Choosing a roofing company is a big decision that should not be made lightly. No one sets out to hire a subpar roofing company, but distinguishing a top-notch roofing business from a mediocre one is a challenge for many people, especially if they’ve never had work done on their roof before. That’s where we come in. We’ve put together this list of the four best roofing companies of 2023 to help make it easier for you to pick the right one for your roofing needs.
This guide covers our four favorite roofing companies on the basis of cost, availability, and workmanship. It also contains general information and tips for selecting a roofing company, in case none of our picks meet your requirements or you live in an area without access to any of them.
Top 4 Best Roofing Companies of 2023
Here are our four top picks for the best roofing companies of 2023. We selected each of the following companies because they stand out from the rest in terms of value for the price you pay, availability, and customer satisfaction, as determined by customer reviews. Let’s take a closer look at each.
- Aspen Contracting – Best Overall
- CMR Construction & Roofing – Best for Repairs
- Power Home Remodeling Group – Best Design Variety
- Lowe’s – Widest Availability
Aspen Contracting — Best Overall
Our pick for the number one roofing company of 2023 is Aspen Contracting. The company has more than 15 years of experience in the roofing business and has amassed an impressive legion of satisfied customers over that time. Aspen Contracting maintains an impressive A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau (BBB), a sign of its ongoing dedication to providing high-quality roofing services and stellar customer service.
All Aspen’s jobs are handled by a dedicated project consultant who works with you throughout the lifetime of your roofing project. This continuity of care provides unparalleled personalized attention and is a large part of what makes Aspen so successful. The company’s attention to detail and ability to give its customers the attention they deserve are the primary factors that set Aspen apart from its competitors.
Aspen offers a generous lifetime warranty on all its roofs, and Aspen customers have access to tons of upgrades like eco-friendly solar shields and solar-powered vents that save you money in the long run. The company also offers optional impact-resistant shingles, state-of-the-art synthetic underlayers, and additional services for siding and gutters.
The company offers free estimates on its website, so it’s a breeze to get an idea of how much it will cost before you sign a contract. The only negative thing we have to say about Aspen Contracting is that its website desperately needs an upgrade. However, once you get past the aesthetic shortcomings, you can find tons of helpful information.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Lifetime warranty
- Several eco-friendly money-saving options
- Widespread availability
- More than 15 years of experience
- Excellent record of customer satisfaction
Cons
- The company’s website is straight out of the early 2000s
CMR Construction & Roofing — Best for Repairs
CMR Construction & Roofing is a mainstay of the roofing industry, with an excellent track record over more than 20 years in the business. The company has locations in more than half of the country — 32 states as of this writing — and has a streamlined process for scheduling time-sensitive repairs. The company offers regular roofing services — including full roof installations and replacements — but excels at emergency repairs.
The company bills itself as experts in storm damage, and customer reviews support this claim. CMR focuses on providing speedy repairs to any damage caused by natural disasters and storms without overlooking potentially hazardous underlying damage that other, less-experienced companies may overlook. Many reviews mention the impressive speed and efficiency displayed by the CMR team dispatched to repair their roof.
CMR also offers free roof inspections and quotes without any obligation on your part, making it easy to hear what the company has to say before committing.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Experts at assessing and repairing storm damage
- Fast, efficient service
- One representative from end-to-end handles your project
- Tons of roofing materials and designs to choose from
Cons
- Not available in 28 states
- No mention of a warranty on the company’s website
Power Home Remodeling Group — Best Design Variety
The first two companies on our list focus on repairing roof damage and replacing old roofs, essential services, to be sure, but not what you want if you’re looking to remodel your home’s exterior. Enter Power Home Remodeling Group, a roofing contractor that emphasizes design and aesthetics. The company describes itself as a “Dream-Realization” company, and its catalog of roofing services contains an impressive amount of different looks and options to help you craft the home of your dreams.
Unlike many design-first remodeling companies, Power Home Remodeling Group recognizes the importance of offering eco-friendly technology that adds to your home’s curb appeal rather than detracts. To that end, the company uses environmentally-friendly building materials and has experience installing and working with solar panels.
The bottom line is that Power Home Remodeling Group is a great choice for anyone looking to replace their roof for aesthetic reasons. However, if you have damage you need fixed or are looking to replace an old roof, you have better options.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- More design choices than most companies
- Environmentally-conscious options available
- Fast response times and short job times for most work
Cons
- Only 18 locations
- Not the best choice for emergency work
Lowe’s — Best Availability
This might come as a shock to you, but Lowe’s roofing services are quite solid. Choosing a big box store to repair or replace your roof might make you uneasy, but Lowe’s has a surprisingly good track record of satisfied roofing customers. Ultimately, Lowe’s work is above-average, and the company makes our list due to its nearly universal availability, which makes it a viable option for practically everyone.
