When it comes to choosing the best window brand for your home, it’s essential to consider all your options carefully. In this comparison, we’ll be exploring two well-known contenders in the world of windows: Simonton and Milgard®.

Both Simonton and Milgard® feature durable and energy-efficient new construction and replacement window brands that help maintain a consistent temperature inside your house, keep the interior cool in the summer, and warm during the winter. Both brands also protect the house against harsh elements, weather, insects, and moisture.

In this article, you’ll find all relevant information about Simonton and Milgard® Windows to help you understand the difference between the two brands. We’re providing you with a comprehensive guide that covers cost, warranty, energy efficiency, and frame materials.

Simonton Windows Overview

Simonton is a brand of high-quality and energy-efficient new construction and replacement windows and door lines. It was founded in 1946 by Fred and Sybil Simonton and is located in Pennsboro, West Virginia.

Simonton Windows is made by Ply Gem, a manufacturer of exterior building products offering windows, doors, siding, railing, stone veneer, and fence products. 

Simonton Windows offer durable and energy-efficient new construction and replacement windows, which are available in nine window styles: Double Hung Windows, Single Hung Windows, Slider Windows, Casement Windows, Awning Windows, Bay Or Bow Windows, Picture Windows, Geometric Windows, and Garden Windows.

Simonton Windows is available in 12 series, namely Simonton Reflections® 5500, Simonton Reflections® 5050, Simonton Asure®, Simonton Impressions®, Simonton StormBreaker Plus®, Simonton ProFinish® Brickmould 600, Simonton ProFinish® Brickmould 300, Simonton ProFinish® Contractor, Simonton ProFinish® Builder, DaylightMax, Madeira, and Verona.

Get Free Window Estimates in 30 Seconds
Connect with trustworthy experts in your area.

The available exterior color choices are Black, Brick, Chocolate, Cream, Driftwood, Pine, Tan, and White, while the available custom woodgrain interior colors are Antique Cherry, Driftwood, Maple, Oak, Tan, and White. They also feature six hardware finish options, including Dark Bronze, Driftwood, Nickel, Oil-rubbed Bronze, Polished Brass, and Tan.

Moreover, Simonton Windows offers four grid styles: 5/8″ Flat, 3/4″ Sculptured, 3/4″ Sculptured Brass, and 1″ Sculptured, with seven available grid patterns, including Colonial, Double Perimeter, Double Prairie, Diamond (Flat Only), Perimeter, Prairie, and Victorian (Flat Only). 

Milgard Windows Overview

Milgard® Windows are manufactured by Milgard Manufacturing, Inc, a company of custom window and door products. The company was founded in 1958 by Maurice Milgard, Jr., and Gary Milgard and is located in Tacoma, Washington.

From our evaluation of Milgard® windows, we have seen that they offer energy-efficient new construction and replacement windows that are available in three window frame materials, including vinyl, fiberglass, and aluminum.

They feature seven window styles: Horizontal Slider Windows, Double Horizontal Slider Windows, Radius Windows, Single Hung Windows,  Double Hung Windows, Casement Windows, Awning Windows, Picture Windows, Bay & Bow Windows, and Specialty Windows. 

Milgard® Windows are available in five window series, namely Tuscany® Series | V400, Trinsic™ Series | V300, Style Line® Series | V250, Ultra™ Series | C650, and Thermally Improved Aluminum | A250.

The available interior colors for both Tuscany® Series | V400 and Style Line® Series | V250 are White and Tan, while the available exterior colors are White and Tan, Sand (Premium), Ivory (Premium), Fog (Premium), Silver (Premium), Classic Brown (Premium), Espresso (Premium), and Bronze (Premium). 

The Trinsic™ Series | V300 features three available interior colors, including White, Tan, and Black (Capstock) with 10 exterior colors: White, Tan, Sand (Painted), Ivory (Painted), Fog (Painted), Silver (Painted), Classic Brown (Painted), Espresso (Painted), Bronze (Painted), and Black (Capstock). 

The Ultra™ Series | C650 offers four interior colors: White, Harmony, Bark, and Black Bea with four exterior colors, including Frost, Harmony, Black Bean, and Bark. For the Thermally Improved Aluminum | A250 Series, the available interior and exterior colors are Clear Anodized and Bronze Anodized.

Grid variations are Flat Grid, Sculptured Grid, Simulated Divided Lite (SDL), and 2-1/4″ Check Rail.

Read Also: Review of Simonton Windows vs Andersen

Simonton vs Milgard: Cost Comparison

The average industry pricing of Simonton Windows ranges from $200 to $1200 per window and $265 to $1,500 per installed window.

Moreover, Simonton Windows provides a free in-home consultation where you can get the most accurate pricing that will fit your budget for your new construction or replacement window project based on your preference and needs.

