CertainTeed Shingles Review: A Century of Reputation
March 26, 2024
Top 8 Best Roofing Companies (2024 Review)
Finding reputable professionals to work on your home can be an exhausting, stressful affair. That's doubly true of roofing companies since a new roof is one of the largest expenses a homeowner will ever incur.
As a professional roofer, I’ve seen the good and the bad in this industry. In this article, I'll review eight top companies and give you my take on their services. Hopefully, in doing so, I can take some of the stress out of the process for you.
If you want to cut to the chase and get started right away, take a look at these three of my top 8 roofing companies to get a quote today:
Top Pick
4.1
Specialized metal shingles
Service area spans dozens of states
Provides first-time roof installation & military discounts
Limited Time:
Zero Down - 18 months same as cash with minimum monthly payment
Best Asphalt Shingles
3.9
Thousands of 5-star reviews
Phone, email, & text consultations
Factory-trained installers
Limited Time:
Get 10% Off Your Roofing Project
Best Quality Shingles
3.7
Top-quality shingles
Provides windows & solar system services
Quick, thorough installations
Limited Time:
No current offers available.
What Are the Top-Rated Companies for Roofing Installation?
The following eight companies are my top-rated companies:
Erie Home: Best Metal Roof Installer
DaBella: Best Asphalt Shingle Installer
One Day: Best Quality Shingles
Power Home: Best Customer Service
Contractor Appointments: Most Partners
Thompson Creek: Best Additional Services
Capital Construction: Best Reviewed
Long Home Products: Best Incentives
Compare The Best Roofing Companies
I’ve compiled a chart to give you a brief overview of the important points for each roofing company.
Company | Our Rating | BBB Rating | Roof Types | Warranty | States Served |
 | A+ | Metal | Lifetime | 35 states | |
 | A+ | Asphalt, tile | Two-year | 17 states | |
 | A+ | Asphalt | Varies | 18 states | |
 | A+ | Asphalt shingle, architectural | Lifetime | 15 states | |
 | Not Rated | Varies | Varies | 50 states | |
 | Not Rated | Asphalt | 50-year | 4 states | |
 | A+ | Asphalt, Wood Shake, Slate, Synthetic | 5-year; 10-year extended | Chicago, IL | |
 | A+ | Asphalt, Metal, Flat | 50-year | 11 states |
Best Metal Roof Installer
Erie Home
4.1
Our Rating
Not many companies do metal shingles. Erie Home not only specializes in it, but it controls virtually every stop in the supply chain to ensure the quality and integrity of its final product. I deem it the best in metal roofing for that reason. Having oversight of the entire process, from manufacturing materials to installation on a customer's roof, is extremely unusual in the industry and allows Erie Home to deliver a quality, professional product.
Responsive communication.
The sales and inspection team is professional.
Availability across dozens of states.
Lacks pricing information.
No cost estimation tool.
Erie offers a variety of home remodeling services. Unique to companies in this list, it offers patio services.
- Roofing
- Windows
- Siding
Erie Home is my top choice for metal shingles. Its years of experience and integrated supply chain are strong arguments for its products and services. Metal roofing is a fairly recent invention that differs from traditional roofing systems. So, having a professional company with verifiable experience installing them is an asset to any homeowner considering a metal roof.
If you want to know more about Erie Home and why they’re so highly rated, read our full review here.
Best Asphalt Shingles
DaBella
3.9
Our Rating
DaBella is a family-oriented company founded in 2011 that has exploded across the nation. With 15,000 five-star reviews and a variety of awards, it's hard to argue with the success they've had. Named after the founder's twin children, David and Isabella, they bring a family-conscious mentality to the table.
In an industry not known for being tech-savvy, DaBella has a great website that's intuitive and easy to navigate. It does consultation over the phone, email, or text. It offers financing and employs factory-trained installers. This technology-based approach to customer service allows flexibility is a blessing for a busy family.
Offers deals on their services
Multiple ways to communicate (talk, text, email)
Factory-trained installers
Only a two-year labor warranty
Best Quality Shingles
One Day
3.7
Our Rating
One Day is a roofing and remodeling company based in Columbia, Maryland, with satellite offices in 18 states. It specializes in roofing, windows, gutters, trim, and siding. As the name suggests, they aim to complete jobs quickly – even as fast as one day. In an industry where jobs can often drag out, this is a huge benefit.
I find that the company offers high-quality asphalt shingles, most of which I'm familiar with and know are well-regarded amongst roofers and customers alike.
However, the company’s website is very low on roofing information. Basic information like warranty, types of roofs, and services offered was almost non-existent. As well, the estimation tool was broken. Links to satellite offices didn't provide any additional information, and phone calls aren’t always returned.
