Expert Advice On Improving Your Home

10 Best Pest Control Companies in West Islip, NY

Get matched with a top local pro.
Join more than 640 people who have gotten a free quote in the past week.

Written By David Cusick

Last Updated April 2024

West Islip’s plentiful rainfall and warm summers mean residents deal with a variety of pest problems, including rats and wasps. Setting up routine pest control with a good company can reduce your encounters with these pests in the future.

There are many great exterminator options, so the team at Today's Homeowner has done the research and made a list of some of the best pest control companies in West Islip to help you make the right choice. Keep reading to discover the top providers near you.

Our Recommended Providers

Top Pick
4.8/5
  • Covers 13 common pests in general plan
  • Offers wildlife removal
  • Extra treatments as needed at no extra cost
Comprehensive Service
4.7/5
  • Pest control guarantee
  • Treats over 15 common pests
  • Offers instant online quotes

Top 10 Best Pest Control Companies in West Islip

Terminix

Terminix Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
45 S Service Rd, Plainview, NY 11803 (505) 449-1724 terminix.com

Commitment to customer education

Transparent pricing

No-cost inspections

Reviews praise customer service

Preventative pest control services

Services Offered

Ants
Bed bugs
General pest control
Silverfish
Spiders
Wasps
Cockroaches
Termites
Flies
Moths
Baiting
Wildlife
Garden protection
Mosquitos
Mice
Green pest control
Bees
Ticks
Prevention

Orkin

Orkin Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
75 Nassau Terminal Rd, New Hyde Park, NY 11040 (917) 717-7159 orkin.com

Transparent pricing

No-cost inspections

Consistently high customer service reviews

Helpful homeowner content on its website

Services Offered

Fumigation
Silverfish
Wasps
Bees
Flies
Wildlife
Ticks
Ants
Termites
Prevention
Cockroaches
Mosquitos
Baiting
Mice
Bed bugs
Beetles
General pest control
Spiders

Arrow Exterminating Company, Inc.

Arrow Exterminating Company, Inc. Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
1512 Sunrise Hwy South Service Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706 (516) 537-9436 arrowexterminating.com

No-cost inspections

Reviews praise customer service

Offerings of preventative treatments

Lack of hidden fees

Educational web content

Punctuality

Services Offered

Bees
Ants
Mosquitos
Wildlife
Beetles
Wasps
Prevention
Termites
Flies
Ticks
General pest control
Bed bugs
Mice
Cockroaches
Spiders
Fleas

Fox Pest Control - Long Island

Fox Pest Control - Long Island Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
66 S 2nd St Unit D, Bay Shore, NY 11706 (631) 206-5787 fox-pest.com

Continuous highly praised customer service reports

No-cost inspections

Transparent pricing

Helpful homeowner content on its website

Services Offered

Ticks
Mice
Wasps
Prevention
Bed bugs
Spiders
Termites
Mosquitos
General pest control
Silverfish
Fleas
Ants
Cockroaches
Beetles
Bees

Majestic Pest Control of Melville

Majestic Pest Control of Melville Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
785 Walt Whitman Rd, Melville, NY 11747 (516) 715-2896 majesticpestcontrol.com

Helpful homeowner content on its website

Transparent pricing

Positive customer service reviews

Proactive approach to pest control

Free inspection policy

Services Offered

Green pest control
General pest control
Mice
Flies
Bed bugs
Bees
Mosquitos
Termites
Baiting
Spiders
Ants
Cockroaches
Wasps
Prevention

Suburban Exterminating

Suburban Exterminating Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
879 W Jericho Turnpike, Smithtown, NY 11787 (631) 864-6900 suburbanexterminating.com

Commitment to customer education

Punctuality

Reviews praise customer service

Free inspection policy

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Mice
Spiders
Wildlife
Termites
Flies
Bed bugs
Prevention
Mosquitos
Cockroaches
Wasps
Beetles
Ants
Ticks
Green pest control
Bees
General pest control
Fleas