The exact price of Simonton window products may also vary, depending on the selected window product line, type, and specification. 

The average industry pricing of Milgard® Windows ranges from $170 to $1,890 per window and $325 to $2,650 per installed window.  

To get the best possible price estimate, you can avail it by contacting or requesting a quote from a Milgard® Certified Dealer. Free, no-obligation consultation and different kinds of options available that are suitable for your budget and needs will be provided to you.

Moreover, the most accurate pricing may vary depending on the selected Milgard® Window product’s size, material type, specific color, and decorative grids. 

Read Also: Our Milgard vs Anderson Review

Simonton vs Milgard: Warranty Comparison

Simonton Windows offers a Double-Lifetime Limited Warranty for residential warranty holders and coverage of a 10-Year Limited Warranty for commercial or multi-resident warranty holders.

The Double-Lifetime Limited Warranty is applicable to vinyl components, screens, and hardware. It is also transferable to the succeeding owner by the original warranty holder.

The Lifetime Limited Warranty for commercial or multi-resident warranty holders applies to vinyl components, laminated glass, and hardware glass,  and offers coverage of 3 years for factory-applied exterior coating. The Lifetime Limited Warranty is transferrable within the 10-year warranty period except for the 3-year Factory-Applied Exterior Coating Limited Warranty.

Both the Double-Lifetime Limited Warranty and the Lifetime Limited Warranty include the vinyl and hardware components, screens, and glass products. Moreover, the installation, removal, repair, or labor costs are not included in the warranty coverage.

Milgard offers two main kinds of warranties for the replacement window products available: Full Lifetime Warranty and Lifetime Limited Warranty.

Full Lifetime Warranty applies to Tuscany® Series | V400, and it has Glass Breakage Coverage, and for Trinsic™ Series | V3001, while Lifetime Limited Warranty applies to Style Line® Series | V2502, Ultra™ Series | C650, and Thermally Improved Aluminum | A250.

Moreover, Milgard® Windows offer a 10-year limited warranty applicable to all owners of the covered product.

Simonton vs Milgard: Energy Efficiency Comparison

All window products of Simonton Windows are ENERGY-STAR certified windows, meaning they are high-quality and environmentally-friendly window products. They provide benefits, such as reducing heat transfer and allowing windows to insulate better, making them ideal energy-efficient windows for residential and commercial use.

Simonton Windows also features standard Argon-gas-filled windows with Low-emissivity glass that helps reduce the amount of ultraviolet and infrared light that passes through without inhibiting an ample natural light that enters your house at the same time. Low-E glass also helps regulate and maintain a consistent temperature inside the house.

Moreover, their window product lines offer triple-pane windows with ProSolar Low-E glass and three layers of silver that help improve the insulation properties and prevent the fading of the window materials. It also reduces heating and cooling costs while providing interior warmth and comfort for people.

Milgard® features many components that enhance the energy efficiency of their window products, including glass with dual and triple glazing that helps insulate the interior, reduce energy consumption during winter, and heat during the summer. Their windows also have argon gas between the panes that improve thermal insulation.

SunCoat® and SunCoatMAX® Low-E Glass Coatings are applied to one surface or side of the glass that helps maintain a consistent temperature, improve energy efficiency, and thermal performance of the windows by reflecting heat to the exterior part of the house during summer while keeping the heat inside during the winter. 

Moreover, Milgard® features EdgeGardMAX® Spacers between two panes with a correct distance to provide insulation by stopping the heat flow and reducing condensation on the windows.

Simonton vs Milgard: Frame Materials Comparison

Simonton Windows features engineered windows with four available frame material variations, including vinyl, aluminum-clad wood, aluminum, and wood composite, while Milgard® features three available frame materials for their windows, including fiberglass, vinyl, and aluminum.

Simonton vs Milgard: Final Showdown

Both Simonton and Milgard® Windows provide high-performing and durable energy-efficient new construction and replacement windows. Both brands offer window products at an affordable price that fit the needs and budget of the customer, providing flexibility in having a cost-efficient and convenient replacement window project.

If you prefer high-quality windows with a wide range of frame materials, product lines, and decorative choices, then Simonton is an excellent window brand for you.

Editorial Contributors
avatar for Matt Greenfield

Matt Greenfield

Matt Greenfield is an experienced writer specializing in home improvement topics. He has a passion for educating and empowering homeowners to make informed decisions about their properties. Matt's writing focuses on a range of topics, including windows, flooring, HVAC, and construction materials. With a background in construction and home renovation, Matt is well-versed in the latest trends and techniques in the industry. His articles offer practical advice and expert insights that help readers tackle their home improvement projects with confidence. Whether you're a DIY enthusiast or a seasoned professional, Matt's writing is sure to provide valuable guidance and inspiration.

Learn More