10 Best Pest Control Companies in New Square, NY

More than 350 people have received a free quote in the last 60 days.

Last Updated: February 25, 2025

New Square’s plentiful rainfall and warm summers mean homeowners experience a range of pest issues, including ticks and wasps. Homeowners and apartment dwellers who have a preventative pest control plan in place can avoid encounters with these unwanted creatures. Luckily, pest control companies can help take care of this for you.

There are many exterminators to choose from, which can make hard for you to know which is best for you. That’s why we've analyzed plenty of options to find the best pest control companies in New Square. Keep reading to learn more about each exterminator.

Advertisement This site receives compensation from some of the companies featured in this listing, which may impact where and how products appear. When you click "Get Quote," you will be connected with partners who may contact you with information related to your inquiry. This listing doesn't feature all companies, products, or offers that may be available.
Top Pick
4.8/5
  • Covers 13 common pests in general plan
  • Offers wildlife removal
  • Extra treatments as needed at no extra cost
Comprehensive Service
4.7/5
  • Pest control guarantee
  • Treats over 15 common pests
  • Offers instant online quotes

Top 10 Best Pest Control Companies in New Square

Advertisement This site receives compensation from some of the companies featured in this listing, which may impact where and how products appear. When you click "Get Quote," you will be connected with partners who may contact you with information related to your inquiry. This listing doesn't feature all companies, products, or offers that may be available.

Terminix

Terminix Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

408 The American Rd, Morris Plains, NJ 07950 (949) 454-4686 terminix.com

Transparent pricing

Proactive solutions for pest control

Educational web content

Positive customer service reviews

Free inspection policy

Services Offered

Termites
Silverfish
Bees
Flies
Moths
Bed bugs
Wildlife
Mosquitos
Cockroaches
Ticks
Mice
Wasps
Green pest control
General pest control
Prevention
Spiders
Ants

Orkin

Orkin Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

75 Nassau Terminal Rd, New Hyde Park, NY 11040 (917) 717-7159 orkin.com

Consistently high customer service reviews

Free inspection policy

Lack of hidden fees

Helpful homeowner content on its website

Services Offered

Cockroaches
Beetles
Prevention
Bees
Termites
Wildlife
Spiders
Mice
Baiting
Fumigation
Mosquitos
Bed bugs
Wasps
General pest control
Flies
Silverfish
Ants
Ticks

24 Hour Pest Control NYC

24 Hour Pest Control NYC Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

431 E 102nd St, New York, NY 10029 (646) 661-7415 247pestcontrolnyc.com

Educational web content

Reliable exterminators

Free inspections

Consistently high customer service reviews

Offerings of preventative treatments

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Wasps
Bees
Bed bugs
Cockroaches
Ants
Spiders
Moths
Beetles
Prevention
Mosquitos
Termites
Silverfish
Ticks
Wildlife
Green pest control
Ethical pest control
Fleas
General pest control
Mice
Garden protection
Flies

Western Pest Services

Western Pest Services Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

162-164 East Ave, Norwalk, CT 06851 (844) 205-4306 westernpest.com

Transparent pricing

Commitment to customer education

Consistently high customer service reviews

Preventative pest control services

Timeliness of service

Free inspections

Services Offered

Fleas
Ethical pest control
Silverfish
Mice
Termites
Mosquitos
Beetles
Moths
Ants
Green pest control
Spiders
Ticks
Flies
Prevention
Wildlife
Wasps
General pest control
Bed bugs
Baiting
Cockroaches

Dependable Exterminating

Dependable Exterminating Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

19 Don Bosco Ln, Stony Point, NY 10980 (845) 786-1620 dependableexterminating.com

Transparent pricing

Free inspections

Proactive approach to pest control

Reviews praise customer service

Services Offered

Termites
Wildlife
Mosquitos
Beetles
Cockroaches
Bed bugs
Ants
Mice
Baiting
General pest control
Prevention
Moths
Bees
Wasps
Silverfish
Fleas
Ticks
Flies
Spiders
Green pest control

EZ Bed Bug Exterminator NYC

EZ Bed Bug Exterminator NYC Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

667 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10065 (646) 760-5999 ezpestexterminating.com

Lack of hidden fees

Free inspections

Positive customer service reviews

Educational web content

Services Offered

Ethical pest control
Bees
Wasps
Ants
Fleas
Spiders
Termites
Cockroaches
Mice
Moths
Garden protection
Flies
General pest control
Prevention
Green pest control
Beetles
Silverfish
Bed bugs
Mosquitos

Arrow Exterminating Company, Inc.

