted by a customer service representative. They’ll get some preliminary information, then schedule an appointment with an inspector and sales rep.
- On the appointment date, an inspector will come out to your home, inspect the property, generate a free quote for the job, then answer any questions you have about the project.
- Once you agree with the price and sign the quote, the representative will schedule an installation date.
- On the day of the installation, a work crew will arrive, remove all the old roofing, install the new roof, then clean the area of all debris and leftover material. The worksite manager will then give the roof a final inspection, go over everything, including the final bill, then answer any final questions you may have.
The Good
Thanks to the multiple contact methods available on its site, Erie makes it extremely easy to get ahold of its team. Even better, customer testimonials indicate that Erie is highly responsive, usually getting back to a homeowner the next day. Customers also note that Erie’s sales and inspection team is top-notch, with most noting their skill and professionalism.
The Bad
We don’t like Erie’s lack of direct pricing information and estimator tool. Without this information, you can be in for a big shock when a salesperson outlines the expected cost of a roof. Another problem with Erie is that it’s highly persistent with phone calls after you send your information, which could frustrate some potential customers.
Is Hiring Erie Metal Roofs Worth Your Money?
We find Erie to be an excellent company to choose for your next metal roofing project. It provides a top-quality product at a reasonable price with stellar customer service. Additionally, its warranty is well above industry standards, offering lifetime protection for both workmanship and labor. While Erie has some issues, namely its lack of variety, its benefits far outweigh these shortcomings.
FAQs About Erie Metal Roofs
Is Erie a Good Roofing Company?
Erie has proven itself to be an excellent roofing company over its nearly 50 years in business. It has an A+ on the BBB with high customer satisfaction ratings across multiple sites, like Facebook, Trustpilot, and Google Reviews.
What Are the Disadvantages of Erie Metal Roofs?
Erie metal roofs have several disadvantages, including the following:
- High cost: Erie’s metal roofs are more expensive than traditional asphalt roofing but last a lot longer.
- Difficult to repair: When shingles are knocked down, it’s a relatively easy fix. Not so for metal roofs, which can be extremely difficult to repair and expensive to replace. Additionally, obtaining replacement shingles will be difficult since they’re proprietary and only available to Erie.
- Noisy: All metal roofs are much noisier in the rain and hail, which can be agitating for some homeowners.
What Are Some of the Benefits of an Erie Metal Roof?
While Erie’s metal roofs have their downsides and are expensive, some of their main benefits include:
- Longevity: Erie’s roofs, on average, last an average of 50 years, two to three times as long as traditional asphalt shingles.
- Durability: Erie’s roofs can better withstand extreme temperatures, impacts, wind, and other environmental hazards compared to asphalt roofs.
- Aesthetically pleasing: Its roofs have unique, high-end looks.
Methodology: How We Ranked Erie Metal Roofs and Other Roofing Brands
At Today’s Homeowner, we strive to bring you the most transparent, accurate information for your home improvement projects. To that end, we have researched the top residential roofing companies so you can choose the right one for your next roof replacement or repair.
Our ratings are based on publicly available information about each company, secret shopping online and over the phone, customer-review analysis, and discussions with experienced roofing installation and repair contractors.
A company can earn a maximum of 100 points across four categories, converted to a five-star scale. We researched and analyzed dozens of residential roofing installers and developed the following formula:
- Services and Products (30 points): We looked at the variety and quality of each company’s services and products when determining this factor’s score. A company’s variety of shingles, repair add-ons, maintenance options, cleaning services, and various other roofing installations (like ventilation systems and insulation) all impacted their score.
- Additional Services (10 points): We compared each company’s on-site services to extras, such as roof inspections, shingle recycling, and debris removal.
- Affordability (25 points): We ranked each company’s total cost for roof installations and shingles replacement compared to the current 2023 national industry average. This included research through company-specific price calculators (when available), obtaining quotes, and using user feedback on listed prices and charges.
- Warranty (20 points): We researched each company’s warranty and graded them according to their type (Workmanship and Material) and length.
- Company Reputation (15 points): Reputation and trustworthiness are essential when evaluating a construction or contracting company. As such, we thoroughly inspected each company’s background, reviews, and industry ratings. This included checking their Better Business Bureau Ranking (BBB), business history, and customer feedback and ratings from Google, Yelp, and other industry-related websites, when applicable.
We monitor company data on an ongoing basis to keep rankings and information up to date.