Some of the advantages of using Lowe’s for roofing work include fast service, scheduling simplicity, and more sophisticated financing options than smaller companies. Lowe’s offers the easiest scheduling of any company on this list, mostly thanks to the infrastructure that comes with running such a large business. Lowe’s considerable weight as a huge corporation also makes it easier for homeowners to finance their roofing work, making it feasible for more people to replace their roofs even on a tight budget.
Unfortunately, there are some downsides to choosing Lowe’s as well. First, Lowe’s doesn’t offer lifetime warranties. Instead, you can expect a one- or two-year warranty on labor, which might make some homeowners uncomfortable. Second, you’re unlikely to deal with the same individual for the length of your project. If personalized attention is important to you, you’re better off going with a smaller company.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Available basically everywhere
- Financing options
Cons
- More restrictive warranties
- You’re more likely to be treated as just another customer
Factors to Consider When Hiring a Roofing Company
If none of these companies are available in your area or if none of them strike your fancy, here are some general tips that apply to hiring any roofing company.
Consultations
Before you become a customer, you’ll need to schedule a consultation. Most companies are happy to give you a free assessment and price quote, so be wary of any that want to charge you for an inspection. Most roofing companies let you schedule a consultation for free on the company website or over the phone.
Service Area
Depending on where you live, you may not have many choices when selecting a roofing company. Most companies will simply reject your request for a quote if you live outside their service area, although calling ahead of time is still a good idea since it will save you the hassle of filling out a form or dialing a phone number for no reason.
Additional Service Options
Most roofing companies also offer services for siding, gutters, and other exterior work. If you need more work done on other areas of your home, consider looking for a company that will do it all since having all of the work done by the same company is convenient.
Financing
Roofing companies are keenly aware that roofing services are expensive, and many offer financing to help homeowners on a budget. In general, larger companies offer better financing deals, so consider going with a big company like Lowe’s if financing is important to you.
Warranties: Labor & Parts
The best roofing companies offer comprehensive warranties that cover both labor and materials. A good manufacturer’s warranty indicates that the company stands behind its work and is confident in the roofs they install and repair. On the other hand, a limited or short-term warranty can be indicative of lower-quality work.
Cost to Hire One of the Best Roofing Companies
There’s no way around it: hiring one of the best roofers will cost you more than hiring an average one. However, paying the price upfront by hiring an experienced roofing company may be less expensive in the long run since you won’t need to worry about re-roofing as frequently.
Pricing for roofing work varies significantly depending on where you live and what kind of work you need. The best advice we can give you is to get estimates from as many local companies as possible before you choose one. However, the national average cost of a roof replacement is around $10,000, and getting a new roof installed instead of replacing your current roof can easily cost over $20,000.
Roofing Costs by Type
The material a roof is made from greatly affects the price. Here are some estimates based on national averages for common types of roofing:
- Asphalt shingles: $5,000
- Concrete tiles: $10,000
- Clay tiles: $18,000
- Slate: $18,000
- Metal roofing: $40,000
- Solar Shingles: $60,000+
The above estimates are based on a 1,800-square foot roof.
Advantages of Using One of the Best Roofing Companies
To put it simply, roofing is one of the sectors where you get what you pay for. Hiring one of the best roofing companies to work on your roof affords you many advantages, but the most important one is quality. The best companies have the most experienced and skilled workers, meaning you’re less likely to need future visits to repair shoddy work. It’s not a coincidence that the best roofing companies tend to offer lifetime warranties. If you hire a roofing company that doesn’t offer a reasonable warranty on its work, consider purchasing a home warranty that includes roofing.
Besides the quality of the work, the best roofing companies are also more reliable, which means you won’t have to deal with unexpected delays or drawn-out project timelines. You’ll also have more direct access to the people in charge of your project, usually through a dedicated project manager.
Overall, hiring one of the best roofing companies gives you access to higher quality materials — like GAF shingles — and labor, which means a higher cost now in exchange for fewer roofing issues in the future.
How to Find a Reputable Roofer
The easiest way to find a reputable roofer is to get a recommendation from a trusted friend, family member, or neighbor. This method is the most reliable since you know that you’re getting a genuine recommendation from someone who has experience working with the company.
