Expert Advice On Improving Your Home

June 2023 Reviews

6 Best Home Warranty Companies in Lancaster, NY

Written By Todays Homeowner Local Pros

Last Updated June 2023

Are you considering a home warranty? Try one of our recommended home warranty companies. There are many benefits of homeownership in Lancaster. However, major home systems and appliances, like your electrical systems and refrigerator, can break down due to normal wear and tear, leaving you with pricey repairs.

When one of your systems or appliances stops working, a home warranty will step in and help you cover the costs. A home warranty plan can give homeowners the peace of mind they need to feel less anxious about homeownership. Choosing the best home warranties on the market can be quite a challenge because of the many options out there. If you are overwhelmed by trying to compare the different options, keep reading for our guide to the top home warranty companies in Lancaster.

Preferred Providers

Best Overall
4.5/5
  • Over 10 years of experience
  • 24/7 customer service team
  • Home inspections aren’t required
4.5/5
  • Low service fees compared to other home warranty providers
  • Two months of free coverage
  • Has an appliance-only, systems-only, and combo plan option
4.5/5
  • The oldest and most trusted company in the industry
  • Allows customers to build their own plans
  • Ability to choose the service fee you want to pay

The 6 Best Home Warranty Companies in Lancaster

Choice Home Warranty

Over 10 years of experience

24/7 customer service team

Home inspections aren’t required

90-day repair guarantee

Plans aren’t customizable

Customers can’t choose their own contractor

Not available in washington

In Lancaster, Choice Home Warranty is the best overall home warranty. Choice has been in the home warranty industry for about 15 years. The 2 plans from Choice are easy to comprehend and offer a mix of both system and appliance coverage. If you're looking for very high coverage caps and simple-to-understand service contracts, this is the provider for you. Plus, it has great customer service, professional contractors, and lower out-of-pocket costs compared to other home warranties.

Choice Home Warranty has 2 plans that offer a mix of appliance and system coverage. Choice's service fees are an affordable $85, and the coverage caps come out to around $3,000 for each covered system or appliance.

Read our Choice Home Warranty Review to learn more. To receive a free quote from Choice Home Warranty, fill out this online form or give them a call at 929-400-6164.

Basic Plan

Total Plan

Service fee: $85.00 Monthly cost: $45.00
Items covered: Ceiling fan , Cooktop exhaust , Dishwasher , Disposal , Ductwork , Electrical , Garage door opener , Heating system , Oven , Microwave , Plumbing system , Toilet , Water heater Add-on items: Pool , Spa , Septic , Well pump , Roof leaking , Septic tank , Sump pump , Vacuum , Stand-alone freezer
Service fee: $85.00 Monthly cost: $53.33
Items covered: Ceiling fan , Cooktop exhaust , Dishwasher , Disposal , Ductwork , Electrical , Garage door opener , Heating system , Oven , Microwave , Plumbing system , Toilet , Water heater , AC , Washer , Dryer , Refrigerator Add-on items: Pool , Spa , Septic , Well pump , Roof leaking , Septic tank , Sump pump , Vacuum , Stand-alone freezer

Select Home Warranty

Low service fees compared to other home warranty providers

Two months of free coverage

Has an appliance-only, systems-only, and combo plan option

90-day repair guarantee

Has a $75 cancellation fee

Low coverage caps

Select Home Warranty is the most cost-effective home warranty in Lancaster. With a home warranty from Select, you can enjoy a highly affordable service fee and free roof coverage upon purchase of a policy plan. Not to mention, it has an extensive network of highly trained professionals all over the country who are experts in home maintenance. The home warranty company offers 3 plans to policyholders with various options for appliance and system coverage.

There are 3 home warranty plans from Select Home Warranty: Bronze Care Plan, Gold Care Plan, and Platinum Care Plan. The coverage caps associated with Select's plans are around the $2,000 mark for many of the major systems and appliances, and service fees are a reasonable $60.

To get a free quote from Select Home Warranty, fill out this online form or call 888-370-3953. For more information, read our detailed review of Select Home Warranty.