Arrow Exterminating Company, Inc. Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

289 Broadway, Lynbrook, NY 11563 (516) 260-4092 arrowexterminating.com

Reliable exterminators

Offerings of preventative treatments

Consistently high customer service reviews

Transparent pricing

No-cost inspections

Helpful homeowner content on its website

Services Offered

Mosquitos
Fleas
Spiders
Wildlife
Bed bugs
Termites
Cockroaches
Flies
General pest control
Prevention
Mice
Ants
Bees
Beetles
Wasps
Ticks

Bug Runner-Exterminating Co

Bug Runner-Exterminating Co Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

680 N Main St, Spring Valley, NY 10977 (845) 352-1147 bugrunner.com

Proactive solutions for pest control

Transparent pricing

Free inspection policy

Commitment to customer education

Consistently high customer service reviews

Timeliness of service

Services Offered

Bed bugs
Spiders
Ants
Cockroaches
Ticks
Mosquitos
Mice
Bees
Moths
Fleas
Wasps
Prevention
Termites
General pest control
Wildlife

Tapout Termite & Pest Control

Tapout Termite & Pest Control Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

100 Blanch Ave, Closter, NJ 07624 (201) 736-4802 tapoutpestcontrol.com

Lack of hidden fees

Helpful homeowner content on its website

Positive customer service reviews

Free inspection policy

Services Offered

Spiders
Ticks
Wasps
Cockroaches
Fleas
Bed bugs
Silverfish
Ants
Prevention
Termites
Bees
Beetles
General pest control
Mosquitos
Moths
Flies
Mice

Bug Runner Exterminating Co

Bug Runner Exterminating Co Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

140 E Ridgewood Ave Suite 415, Paramus, NJ 07652 (201) 391-2121 bugrunner.com

Free inspections

Educational web content

Lack of hidden fees

Offerings of preventative treatments

Consistently high customer service reviews

Punctuality

Services Offered

Wildlife
Ticks
Wasps
General pest control
Mosquitos
Ants
Termites
Cockroaches
Bed bugs
Spiders
Bees
Mice
Fleas
Moths
Prevention
Today's Homeowner Ranking Methodology

Today's Homeowner looks at dozens of datapoints on pest control companies to come up with our data-driven rankings. It's not possible for a company to pay for preferential treatment in our rankings. We look at the following key factors in determining who should top our list:

  • Company Experience
  • Real User Reviews
  • Company Reputation
  • Accreditations and Licenses
  • Service Area
  • Customer Service
Have questions about our methodology or company ratings? Reach out to FindAPro@TodaysHomeowner.com.

Top Pest Control Brands in New Square

Today's Homeowner narrowed it down to these pest control companies by comparing pest control treatments offered, costs, customer reviews, state availability, contracts, and more.

Here’s how New Square’s top providers ranked:

Terminix

Terminix’s headquarters are in Memphis, Tennessee, but it has branches in 45 states and several countries around the globe. It has also been in business for almost 100 years. With this breadth of experience, you can see why Terminix is a top choice for many homeowners.

Terminix’s specialty is termites, but they help with much more than that. Their other services include: rodents, mosquitoes, spiders, ants, ticks, cockroaches, and wildlife control such as skunks, raccoons, opossums, squirrels, and more. Terminix’s typical pest regimen includes a home inspection and initial treatment, with three additional treatments over the course of a year.

Orkin

Orkin Pest Control’s headquarters are in Atlanta, Georgia. It is one of the longest-running pest control companies with a expansive network of branches. Its pest control specialists have to undergo 160 hours of training. In addition, because of its large network, it can usually provide next-day — or even same-day — service.

Orkin will send a pest control expert to inspect your property to identify issues and develop treatment plan. Orkin’s general pest control service is also quarterly, meaning your home will be treated several times over the course of a year.

Rentokil

Rentokil has been helping homeowners and business owners get rid of common pests for over 90 years. In North America, Rentokil is the parent company of quite a few local pest control branches like Presto-X, Western Exterminator, and J.C. Ehrlich.

Rentokil can protect your home from the common pests in New Square, including ants, spiders, crickets, bed bugs, flies, moths, mosquitoes, wasps, bees, and cockroaches. Rentokil’s treatments are safe for your pets and children.