If you don’t know anyone who had work done on their roof recently, your best bet is to read as many reviews of roofing companies as possible and schedule tons of free assessments. You can often get a sense of how easy a company will be to work with from how its staff treats potential customers.
You can also consider asking any home improvement contractors you’ve hired in the past since they may know a reputable roofer if they don’t do roofing work themselves.
Residential vs. Commercial Roofing Companies
Make sure to hire the right roofing company for your needs. Many roofing companies provide both residential and commercial roofing services, but not all of them. While there are similarities between residential and commercial roofing, choosing a company that focuses on residential roofing is the right choice for people who own single-family homes.
Key Takeaways
Our top recommendation is to go with either Aspen Contracting or CMR Construction & Roofing, depending on what kind of work you need. Aspen Contracting is your best bet if your roof is just getting old since the company excels at routine roof replacements due to ordinary wear and tear. CMR Construction & Roofing would be the better choice if your roof was damaged during a storm or natural disaster. The company specializes in fast, efficient roof repairs and has tons of experience assessing storm damage.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you know when to replace your roof?
The most common signs that you need to replace your roof are leaks, shingle damage like missing shingles or peeling shingles, noticeable sagging anywhere across your roof, and extensive fungal growth. Most asphalt shingle roofs need to be replaced as they age, with the average lifespan being around 20–25 years.
How long does it take a roofing company to replace your roof?
The best roofing companies only take 3 to 5 days to replace a roof once work begins. Scheduling the project usually takes longer and depends on how busy the company is. Larger roofs take longer, but it shouldn’t take more than five days unless your roof is greater than 2,000 square feet.
What is the largest roofing company in the U.S.?
Centimark Corporation, based in Pennsylvania, is the largest commercial roofing contractor in the U.S., with an estimated 3500 employees.
Who owns the best roofing company?
In our opinion, the best roofing company is Aspen Contracting. The company is run by the president and CEO Pat Nussbeck.
Today's Homeowner Roofing Methodology (Roofing Type)
Arranging for a home repair of this scale is going to be a fairly involved project. If you haven’t conducted renovations like this – either via a contractor or on your own – then it can be a bit overwhelming. At Today's Homeowner, we pride ourselves on being able to take all of the guesswork out of the equation for you.
We’ve thoroughly evaluated each roofing type to make your selection process easier. Through exhaustive research into hundreds of different roofing providers throughout the United States and analyses of thousands of individual homeowner experiences, we’ve broken our roof rating system down into the following categories.
All roofs receive an aggregate rating between (0.0) and (1.0). This rating is comprised of six key evaluation criteria, which we’ve outlined below. The rating between (0.0) and (1.0) will correspond to a secondary rating out of five stars, which is displayed more visibly in our articles across this category.
- Durability (.40): With roofs being constantly exposed to the elements, different materials’ relative durability is a key metric that must be considered. If you’re planning on conducting such an extensive upgrade to your home, then your roof’s expected lifespan should be among your primary concerns. We’ve weighed the relative effectiveness of all roofing materials, from asphalt shingles to corrugated metal roofing from different manufacturers in order to determine the most long-lasting options.
- Cost (.25):The nationwide average cost for replacing a 1,500-square-foot roof falls between $6,500 and $16,000. Across the board, you should expect to pay between $4 and $11 per square foot of roofing material. This range will account for your location, material choice and availability, ease of access to and installation of your roof, and far more.
- Contractor Availability (.13): Different roofing contractors in different locales will have varied service offerings. For example, not all roofers are equipped with the requisite skillset and knowledge to install metal roofing. Depending on the kind of roof you want to have installed, your contractor options may be somewhat limited.
- Warranty Offerings (.12): Aside from workmanship warranties, many roofing manufacturers will offer warranties for the panels themselves. Structural failure should be covered by any manufacturing firm for at least 10 years after the installation has been completed, at the panel or shingle’s full value. We grade each roofing type by standard warranty offerings to ensure that you’re covered in this case.
- Ease of Future Maintenance and Upgrades (.05): You should always have contingency plans after any home upgrade. Maintenance is inevitable, no matter the material you use. Whether you’re installing solar panels on a functional existing roof, or are simply replacing a defective panel or shingle, certain materials will be easier to work with than others. Typically, less durable materials will score higher in this category due to their better pliability and workability.
- Customization Options (.05): Any exterior and visible home upgrade is going to have an aesthetic element, aside from functionality. A roof replacement should be an upgrade to the curb appeal of your home. Different types of roofing materials will have varying numbers of style and color options, which factor into our rating.