Bronze Care Plan

Gold Care Plan

Platinum Care Plan

Service fee: $60.00 Monthly cost: $57.67
Items covered: Disposal , Dishwasher , Dryer , Microwave , Oven , Refrigerator , Washer Add-on items: Pool , Spa , Septic , Sprinkler , Stand-alone freezer , Vacuum , Well pump , Sump pump , Roof leaks
Service fee: $60.00 Monthly cost: $57.67
Items covered: Air Conditioner , Ductwork , Electrical , Heating system , Plumbing , Water heater Add-on items: Pool , Spa , Septic , Sprinkler , Stand-alone freezer , Vacuum , Well pump , Sump pump , Roof leaks
Service fee: $60.00 Monthly cost: $62.08
Items covered: Disposal , Dishwasher , Dryer , Microwave , Oven , Refrigerator , Washer , Air conditioner , Ductwork , Electrical , Heating system , Plumbing , Water heater , Ceiling fan , Garage door , Plumbing stoppages Add-on items: Pool , Spa , Septic , Sprinkler , Stand-alone freezer , Vacuum , Well pump , Sump pump , Roof leaks

American Home Shield

The oldest and most trusted company in the industry

Allows customers to build their own plans

Ability to choose the service fee you want to pay

Broad coverage on up to 33 appliances and systems

Doesn’t let customers choose their own technician

Doesn’t provide coverage in alaska

American Home Shield offers the most customizable home warranty for Lancaster residents. AHS offers the ability to customize your plan with the coverages that work specifically for your home. Plus, it also has a remarkably low claim denial rate in comparison to other home warranty companies. The 3 plans that AHS offers include differing levels of system and appliance coverage, as well as add-on options.

American Home Shield has 3 plans that offer a combination of system and appliance coverage. The coverage caps associated with AHS's plans are close to the $2,500 mark for many major systems and appliances, and service fees are customizable and range from $75 to $125.

For a more detailed breakdown, read our American Home Shield full review. To get a free quote from American Home Shield, fill out this online form or call 888-365-2839.

ShieldSilver

ShieldGold

ShieldPlatinum

Service fee: $75.00 - $125.00 Monthly cost: $29.27 - $44.27
Items covered: Air Conditioner , Alarm , Attic fans , Bath exhaust fans , Ceiling fans , Cooktop exhaust , Disposal , Doorbell , Ductwork , Electrical , Garage door , Heating system , Locksmith , Plumbing , Plumbing stoppages , Toilet , Water dispenser , Water heater , Whole house fan Add-on items: Pool , Spa , PC , TV , Septic , Well pump
Service fee: $75.00 - $125.00 Monthly cost: $39.27 - $54.27
Items covered: Air conditioner , Alarm , Attic fans , Bath exhaust fans , Ceiling fans , Cooktop exhaust , Dishwasher , Doorbell , Dryer , Ductwork , Electrical , Garage door , Heating system , Microwave , Oven , Plumbing , Plumbing stoppages , Refrigerator , Toilet , Trash compactor , Washer , Water heater , Whole house fan Add-on items: Pool , Spa , PC , TV , Septic , Well pump
Service fee: $75.00 - $125.00 Monthly cost: $59.27 - $74.27
Items covered: Air conditioner , Alarm , Attic fans , Bath exhaust fans , Ceiling fans , Cooktop exhaust , Dishwasher , Disposal , Doorbell , Dryer , Ductwork , Electrical , Garage door , Heating system , Locksmith , Microwave , Oven , Plumbing , Plumbing stoppages , Refrigerator , Roof leaks , Toilet , Trash compactor , Washer , Water dispenser , Water heater , Whole house fan Add-on items: Pool , Spa , PC , TV , Septic , Well pump

The Home Service Club

Policy starts in ten days

24/7 customer service support

Generous coverage caps on important systems and appliances

30-labor guarantee and 90-day parts guarantee

Offers utility and home service outside line coverage

Higher service fee of $95

Not accredited by the better business bureau (bbb)

Only 2 plan options

The Home Service Club is the best home warranty with the quickest service for Lancaster residents. If you're looking for quick coverage where the home warranty goes into effect just ten days after you pay for the plan, instead of the typical 30 days, this is the home warranty for you. Plus, it has customer service representatives available 24/7, as well as a 30-day labor guarantee and a 90-day parts guarantee. HSC offers 2 plans for homeowners to decide between.

The Home Service Club has 2 plans that offer a mix of appliance and system coverage. The coverage caps from HSC are around $2,000. The service fees are customizable and range from $65 to $90, which is less than other providers in the Lancaster area.

For a more detailed breakdown, read our review of The Home Service Club. To get a free quote from The Home Service Club, you can fill out this online form or call 800-750-9443.