Offers industry-leading, top-quality shingles.
The website lacks information.
Unresponsive.
One Day offers a fairly narrow set of services.
- Roofing
- Windows
- Solar
Best Customer Service
Power Home
4.0
Our Rating
Power Home is the largest residential re-roofer in the United States and the third largest home remodeling firm. With 2,700 employees, they serve customers in 15 states, from Connecticut to Colorado and numerous states in between. Power Home is one of the most impressive companies I've reviewed so far. It has every mark of a quality company: a 30-year track record, lifetime labor, and material warranties, strong reviews, and more. Information about warranties and licensing is all up-front and readily available. Unlike some of the companies I've reviewed, Power Home seems eager to share information and make an argument, not just for the quality of its work but its quality as a company. I struggled to find anything to criticize about them.
Well-documented licensing and warranties
Great website with lots of relevant information
Supports the employment of veterans
Strong customer reviews
Little to no information about the materials and products used
Power Home provides a limited but standard array of home services.
- Roofing
- Windows
- Siding
- Doors
- Attic Insulation
I like Power Home. Not only does it have great reviews, but its website is informative and thorough, leaving prospective customers with very few questions about its products, services, and company culture.
Most Partners
Contractor Appointments
N/A
Our Rating
Contractor Appointments is an aggregate service provider that helps homeowners find reputable professionals in their area. Based in Minnesota, they generate leads, which they then provide to independent construction contractors who follow up with the client.
This company is a mixed bag. On the plus side, no matter what type of job you need to be done, there’s a good chance that Contractor Appointments has a partner that can help you out.
The company also appears to work with partners who charge reasonable prices. Contractor Appointments lists the average price per square foot for a new roof, and it falls right in line with fair market prices in my experience. That kind of transparency is certainly commendable. I also appreciate that they focus strictly on sales and appointments and let the professionals do the work. However, I don't like that most information on the website is kept behind a "fill out this form" wall. It feels like an unnecessary and aggressive sales tactic.
Because Contractor Appointments directs you to other roofing companies, I was unable to assign a score.
Good online estimation tool.
Provides comparisons of contractors.
Sometimes uses aggressive sales tactics.
Information is gated behind giving them your personal information.
Contractor Appoints doesn’t have many services, but I give them bonus points for doing roof repairs.
- Roofing
- Windows
- Solar
- Repair
I think this is another solid company. There are some things to like and some things to dislike, but all things considered, I feel it's worth consideration.
Best Additional Services
Thompson Creek
3.9
Our Rating
Thompson Creek is a home remodeling company serving the Mid-Atlantic region. Since 1980, it has built a well-respected brand with many prior customers and advocates. They offer a range of services across all exterior remodeling and some internal remodeling, like baths.
This company is another favorite of mine, not least of all because of their transferable warranty. If you buy or sell a home that Thompson Creek has worked on, the warranty on their work goes with it. It's a small thing, but caring about the small details is what a great company does. Beyond that, my experience with them was great. They have friendly service, a solid website, financing, and numerous additional services. It's a really solid company all the way around.
Informative website
In-house financing
50-year transferable labor warranty
Limited service area
Won’t quote price information without inspecting the roof.
Thompson Creek provides a wide array of home remodeling services.
- Roofing
- Windows
- Siding
- Doors
- Gutters
- Baths
Thompson Creek is a great company. Its transferable labor warranty is an industry exception, making it stand out from its competition. Beyond that, I found all other aspects to be good or above average. I'd be happy to hire them to work in my own home.
Best Reviewed
Capital Construction
4.1
Our Rating
Capital Construction is a smaller company operating in Chicago and the surrounding suburbs. It does roofing and exterior work, including storm damage remediation and general insurance claims.
All-in-all, Capital Construction is a solid company. It's an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor with outstanding reviews from customers. I appreciate most that it does a variety of roofing types, whereas many of these companies only do a select few. Its labor warranty is the weakest point at only five years (or 10, with an extended warranty), but it's offset by very few complaints and a long-time A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau.
Owen Corning Preferred Contractor
Does storm damage remediation
Free inspections
Limited information on the web
Limited to the Chicago area
Capital Construction doesn’t provide a wide variety of home remodeling services, but I think that’s offset by doing remediation and insurance claims.
- Roofing
- Siding
- Gutters
- Storm damage remediation
- Insurance claims work
Capital Construction is not a bad choice by any means. It’s certainly disadvantaged by only being in the Chicago area, but its service itself is on par with professional expectations and customer reviews affirm that.
Best Incentives
Long Home Products
4.0
Our Rating
Started in 1945 as a fencing company in Washington, D.C, Long Home Products has expanded into a multifaceted business serving residential remodeling needs across the East Coast, including roofing. It provides numerous incentives and services to accommodate the gamut of homeowner needs.
