Expert Advice On Improving Your Home

10 Best Roofers in Lancaster, NY

Get matched with a top local pro.
Join over 640 homeowners that have gotten a free quote in the past week.

Written By David Cusick

Last Updated February 2024

Your roof insulates your home and protects you from the elements, but caring for it isn't always easy. In Lancaster, snowfall can contribute to cracks or water damage if left to sit and melt on your roof.

One of your area's top roofing contractors can help with any concerns you may have. No matter if your roof needs repairs, a replacement, or cleaning, one of Lancaster's top roofers can help.

Top 10 Best Roofers in Lancaster

Graves Brothers Home Improvement

Graves Brothers Home Improvement Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
6814 Main St Suite 104, Williamsville, NY 14221 (716) 875-7663 gravesbros.com

Preventive services

Transparent pricing

Honors appointment windows

Free inspections

Quality customer service

Customer education

Services Offered

Solar panel installation
Wood roofs
Rubber roofs
Roof repair
Replacement
Asphalt roofs

Expert Contracting

Expert Contracting Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
1711 Union Rd Suite 54, West Seneca, NY 14224 (716) 572-7303 expertcontractinginc.com

Customer education

Honors appointment windows

Transparent pricing

Preventive services

Free inspections

Quality customer service

Services Offered

Roof repair
Dormers
Replacement
Metal roofs

Buffalo Roofing

Buffalo Roofing Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
5565 Transit Rd, Williamsville, NY 14221 (716) 444-7663 buffaloroofing.com

Reputation for timeliness

Quality customer service

Customer education

Transparent pricing

Free inspections

Services Offered

Replacement
Metal roofs
Slate
Roof repair

Pacifico Contracting & Home Improvement

Pacifico Contracting & Home Improvement Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
1032 Abbott Rd, Buffalo, NY 14220 (716) 294-7646 pacificocontracting.com

Customer education

Locally owned

Transparent pricing

Quality customer service

Free inspections

Services Offered

Roof repair
Replacement

Neth & Son Inc

Neth & Son Inc Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
146 Taylor Dr, Depew, NY 14043 (716) 259-1856 nethandson.com

Transparent pricing

Transparent project updates

Free inspections

Customer education

Quality customer service

Services Offered

Slate
Metal roofs
Flat roofs
Roof repair
Replacement

Besroi Roofing & Siding

Besroi Roofing & Siding Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
5434 Genesee St, Lancaster, NY 14086 (716) 684-0355 besroiroofing.com

Free inspections

Customer education

Transparent pricing

Transparent project updates

Services Offered

Replacement
Roof repair

All Access Builders LLC

All Access Builders LLC Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
2017 Clinton St, Buffalo, NY 14206 (716) 770-6560 allaccessbuilders.com

Quality customer service

Free inspections

Honors appointment windows

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Roof repair
Mold remediation
Replacement

Dalex Roofing

Dalex Roofing Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
1974 Eggert Rd, Buffalo, NY 14226 (716) 609-2918 dalexroofing.com

Quality customer service

Customer education

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Roof repair
Flat roofs
Metal roofs
Quality inspection
Asphalt roofs
Replacement

Lifetime Siding, Roofing and Construction

Lifetime Siding, Roofing and Construction Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
5500 N Bailey Ave, Buffalo, NY 14226 (716) 239-6476 lifetimesidingandroofing.com

Free inspections

Quality customer service

Transparent pricing

Customer education

Reputation for timeliness

Services Offered

Quality inspection
Replacement
Wood roofs
Roof repair

Amherst Roofing

Amherst Roofing Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
8900 Transit Rd, East Amherst, NY 14051 (716) 304-4554 amherstroofingwny.com

Customer education

Quality customer service

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Replacement
Ventilation
Roof repair
Quality inspection
Today's Homeowner Ranking Methodology

Today's Homeowner looks at dozens of datapoints on roofers to come up with our data-driven rankings. It's not possible for a company to pay for preferential treatment in our rankings. We look at the following key factors in determining who should top our list:

  • Company Experience
  • Real User Reviews
  • Company Reputation
  • Accreditations and Licenses
  • Service Area
  • Customer Service
Have questions about our methodology or company ratings? Reach out to FindAPro@TodaysHomeowner.com.

How Much Does a New Roof Cost in Lancaster?

Budget is a major consideration when replacing something as big as your roof. Below, see the average price range for roof replacement on a 1,500 square foot home in Lancaster, as well as price differences between different popular roofing materials.