JP McHale Pest Management

JP McHale Pest Management Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
30 Pond Rd, Oakdale, NY 11769 (631) 287-5551 nopests.com

Free inspection policy

Educational web content

Proactive approach to pest control

Consistently high customer service reviews

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Spiders
Wildlife
Termites
Mosquitos
Prevention
Baiting
Cockroaches
General pest control
Ants
Ticks
Green pest control
Mice

proof. Pest Control

proof. Pest Control Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
1016 Grand Blvd Unit 1, Deer Park, NY 11729 (631) 935-0450 proofpest.com

Free inspections

Reviews praise customer service

Commitment to customer education

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Bed bugs
General pest control
Spiders
Fleas
Termites
Ants
Mice
Cockroaches
Green pest control
Garden protection
Ticks
Mosquitos

At Last Pest Control

At Last Pest Control Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
496 Sunrise Hwy, West Babylon, NY 11704 (631) 933-1136 atlastpestcontrol.com

Reliable appointment windows

Reviews praise customer service

Commitment to customer education

Free inspection policy

Lack of hidden fees

Services Offered

Mice
Spiders
Bees
Green pest control
General pest control
Silverfish
Wildlife
Cockroaches
Wasps
Ants
Termites
Bed bugs
Moths

National Pest Experts

National Pest Experts Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
330 Conklin St, Farmingdale, NY 11735 (516) 937-0200 nationalpestexperts.com

Free inspection policy

Positive customer service reviews

Punctuality

Lack of hidden fees

Services Offered

Beetles
Mosquitos
Spiders
Ants
General pest control
Mice
Cockroaches
Wasps
Bed bugs
Wildlife
Fleas
Today's Homeowner Ranking Methodology

Today's Homeowner looks at dozens of datapoints on pest control companies to come up with our data-driven rankings. It's not possible for a company to pay for preferential treatment in our rankings. We look at the following key factors in determining who should top our list:

  • Company Experience
  • Real User Reviews
  • Company Reputation
  • Accreditations and Licenses
  • Service Area
  • Customer Service
Have questions about our methodology or company ratings? Reach out to FindAPro@TodaysHomeowner.com.

Top Pest Control Brands in West Islip

Today's Homeowner narrowed it down to these pest control companies by comparing costs, state availability, pest control treatments offered, contracts, customer reviews, and more.

This is how the top pest control companies ranked in West Islip:

Terminix

Terminix ranks in the top four pest control companies in the world, and it has been assisting homeowners with staying pest-free for over 90 years. The company offers professional pest control treatments that are safe for your family.

Terminix can help you with all types of pest issues for homeowners and business owners. These include raccoons, roaches, spiders, ants, opossums, rodents, and termites. Along with pest control, Terminix offers other services, including mechanical exclusion, home disinfection services, moisture control, and attic insulation.

Orkin

Started in 1901 by a rat poison salesman named Otto, the Orkin brand has become one of the most trustworthy in the pest control industry. It has excellent consumer reviews and trained exterminators who all complete 160 hours of training.

Orkin offers an expert property inspection to identify problem pests and areas and draw up an appropriate treatment plan. After the initial treatment, your Orkin expert will follow up to check that the pests haven’t come back. If they have, your local technicians can help.

Rentokil

Founded in 1925, Rentokil has close to 100 years’ worth of experience exterminating pests. The global brand owns the North American pest control companies Western Exterminator, J.C. Ehrlich, and Presto-X.

Rentokil and its partners handle the following pests: bees, bed bugs, ants, cockroaches, wasps, spiders, mosquitoes, moths, flies, and crickets. Rentokil’s treatments are child- and pet-friendly.

How To Choose a Pest Control Company

Pest control providers aren't all the same when it comes to reputation, expertise, and capability. It’s important to research businesses to find the right one for your specific circumstance. Here are the key factors to consider when choosing a pest control provider:

Services Offered

You should choose a pest control company that has expertise handling your specific problem, whether it's bed bugs, termites, roaches, rodents, or something else. The company should clearly describe on their website its expertise with your specific pest.