Standard Coverage Plan

Comprehensive Coverage Plan

Service fee: $60.00 - $95.00 Monthly cost: $50.40
Items covered: Air conditioner , Ceiling fan , Dishwasher , Garbage disposal , Dryer , Electrical system , Food center , Free-standing ice maker , Garage door opener , Heating system , Microwave , Oven , Plumbing , Refrigerator , Trash compactor , Central vacuum , Washer , Water heater Add-on items: Utilities and home service line coverage (outside gas line, outside water line, outside sewer line, sprinkler system , Pool , Spa , Water softener , Roof leaks , Well pump , Pump , Stand-alone freezer
Service fee: $60.00 - $95.00 Monthly cost: $62.90
Items covered: Air conditioner , Alarm wiring , Attic fans , Ceiling fan , Dishwasher , Garbage disposal , Doorbell , Dryer , Ductwork , Electrical system , Food center , Free-standing ice maker , Garage door opener , Heating system , Microwave , Oven , Pest control , Phone , Plumbing , Plumbing stoppages , Refrigerator , Sump pump , Toilet , Trash compactor , Central vacuum , Washer , Water dispenser , Water heater , Whole house fan Add-on items: Utilities and home service line coverage (outside gas line, outside water line, outside sewer line, sprinkler system , Pool , Spa , Water softener , Roof leaks , Well pump , Pump , Stand-alone freezer

Liberty Home Guard

Very highly rated among customer service reviews

Covers repairs with a 60-day workmanship guarantee

Extensive list of 20+ add-on coverages

Easy claims process

Isn’t available in 2 states

Won’t cover known or unknown pre-existing conditions

Liberty Home Guard offers the most trustworthy home warranty in Lancaster. Liberty has been in the home warranty industry for around 6 years. Liberty offers 3 plans for you to choose from. With a home warranty from Liberty, you can enjoy a seamless complaint process and guaranteed service professionalism upon every repair visit. Not to mention, it has a 60-day workmanship guarantee and some of the best customer service in the industry.

There are 3 home warranty plans from Liberty Home Guard: Appliance Guard, Systems Guard, and Total Home Guard. Liberty's service fees are an affordable $75, and the coverage caps come out to around $3,000 per covered appliance or system.

For more information, read our Liberty Home Guard full review. To receive a free quote from Liberty Home Guard, you can fill out this online form or call 866-451-2281.

Appliance Guard

Systems Guard

Total Home Guard

Service fee: $75.00 Monthly cost: $69.99
Items covered: Ceiling Fan , Cooktop exhaust fan , Disposal , Dishwasher , Dryer , Garage door , Microwave , Oven , Refrigerator , Refrigerator ice maker , Washer Add-on items: Pool , Saltwater pool , Spa , TV , PC , Pump , Generator , Free-standing ice maker , Septic tank pumping , Roof leaks , Pests , Water softener , Well pump , Wine refrigerator , Septic , Sprinkler , Locksmith , Trash compactor , Sump pump , Vacuum , Stand-alone freezer , Water dispenser
Service fee: $75.00 Monthly cost: $74.99
Items covered: Air Conditioner , Bath exhaust fan , Ductwork , Electrical , Heating system , Plumbing , Plumbing stoppages , Toilet , Water heater Add-on items: Pool , Saltwater pool , Spa , TV , PC , Pump , Generator , Free-standing ice maker , Septic tank pumping , Roof leaks , Pests , Water softener , Well pump , Wine refrigerator , Septic , Sprinkler , Locksmith , Trash compactor , Sump pump , Vacuum , Stand-alone freezer , Water dispenser
Service fee: $75.00 Monthly cost: $79.99
Items covered: Ceiling Fan , Cooktop exhaust fan , Disposal , Dishwasher , Dryer , Garage door , Microwave , Oven , Refrigerator , Refrigerator ice maker , Washer , Air Conditioner , Bath exhaust fan , Ductwork , Electrical , Heating system , Plumbing , Plumbing stoppages , Toilet , Water heater Add-on items: Pool , Saltwater pool , Spa , TV , PC , Pump , Generator , Free-standing ice maker , Septic tank pumping , Roof leaks , Pests , Water softener , Well pump , Wine refrigerator , Septic , Sprinkler , Locksmith , Trash compactor , Sump pump , Vacuum , Stand-alone freezer , Water dispenser

Cinch Home Services

Offers home insurance deductible of $500

Extra long 180-day workmanship guarantee

Offers free cancellation in the first 30 days

Charges high service fees of $75-$150

Doesn’t allow customers to choose their own technician

Isn’t available in hawaii or alaska

In Lancaster, Cinch Home Services offers the home warranty with the best workmanship guarantee. Cinch offers a 180-day workmanship guarantee that ensures your home systems and appliance repairs will be professionally done. Plus, it also has a broad range of coverage options that will give homeowners peace of mind. The home warranty company offers 3 plans to policyholders that have various options for appliance and system coverage.