Long Home Products is another great company on this list. It has good reviews, many awards, and decades in the business to show for it. Companies with histories as old as Long Home Products are hard to argue with. It's a testament to competence and professionalism. I like, specifically, that it's the only company on my list to offer flat roofing services. While flat roofs are rare for residential homes, some do exist, and for those homeowners having access to quality professionals is essential. I'm happy to see Long Home Products serving those people.
Company with a proven track record
Numerous industry awards
Offer flat roofing services
Limited to the East Coast
- Roofing
- Windows
- Doors
- Baths
I would hire Long Home Products if it were in my area. Everything about it speaks to its decades of experience in the business and the quality of its services. The accumulated trade and business knowledge acquired over that many decades is an asset to customers. They're a strong pick in my book.
What Types of Roofing Do Top Companies Offer?
Below I’ve compiled a table of all the roofing options offered by the top 8 companies.
| Type of Roofing | Erie Home | DaBella | One Day | Contractor Appointments | Power Home | Thompson Creek | Capital Construction | Long Home Products |
| Asphalt | X | X | X | X | X | X | X | |
| Metal | X | X | ||||||
| Solar | X | X | ||||||
| Slate | X | |||||||
| Clay tile | X | |||||||
| Wood shake | X | |||||||
| Rolled (flat) | X |
Capital Construction and Long Home Products offer the most types of roofs, and you can read more about them in our article on roofing types.
Top Pick
4.1
Specialized metal shingles
Service area spans dozens of states
Provides first-time roof installation & military discounts
Limited Time:
Zero Down - 18 months same as cash with minimum monthly payment
Best Asphalt Shingles
3.9
Thousands of 5-star reviews
Phone, email, & text consultations
Factory-trained installers
Limited Time:
Get 10% Off Your Roofing Project
Best Quality Shingles
3.7
Top-quality shingles
Provides windows & solar system services
Quick, thorough installations
Limited Time:
No current offers available.
What Should You Consider When Choosing a Good Roofing Company?
A good roofing company will be an experienced contractor with a reputation to prove it, and the best way to find a quality professional is by recommendation. The most valuable recommendations are from people you know who've had work done by that company or even worked at the company. They'll give you candid, unfiltered feedback you can't get anywhere else.
The next step is to ensure that they have all the proper licensing and insurance required by law. These laws vary from state to state, but every state should have online tools to look up licensing.
You should always request proof of insurance from the contractor directly.
Lastly, and perhaps this is a personal preference, a portfolio of work is a must. Any company that stands by its products and workmanship should happily oblige a prospective customer and provide proof of their work.
How Should You Prepare Your Home for Roofing Installation?
Nothing needs to be done to prepare the house for a new roof, but you can do a few other things to help the situation.
First, tidy up the property. Not only will this allow the workers to easily move equipment and material in and out, it'll allow you to see that they've properly cleaned up all debris when the job is finished.
Today's Homeowner Tips
Be sure to mow the lawn. Nails get everywhere when roofing, especially tearing off. A short lawn makes it easier to spot and remove them before they end up in someone’s foot. The roofing company should take care of it, but they’re only human, and a single nail is easy to miss. Double-check when they’re done.
Second, organize a different place to park other than the driveway. There's lots of heavy and tedious material and equipment that needs to get to a roof, so the closer a roofer can get to the house, the easier and quicker they can get it all sorted.
Third, turn off any automatic watering systems and house alarms that might get tripped. Keep pets indoors or in a secluded area away from workers and the work area (as much for their safety as the roofers.)
How Can You Save Money When Hiring the Top Roofing Companies?
There are a few strategies to save money on a roof, but the best is getting multiple quotes. It's the best way to ensure you're not being taken advantage of by an unscrupulous company. Note that the lowest bid isn't necessarily the best when shopping around. Rather, try to average them out. The middle-of-the-road price is ideal. Companies that bid low put their workers under the gun to complete the installation within budget. Too often, that leads to rushed, sub-par work.
Another similar, often overlooked point is you should do the same with lenders. If you're not paying out-of-pocket, shop around. Get quotes from multiple lenders, and be aware that different types of loans might cover your needs. One I rarely see mentioned is a Federal Housing Administration (FHA) Title I loan. Not everyone qualifies for an FHA loan, but it's worth keeping in mind.
Read More Roofing Company Reviews
DIY Vs. Professional Roofing Installation: Which Is Better?
This is a tough question. A homeowner can install a roof, but it's a big project and can get complicated quickly (especially for complex roofs.) It requires a lot of research and study to be confident in what you're doing, but it's not beyond reach.
