Expert Advice On Improving Your Home

10 Best Pest Control Companies in Southold, NY

Join more than 640 people who have gotten a free quote in the past week.

Written By David Cusick

Last Updated April 2024

Southold’s plentiful rainfall and hot summers mean residents experience a range of pest problems, including bed bugs and ants. Scheduling routine pest control with a good company can help you avoid these pests later on.

There are many exterminators to choose from, which can make a challenge for you to know which is best for you. That’s why we've examined plenty of options to find the best pest control companies in Southold. Keep reading to discover the top providers near you.

Our Recommended Providers

Top Pick
4.8/5
  • Covers 13 common pests in general plan
  • Offers wildlife removal
  • Extra treatments as needed at no extra cost
Comprehensive Service
4.7/5
  • Pest control guarantee
  • Treats over 15 common pests
  • Offers instant online quotes

Top 10 Best Pest Control Companies in Southold

Terminix

Terminix Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
84 Mattatuck Heights Rd, Waterbury, CT 06705 (785) 861-1160 terminix.com

Educational web content

Transparent pricing

Proactive approach to pest control

Continuous highly praised customer service reports

No-cost inspections

Services Offered

Cockroaches
Mosquitos
Flies
General pest control
Moths
Ants
Wildlife
Mice
Silverfish
Wasps
Ticks
Bed bugs
Spiders
Green pest control
Termites
Baiting
Prevention

Orkin

Orkin Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
105 Clark Dr, East Berlin, CT 06023 (860) 893-7051 orkin.com

Helpful homeowner content on its website

Free inspections

Lack of hidden fees

Positive customer service reviews

Services Offered

Baiting
Cockroaches
Mosquitos
Bees
Ants
Wildlife
Mice
Prevention
Spiders
Flies
Bed bugs
Fumigation
Wasps
General pest control
Termites

Mr. Mosquito

Mr. Mosquito Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
44535 NY-25, Southold, NY 11971 (631) 765-7770 mrmosquitony.com

Offerings of preventative treatments

Continuous highly praised customer service reports

Helpful homeowner content on its website

Free inspection policy

Lack of hidden fees

Services Offered

Mosquitos
General pest control
Fleas
Prevention
Green pest control
Ticks

Safeway Wildlife Control

Safeway Wildlife Control Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
4 N Meadow Rd, Old Saybrook, CT 06475 (860) 395-6473 safewaywildlife.com

Free inspection policy

Commitment to customer education

Services Offered

Wildlife
General pest control
Ethical pest control
Mice

Twin Forks Pest Control

Twin Forks Pest Control Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
30 County Rd 39A, Southampton, NY 11968 (631) 287-9020 twinforkspestcontrol.com

Positive customer service reviews

Transparent pricing

Commitment to customer education

Proactive approach to pest control

No-cost inspections

Services Offered

Bed bugs
Wildlife
Prevention
Termites
Ants
Mice
General pest control
Spiders
Wasps
Bees
Flies
Fleas
Cockroaches

Waltham Pest Services

Waltham Pest Services Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
400 Bayonet St STE 101, New London, CT 06320 (844) 251-7239 walthamservices.com

Transparent pricing

Reviews praise customer service

Educational web content

No-cost inspections

Services Offered

Termites
Wasps
Silverfish
Mosquitos
Prevention
Fleas
Bed bugs
Green pest control
General pest control
Ants
Flies
Mice
Spiders
Moths
Ticks
Cockroaches
Beetles

JP McHale Pest Management

JP McHale Pest Management Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
1738 County Rd 39, Southampton, NY 11968 (631) 213-6100 nopests.com

Free inspection policy

Continuous highly praised customer service reports

Preventative pest control services

Helpful homeowner content on its website

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Spiders
Ants
Mice
Baiting
Wildlife
Ticks
General pest control
Prevention
Green pest control
Termites
Cockroaches
Mosquitos

Alternative Earthcare Tick and Mosquito Spraying and Control Service

Alternative Earthcare Tick and Mosquito Spraying and Control Service Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
53 Hill St, Southampton, NY 11968 (631) 353-7548 alternativeearthcare.com

Consistently high customer service reviews

Helpful homeowner content on its website

No-cost inspections

Lack of hidden fees

Services Offered

Mice
General pest control
Ticks
Baiting
Green pest control
Mosquitos

Peconic Pest Control Inc

Peconic Pest Control Inc Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
445 County Rd 39A, Southampton, NY 11968 (631) 287-7378 peconicpestcontrol.com

Continuous highly praised customer service reports

Transparent pricing

Helpful homeowner content on its website

No-cost inspections

Services Offered

Ethical pest control
General pest control
Spiders
Green pest control

Griggs & Browne Co Inc

Griggs & Browne Co Inc Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
152 Cross Rd, Waterford, CT 06385 (860) 974-2758 griggsbrowne.com

Commitment to customer education

Continuous highly praised customer service reports

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Green pest control
Ticks
Termites
Bed bugs
General pest control
Mosquitos
Today's Homeowner Ranking Methodology

Today's Homeowner looks at dozens of datapoints on pest control companies to come up with our data-driven rankings. It's not possible for a company to pay for preferential treatment in our rankings. We look at the following key factors in determining who should top our list:

  • Company Experience
  • Real User Reviews
  • Company Reputation
  • Accreditations and Licenses
  • Service Area
  • Customer Service
Have questions about our methodology or company ratings? Reach out to FindAPro@TodaysHomeowner.com.

Top Pest Control Brands in Southold

The team at Today's Homeowner identified the top pest control companies by comparing state availability, costs, customer reviews, and more.

