When installing a new driveway, homeowners often face the decision of asphalt versus concrete. Both materials have their merits, but choosing between them can be challenging. Factors like climate, budget, maintenance preferences, and design appeal are crucial in making the right decision. In this guide, I’ll discuss the critical differences between asphalt and concrete driveways, to help you determine which one is best for your home.
This site receives compensation from the companies featured in this listing, which may impact where and how products appear. This listing doesn’t feature all companies, products, or offers that may be available.
Key Differences Between Asphalt and Concrete Driveways
There are significant differences between asphalt and concrete driveways. These distinctions impact everything from installation and maintenance to longevity and appearance.
Asphalt Driveways
Asphalt is a black, sticky paving material composed of aggregates and a petroleum-based binder. It’s heated to make it pliable and easy to spread, then hardens as it cools to create a solid surface. Asphalt driveways typically last up to 30 years with proper care.
Pros:
- Budget-friendly
- Easy to install
- Suited for cold climates
Cons:
- Requires regular maintenance
- Limited customization options
Concrete Driveways
Concrete is a highly versatile construction material made from aggregates, cement, and water. Once it’s mixed, the concrete gets poured into forms, spread out, and finished with tints and stains, stamps, or engravings. When properly installed, concrete driveways can last up to 50 years.
Pros:
- Highly durable
- Customizable
- Minimal maintenance needs
Cons:
- Higher upfront costs
- Cracks in freezing temperatures
Durability Comparison: Asphalt vs Concrete
Regarding durability, both asphalt and concrete have strengths and weaknesses. Understanding how each material performs under different conditions helps homeowners make an informed decision.
Compressive Strength
Concrete boasts superior compressive strength — able to withstand 6,000 pounds per square inch (PSI) of pressure, double that of asphalt. Concrete is a solid choice if you frequently park heavy vehicles on your driveway.
Climate Sensitivity
Climate affects how durable your driveway will be. Asphalt is better in colder areas but softens or melts in extreme heat, leading to annoying bumps and ruts. A concrete driveway is more prone to cracking when temperatures drop as moisture expands and contracts. Knowing your local climate helps you choose the best option for your driveway.
Traffic Volume
While concrete can support more weight, asphalt handles high traffic volumes better. Asphalt is preferable for homes with frequent comings and goings or many visitors. Increased traffic on asphalt driveways means you must perform maintenance more frequently.
Maintenance and Repair: Asphalt vs Concrete
Maintenance requirements and repair considerations are different for each driveway material. Each option has its own set of care instructions and repair challenges.
Asphalt Maintenance
Asphalt driveways require more frequent maintenance than concrete. Within a year of installation, apply sealcoating to protect the asphalt surface. Repeat this process every three to five years to protect asphalt from UV rays and extend its lifespan.
Concrete Maintenance
Concrete driveways usually need less maintenance than asphalt. You can apply sealants to keep the finish looking great, but they’re unnecessary. If you use sealant, reapply it every five to ten years.
Repairs
When it comes to repairs, asphalt is easier to fix. Fill small cracks and potholes with sealant or resurface with new asphalt. Concrete repairs involve epoxy injections or overlays, but matching the color perfectly with the existing surface presents a challenge.
Cost Comparison: Asphalt vs Concrete Driveways
When choosing a driveway material, homeowners care about cost. The upfront costs for asphalt and concrete vary quite a bit, so it’s important to consider long-term expenses.
Installation Costs
Asphalt driveways are budget-friendly to install, costing between $6 and $9 per square foot, according to our research. Concrete ranges from $8 to $15 per square foot for basic installation, and customization options increase costs significantly.
Long-term Costs
While asphalt is cheaper initially, it requires more frequent maintenance and has a shorter lifespan. Despite its higher upfront cost, concrete proves economical in the long run due to its durability and lower maintenance needs.
Appearance and Customization Options
The design appeal of a driveway significantly impacts a home’s curb appeal — asphalt and concrete offer distinct looks and varying degrees of customization.
Asphalt Appearance
Asphalt driveways feature a sleek, jet-black surface when newly installed. Over time, they develop a light gray patina, even with regular maintenance. While less versatile than concrete, colored asphalt options provide a unique look.
Concrete Appearance
Concrete driveways can be customized in many ways. With various textures, colors, stamped patterns, and engravings, you can tailor a concrete driveways to perfectly complement your home’s architectural style. This versatility makes concrete an excellent choice for homeowners looking to make a statement with their driveway.
Climate Considerations for Asphalt and Concrete Driveways
Consider your climate when determining the best driveway material for your home. Both asphalt and concrete react differently to weather conditions, affecting their performance and longevity.
Asphalt in Different Climates
Asphalt performs well in colder climates since it’s less prone to cracking from freeze-thaw cycles. Asphalt softens and deforms in extremely hot weather. This makes it less ideal for homes in areas with scorching summers.
Concrete in Different Climates
Concrete is well suited for warmer climates as it doesn’t soften in high temperatures. Concrete is prone to cracking in cold climates, but special additives and proper installation help prevent this issue.
Installation Process: DIY vs Professional
You might be tempted to take on driveway installation as a DIY project, but I recommend leaving asphalt and concrete driveways to the professionals for the best results.
Asphalt Installation
Asphalt installation requires specialized equipment and expertise. The process involves preparing the base, laying and compacting the asphalt, and allowing it to cure. Professional installation produces proper compaction and a smooth, even surface.
Concrete Installation
Concrete driveway installation is equally complex, involving precise mixing, pouring, and finishing techniques. Professionals can provide proper curing and prevent common issues like cracking and uneven settling.
Environmental Impact of Asphalt and Concrete Driveways
As environmental concerns become increasingly important, homeowners should consider the ecological impact of their driveway choice.
Asphalt Environmental Considerations
Asphalt is partially recyclable, which reduces its environmental impact. The petroleum-based composition of asphalt raises concerns about fossil fuel use and the potential for chemicals to leach into the soil.
Concrete Environmental Considerations
Producing concrete has a significant carbon footprint due to the energy-intensive process of creating cement. Concrete’s longevity and potential for incorporating recycled materials help offset these environmental concerns.
Other Factors To Consider
When deciding between asphalt and concrete driveways, local regulations, resale value, and installation time are important considerations.
Local Regulations
Municipalities typically have regulations that impact the type of driveway materials you can use. Some areas have restrictions on the use of asphalt due to its permeability and impact on local water tables. I recommend checking with local zoning and coding authorities before making a decision.
Resale Value
The type of driveway you have impacts a home’s resale value. Well-maintained concrete driveways are considered more upscale and can add to your home’s market value. Asphalt driveways are considered a less expensive alternative but are a strong selling point when maintained.
Installation Time and Seasonality
You can install asphalt driveways quickly and use them almost immediately after installation. Concrete installations take more time to cure properly before usage. Weather conditions also play a role in scheduling your installation. Schedule your asphalt installation in warmer weather. Concrete driveway installation occurs in a broader range of temperatures, provided it doesn’t reach freezing.
Final Thoughts About Asphalt vs Concrete Driveways
Choosing between an asphalt and concrete driveway ultimately depends on your needs, budget, and local climate. Asphalt is more budget-friendly and easier to repair but requires more frequent maintenance. Concrete, while more expensive upfront, provides greater durability and customization and less maintenance over time.
Consider factors like local weather patterns, your desired home design, and long-term costs when making this critical decision. This consideration will help you select the driveway material that best serves your needs and enhances your property for years.