Today's Homeowner Tips
If you decide to undertake a roofing project yourself, be sure to familiarize yourself with proper roof and ladder safety. Even falls from a single-story roof can cause major injuries.
That said, I still say a roof install is better left to professionals. It's dangerous and labor intensive, and incorrect installation can lead to a host of issues. Moreover, manufacturer warranties are only valid if they're installed according to manufacturer requirements, which is another thing that can trip up a do-it-yourselfer. Accidentally voiding the warranty on your roof could become a costly mistake if you ever need that warranty. I generally encourage people to learn the basics of trade skills and tackle a few projects around the house (it can be very rewarding and save you money). Still, in this case, I would only do it if you're confident in your knowledge and skills.
So, What Is the Best Roofing Company?
I can't choose a single company, but I can choose three: Power Home, Thompson Creek, and Long Home Products. I was thoroughly impressed by all three of them. As a professional roofer and carpenter, I admit to being biased against these big, regional companies. However, despite my scrutiny, I can't find anything bad to say about them. They offer great services; they ensure their work with robust warranties. Most importantly, their customers are happy. There isn't a better argument for a company.
Top Pick
4.1
Specialized metal shingles
Service area spans dozens of states
Provides first-time roof installation & military discounts
Limited Time:
Zero Down - 18 months same as cash with minimum monthly payment
Best Asphalt Shingles
3.9
Thousands of 5-star reviews
Phone, email, & text consultations
Factory-trained installers
Limited Time:
Get 10% Off Your Roofing Project
Best Quality Shingles
3.7
Top-quality shingles
Provides windows & solar system services
Quick, thorough installations
Limited Time:
No current offers available.
FAQs About the Top Rated Roofing Companies
Which type of roofing is best?
The best type depends on your specific needs. All roofs protect a home equally well but come at different up-front costs, lifespans, and styles. The best one is the one that fits your budget and provides for any specific needs you have.
What are some benefits of having a new roof?
The biggest benefit is security and certainty in your roof and the protection it provides your home. Another major benefit is it increases the valuation of your house.
What is the most common type of roofing material?
It varies — for example, clay tile is very popular in the Southwest — but for North America as a whole, asphalt shingles are the most common.
What is the difference between slate and tile roofing?
Slate is a stone, whereas tile is made from baked clay. They both make for very durable, long lasting roofs.
What is the most durable roofing?
In terms of longevity, slate is the most durable. It can last up to 100 years or more, depending on care and environmental conditions. The most durable in terms of ability to resist damage is clay or concrete tile. Both types don’t dent, deform, or wear. They can break or chip under sufficient force, but it’s not common for that to happen once they’re installed on a roof.
Methodology: How We Ranked the Best Roofing Companies
At Today’s Homeowner, we strive to bring you the most transparent, accurate information for your home improvement projects. To that end, we have researched the top residential roofing companies so you can choose the right one for your next roof replacement or repair.
Our ratings are based on publicly available information about each company, secret shopping online and over the phone, customer-review analysis, and discussions with experienced roofing installation and repair contractors.
A company can earn a maximum of 100 points across four categories, converted to a five-star scale. We researched and analyzed dozens of residential roofing installers and developed the following formula:
- Services and Products (30 points): We looked at the variety and quality of each company’s services and products when determining this factor’s score. A company’s variety of shingles, repair add-ons, maintenance options, cleaning services, and various other roofing installations (like ventilation systems and insulation) all impacted their score.
- Additional Services (10 points): We compared each company’s on-site services to extras, such as roof inspections, shingle recycling, and debris removal.
- Affordability (25 points): We ranked each company’s total cost for roof installations and shingles replacement compared to the current 2024 national industry average. This included research through company-specific price calculators (when available), obtaining quotes, and using user feedback on listed prices and charges.
- Warranty (20 points): We researched each company’s warranty and graded them according to their type (Workmanship and Material) and length.
- Company Reputation (15 points): Reputation and trustworthiness are essential when evaluating a construction or contracting company. As such, we thoroughly inspected each company’s background, reviews, and industry ratings. This included checking their Better Business Bureau Ranking (BBB), business history, and customer feedback and ratings from Google, Yelp, and other industry-related websites, when applicable.
We monitor company data on an ongoing basis to keep rankings and information up to date.
Latest Content About Roofing Company Reviews
5 Excellent Alternatives to GAF Roof Underlayment
April 22, 2024
Champion Roofing Overview: Everything You Need to Know
March 15, 2024
Brava Roof Tile – Manufacturer Spotlight
January 24, 2024
Manufacturer Spotlight: Castagra
January 24, 2024
Erie Home Review and Buying Guide
March 15, 2024
Tamko vs GAF: Which Roof Shingle Brand Is Better?
December 14, 2023
Meet the Contributors
Browse Roofing Companies in Major Markets