How To Choose a Pest Control Company

Pest control companies aren't all equal when it comes to credibility, expertise, and competence. It’s important to research providers to find the right one for your specific situation. Here are the key factors to consider when hiring a pest control professional:

Services Offered

You should choose a pest control company that can effectively address your specific problem, whether it's roaches, bed bugs, termites, rodents, or something else. The company should clearly describe on their website its expertise with your specific pest.

Expertise

When selecting a pest control company, look for technicians with certifications in pest control methods from respected industry associations, like the National Pest Management Association (NPMA), on top of proper state licensing. The right credentials indicate that the technicians have completed proper training. Also ask about required training hours and continuing education.

Experience and Reputation

Take some time to read online reviews on Google and Yelp before scheduling a pest control appointment. This can help you confirm whether the company consistently provides quality service and positive experiences. Also check the Better Business Bureau for any complaints. Ask the provider whether technicians receive continual training to stay current on the most recent pest control methods. When you choose an exterminator from our list of New Square's best pest control, you can feel confident knowing that you're hiring an expert that meets our quality and review standards.

Green Pest Control

Search for providers that have “green” certifications if you want more natural, eco-friendly pest control. You can also ask about humane trapping programs that don't harm pests like mice or squirrels. Keep in mind that more potent solutions might be a better option for major infestations. Whether you choose eco-friendly or traditional options, any pesticides (besides those classified as minimal risk) are required to be registered with the EPA.

Reservice Guarantee

Reputable pest control professionals usually offer service guarantees for continuing plans. The warranties mean that a company will return to re-treat your home at no cost if pests remain after the initial treatment. One-off treatments might not include these reservice guarantees.

Questions To Ask Pest Control Companies

Once you have reduced your options to your top exterminators, reach out to each one and ask questions such as:

  • What pest control methods and techniques do you use? Make sure the methods suit your preferences for more standard treatment plans versus more environmentally conscious options. Get details about the chemicals that the company will use.
  • How soon can you start the process? You'll want to start right away before the problem reaches other areas.
  • How frequently will you need to treat my property once the initial service is complete? Most companies offer regular, semi-regular, or annual service plans to look for signs of reinfestations.
  • Can you provide a complete cost analysis and service plan in writing upfront? This allows you to analyze pest control pricing and avoid companies that have non-specific terms and conditions or tack on hidden fees.
  • What results can I typically expect to see after the initial and follow-up appointments? The company should set clear expectations about pest removal timelines and benchmarks.

Analyze potential pest control providers using these questions. This will help you choose the best provider to safely and effectively resolve your pest problem at a reasonable price.

Most Common Pests in New Square

It's important to be aware of the pests you could come across as a resident of New Square. Our team reviewed around 10 million social media posts to identify the pests that cause the most trouble in the area.

If you see signs of the following pests, it may be time to hire an exterminator: <Ul><Li>Mice</Li><Li>Rats</Li><Li>Spiders</Li><Li>Snakes</Li><Li>Ants</Li><Li>Moths</Li></Ul>

Frequently Asked Questions About Pest Control in New Square, NY

The top pest control providers are Orkin and Terminix. They cover all common pests, have many locations, and have been in business for several decades.

Hiring a pest control company and getting a professional to spray your property every quarter is the best way to prevent future pest infestations. This deters insects and animals from coming inside your home.

Pest control chemicals are safe but have to be handled by a professional. If you have any questions or concerns about the safety of the chemicals — such as if they're safe around children and pets — or are wondering how long you need to stay out of your house after using them, you can ask the exterminator. Typically, you should stay away from your home for two to four hours after spraying.

There are some pests you can handle yourself. For example, if you see some ants or a stray spider, chances are you can take care of it on your own. But some pest infestations warrant bringing in the professionals. If you have an out-of-control infestation, you aren’t sure what the pest is, or would like preventative pest control, you should hire a pest control company.

In a town like New Square, where the cost of living is remarkably high compared to other cities, the cost of pest control is most likely a concern. How much pest control costs varies depending on several factors, such as what kind of pests you have an issue with and how bad the infestation is. A single visit can cost between $300 and $500, but a quarterly treatment plan is usually cheaper — around $100 to $300 a visit.

We advise quarterly pest control, or even bi-monthly if needed. For larger infestations, your exterminator may recommend monthly treatments for the first three to six months.

Other New Square, NY Home Services

Loading map...