This is how the top pest control companies ranked in Southold:

Terminix

Terminix has several hundred branches in more than 22 countries and has been in business for about 100 years. It uses the latest pest control techniques to eliminate pests wherever they are.

Terminix helps with all kinds of pests in Southold, and if you aren’t completely satisfied with the service you receive 30 days after treatment, you can get a refund. In addition to pest control, Terminix offers services, like home disinfection services, moisture control, mechanical exclusion, and attic insulation.

Orkin

Orkin Pest Control’s headquarters are in Atlanta, Georgia. It is one of the longest-running pest control companies with a expansive network of branches. Its exterminators must undergo 160 hours of training. Additionally, due to its large network, it can usually offer next-day — or even same-day — service.

Orkin’s typical pest control plan is its annual pest control contract. Once the initial treatment, your Orkin exterminator will follow up to check that the pests haven’t come back. If they have, your local technicians can help.

Rentokil

Rentokil is a respected name in pest control, with branches across the world and nearly a century of experience in the industry. Rentokil is the parent company of several North American pest control providers including Western Exterminator, J.C. Ehrlich, and Presto-X, which can provide tailored services.

Rentokil and its partners deal with the following pests: moths, bees, wasps, spiders, cockroaches, ants, crickets, bed bugs, mosquitoes, and flies. Rentokil uses treatments that are safe for your pets and children.

How To Choose a Pest Control Company

Not all pest control providers are the identical in credibility, background, and proficiency. Evaluating services helps you identify the right choice for your pest issue. Here are the key factors to consider when selecting a pest control professional:

Services Offered

Look for a pest control company that has extensive experience treating the type of pest you're dealing with, whether it's termites, bed bugs, roaches, rodents, or something else. The company should clearly lay out its area of expertise.

Expertise

The ideal pest control company will employ technicians that have state licenses and are certified in pest control methods by groups like the National Pest Management Association (NPMA). These credentials show that the technicians have completed proper training. You'll also want to question each company about ongoing education for their employees.

Experience and Reputation

Before booking an appointment, spend time reading online reviews on sites such as Google or Yelp to verify that the company has a reputation for providing positive experiences and effective services. Also check for any complaints with the Better Business Bureau. Inquire about the ongoing training the company’s technicians receive to ensure they stay up to date on current pest control best practices. When you choose an exterminator from our list of Southold's best pest control, you can rest easy knowing you're hiring an expert that meets our quality and review standards.

Green Pest Control

If you prefer natural pest control methods, look for providers that advertise “green” accreditation. For bigger animals such as mice or squirrels, ask if a provider offers gentle catch and release programs. But keep in mind natural options may not work as well for major infestations. If you have a considerable pest problem, you may need more potent traditional methods. Whether you choose eco-friendly or traditional options, any pesticides (besides those classified as minimal risk) are required to be registered with the EPA.

Reservice Guarantee

Leading pest control provides typically offer service guarantees for ongoing plans. The guarantees mean if pests remain after the initial treatment, the company will come back and re-treat your home for free until the infestation is handled. One-time treatments may not come with reservice guarantees.

Questions To Ask Pest Control Companies

Once you have identified your top pest control providers, contact each one with these questions:

  • How often will you provide service after the first appointment? Most companies offer monthly, quarterly, or yearly service plans to monitor reinfestations.
  • What pest control plans and procedures does your company use? Make sure the techniques align with your goals for more standard treatment plans versus eco-friendly or green options. Get details about the active ingredients and compounds that the company will use.
  • What results should I reasonably expect after the initial and follow-up treatments? The company should provide a clear timeline for when pests will be eradicated.
  • How soon can you start the process? It's important to begin treatment ASAP before the infestation grows.
  • Can you give me a full cost analysis and service plan details in writing? This lets you compare exterminator pricing and avoid companies that have non-specific terms and conditions or tack on hidden fees.

Carefully review potential pest control companies using these questions. This will help you choose the best provider to safely and effectively resolve your pest problem at a reasonable price.

Most Common Pests in Southold

A variety of pests find their way into Southold homes. Some are relatively harmless, but others can damage your home and carry diseases. All of them can cause anxiety. We reviewed around 10 million posts on social media to identify the pests that were causing the most trouble for residents.

Here is a list of some pests you might encounter: <Ul><Li>Mice</Li><Li>Rats</Li><Li>Ticks</Li><Li>Bed Bugs</Li><Li>Snakes</Li><Li>Flies</Li></Ul>

Frequently Asked Questions About Pest Control in Southold, NY

The top pest control providers are Orkin and Terminix. They can treat all common pests, have locations all around the country, and have been in the industry for decades.

The best way to prevent a pest infestation is having a pest control company come to your house once every two or three months. Spraying your property regularly will stop insects and animals from returning.

For the most part, the chemicals used in pest control are safe. However, they have to be handled by a trained professional to make sure they’re used properly. After your house has been sprayed, the exterminator will recommend staying away from your home for a certain period of time. This is typically 2 to 4 hours, but can be as much as 24 hours.

There are some pests you can handle yourself. For example, if you see some ants or a stray wasp, chances are you can take care of it on your own. But some cases warrant calling the professionals. If you have a large infestation, you aren’t sure what the pest is, or would like preventative pest control, you should hire a pest control company.

In a town like Southold, where the cost of living is really high compared to other cities, the cost of pest control is most likely a concern. How much pest control costs varies based on several factors, such as what kind of pests are infesting your home and how bad the infestation is. A single visit can cost between $300 and $500, while a quarterly treatment plan is generally cheaper — around $100 to $300 a visit.

We recommend quarterly pest control treatments, or even bi-monthly if needed. For more serious infestations, your exterminator may recommend monthly treatments for the first three to six months.

Other Southold, NY Home Services