Expertise

Look for pest control companies that employ technicians with certifications in pest control methods from qualified industry groups, such as the National Pest Management Association (NPMA), in addition to state licensing. Holding the proper credentials indicates that the technicians have received adequate training. Also ask about ongoing educational requirements.

Experience and Reputation

Look through reviews on Google, Yelp, and similar sites prior to scheduling a pest control appointment. Confirm through customer feedback that the company reliably provides effective service and a positive customer experience. Also check the Better Business Bureau website for any complaints that have been filed. Ask whether technicians receive continuing regular education on the newest and most advanced pest control treatments. When you select an exterminator from our list of West Islip's best pest control, you can feel confident knowing that you're hiring an expert that meets our quality and review standards.

Green Pest Control

Homeowners who want natural, eco-friendly pest control should look for providers that specialize in “green” certified solutions. You can also ask about trapping options that don't harm larger pests like mice or other burrowing rodents. However, natural options may be less effective for serious infestations, and if you’re dealing with a major pest problem you may need stronger traditional methods. Regardless of what methods you choose, any pesticides that are classified as greater than minimal risk are required to be registered with the EPA.

Reservice Guarantee

Leading pest control professionals usually offer service guarantees for ongoing plans. The guarantees mean if pests remain after the initial treatment, the company will come back and re-treat your home at no cost until the infestation is eliminated. One-time treatments may not come with reservice guarantees.

Questions To Ask Pest Control Companies

Once you have narrowed down your top pest control providers, reach out to each one to ask questions such as:

  • Can you provide detailed pricing information and service plan in writing upfront? This allows you to evaluate exterminator pricing and avoid companies that have ambiguous terms and conditions or tack on hidden fees.
  • How frequently will you need to service my property once the initial treatment is complete? Most companies offer monthly, quarterly, or yearly service plans to check for reinfestations.
  • What pest control procedures and approaches do you use? Ensure that the methods match your preferences for more standard treatment plans versus eco-friendly options. Ask the company for details about what chemicals it plans to apply.
  • When can you start treating my home? It's important to begin treatment ASAP before the infestation grows.
  • What results should I realistically anticipate after the initial and follow-up services? The company should establish clear expectations about pest eradication timelines and benchmarks.

Evaluate potential pest control companies based on their answers to these questions. This will enable you to choose the right provider to effectively fix your pest problem at a reasonable cost.

Most Common Pests in West Islip

You should be aware of the pests you could come across as a resident of West Islip. We analyzed around 10 million social media conversations to figure out which pests people in different cities had problems with the most.

If the following pests invade your home, it may be time to hire an exterminator: <Ul><Li>Mosquitos</Li><Li>Beatles</Li><Li>Ants</Li><Li>Bed Bugs</Li><Li>Bees</Li><Li>Fleas</Li></Ul>

Frequently Asked Questions About Pest Control in West Islip, NY

The top pest control providers are Orkin and Terminix. They can treat all common pests, have many locations, and have been in the industry for several decades.

Hiring a pest control company and getting a professional to spray your property every quarter is the best way to prevent future pest infestations. This deters insects and other wildlife from coming inside your house.

The key to finding the right pest control company for you is to contact multiple companies and get estimates from them. You should also be sure to read reviews to check their reputation and customer satisfaction.

In a town like West Islip, where the cost of living is remarkably high compared to other cities, the cost of pest control is most likely a concern. How much pest control costs depends on several factors, such as what type of pests are infesting your home and how bad the infestation is. A single visit can cost between $300 and $500, while a quarterly treatment plan is generally cheaper — around $100 to $300 a visit.

If you already have a serious infestation, you should get pest control as soon as possible. However, if you just want preventative pest control, the best time of year to have a professional spray your house is in the spring before colony numbers get too high when it's warmer. But it’s never too late for pest control. You can still spray in the summer or in other seasons and see effective results.

Other West Islip, NY Home Services