How To Choose a Roofing Company

Installing a new roof is a big home improvement project that can cost upwards of twenty thousand dollars when all is said and done. It's crucial to research and find a top quality and trusted local roofing contractor for the job. Here are the key factors to consider when choosing a roofing contractor.

  • References and reviews: Vet companies by checking the latest online reviews on sites like Google, Yelp, or the Better Business Bureau (BBB). Look for a track record of consistently good feedback. Requesting local references is another great way to learn more about the customer experience.
  • Responsiveness and communication: From estimate to project completion, your roofer should keep in consistent contact with you, respond to all questions, and handle any concerns.
  • Detailed written estimate: Trustworthy roofing providers will give you a comprehensive written quote. This proposal should outline the complete work plan, materials required, and total price without surprise costs. Steer clear of unclear quotes, or ones that seem much too high or low.
  • Roofing materials and products: Reputable roofing companies sell quality materials that can withstand Lancaster's weather and endure a long time. Be careful of contractors offering extremely inexpensive or generic options. Check out shingle samples before committing.
  • Warranties and guarantees: Reputable roofers provide robust guarantees from shingle manufacturers which protect shingles for over 30 years and labor guarantees for at least 5 years. Use caution with roofers offering shorter warranties.
  • Experience and credentials: Companies that have been in business for over 10 years show stability and expertise. Before hiring, verify that a provider has appropriate licenses, bonding, and insurance. Ask about professional certifications, such as those from the National Roofing Contractors Association.

Signs Your Roof Needs Repair or Replacement

While most homeowners don't think about their roof every day, it plays a key role in protecting your home. Look out for these common signs that your roof may be in need of professional inspection and repair.

Roof Age

The age and material of your roof are important. Asphalt shingles, the most popular roofing material for homes, normally last about around 20–25 years. If your roof is nearing or past this lifespan, schedule an inspection to see if it needs to be replaced.

Leaks or Water Stains in Your Home

One of the most obvious signs of a roof problem is leaking. Stains on ceilings, walls, and insulation — or in your attic — usually indicate that water is seeping through damaged or worn shingles. Don't ignore small leaks, because even these can lead to mold growth and roof deterioration.

Exposed Roof Decking Underneath Shingles

If you can see the roof decking or sheathing material underneath your shingles, it means those shingles are severely curling or losing their seal and need replacement. Shingles should lie flat to prevent water from leaking into your home.

Cracked, Broken, or Missing Shingles

Check your shingles thoroughly from ground level or a sturdy ladder. Look for ones that are cracked or that no longer have their protective coating. Over time, storms can cause surface damage. To keep your roof in repair, replace any missing shingles or ones that have gaping holes.

Flashing Deterioration Around Roof Penetrations

Roof flashing provides a watertight seal around chimneys, vents, valleys, and other areas where water can leak into your home. Peeling, cracked, or deteriorated flashing can allow leaks. We recommend promptly resolving any problems with the roof flashing that come up.

Sagging Roof Line

If your roof shows signs of sagging or unevenness, get a roofer to evaluate it. These issues could indicate a structural problem. A sagging roof that's not given adequate structural reinforcement or full replacement will continue worsening over time.

Frequently Asked Questions About Roofing in Lancaster, NY

The best type of roofing material for your home in Lancaster will be decided by several factors, including your budget and how often you're willing to do maintenance.

Asphalt is more budget-friendly, while options like metal cost more but last longer. Even if you don't need to worry about sun reflectivity, you may choose something like a clay roof for the aesthetic value and protection from fire and pests. You also might choose a material like wood for its environmentally friendly nature.

Roofing contractors do not require a license from the state of New York, however there may be local requirements. You should verify that your contractor meets any local licensing requirements before signing a contract.

Roof cleaning costs around $410 in Lancaster. The exact price will depend on the square footage of your roof, how many levels it has, its material, and how severe the problem is.

Generally, spring or autumn is the best time of year to have your roof replaced. In Lancaster, we highly recommend avoiding the wintertime if you can, as cold temperatures can negatively affect the project's timeline – not to mention you may be cold while contractors are working.

Depending on which contractor you use, your home insurance may cover some roof replacement costs. Some insurance companies may have preferred contractors. It might also be easier to have costs covered if the damage was caused by a covered weather event, such as a tornado. You can talk to your home insurance company to find out if they have preferred contractors, and what costs can be covered.

A professional will either pressure wash or "soft wash" your roof, depending on the roofing material and how much cleaning is needed. Power washing is not recommended for certain roof types like asphalt shingles. To soft wash your roof, your contractor might use tools such as brushes and brooms, and chemicals such as detergent and bleach.

Other Lancaster, NY Home Services