Cinch Home Services has 3 plans that provide a combination of appliance and system coverage. Service fees from Cinch are customizable and range from $75 to $150. The coverage caps are also typically around $1,000-$2,000 at the maximum.

To get a free quote from Cinch Home Services, you can fill out this online form or call 877-589-0505. For more information on this provider, read our Cinch Home Services full review.

Appliances Plan

Built-in Systems Plan

Complete Home Plan

Service fee: $75.00 - $150.00 Monthly cost: $34.99 - $50.99
Items covered: Cooktop exhaust fan , Dishwasher , Dryer , Food center , Free-standing ice maker , Microwave , Oven , Refrigerator , Refrigerator ice maker , Trash compactor , Washer Add-on items: Pool , Septic , Well pump
Service fee: $75.00 - $150.00 Monthly cost: $39.99 - $57.99
Items covered: Air conditioner , Smoke alarm , Attic fans , Bath exhaust fans , Ceiling fans , Disposal , Doorbell , Ductwork , Electrical , Garage door , Heating system , Plumbing , Plumbing stoppages , Septic tank pumping , Spa , Sump pump , Toilet , Vacuum , Water dispenser , Water heater , Whole house fan Add-on items: Pool , Septic , Well pump
Service fee: $75.00 - $150.00 Monthly cost: $49.99 - $67.99
Items covered: Air conditioner , Alarm , Attic fans , Bath exhaust fans , Ceiling fans , Cooktop exhaust , Dishwasher , Disposal , Doorbell , Dryer , Ductwork , Electrical , Food center , Free-standing ice maker , Garage door , Heating system , Microwave , Oven , Plumbing , Plumbing stoppages , Refrigerator , Refrigerator ice maker , Septic tank pumping , Spa , Sump pump , Toilet , Trash compactor , Vacuum , Washer , Water dispenser , Water heater , Whole house fan Add-on items: Pool , Septic , Well pump
Today's Homeowner Ranking Methodology

Today's Homeowner looks at dozens of datapoints on home warranty companies to come up with our data-driven rankings. It's not possible for a company to pay for preferential treatment in our rankings. We look at the following key factors in determining who should top our list:

  • Company Experience
  • Real User Reviews
  • Company Reputation
  • Accreditations and Licenses
  • Service Area
  • Customer Service
Have questions about our methodology or company ratings? Reach out to FindAPro@TodaysHomeowner.com.

Cost of Common Home Repairs in Lancaster

Home Appliance Repair Cost
Air Conditioner $6,133
Heating $4,088
Electrical $613
Toilets $511
Washer/Dryer $818
Plumbing $613
Oven $1,635
Fridge $613

What is a Home Warranty?


A home warranty is a protection plan that covers the cost of repairing or replacing major home systems and appliances when they break over time due to normal wear and tear. Having a home warranty in place can provide some peace of mind and guard your savings account from large out-of-pocket costs. Most home warranty plans start about 30 days after paying for the home warranty plan.

When you have a system or appliance that has a problem, you file a claim with your home warranty provider. You can do so online or by calling customer support, and then a repair technician will come and fix the problem.

At this point, you'll pay your service fee, which is usually between $60 and $150, depending on what plan you opt for. After the service fee is paid, a service technician will come to your home, assess the issue, and make the repair. As long as the repair is covered under the warranty and it's within the coverage cap, most homeowners will not have to pay any other out-of-pocket costs apart from the service fee.

What Does a Home Warranty Cover?

A home warranty will cover systems and appliances that have broken down from normal wear and tear. For instance, if your washing machine suddenly stops working under normal use conditions, this is a perfect time to call your home warranty provider. The appliances commonly covered under a home warranty plan are the oven, microwave, refrigerator, dryer, washing machine, dishwasher, and more. System coverage typically includes plumbing, heating, electrical systems, air conditioning, and more.

You can also optionally decide to pay extra for add-on coverage for items like spas, swimming pools, septic systems, and roof warranty.

A home warranty will only help you with repairs and replacements due to normal wear and tear. If you don't take care of your appliances or systems and maintain them properly, the home warranty will not cover it. Also, a home warranty does not cover lack of maintenance, cosmetic damages, pre-existing conditions, and misuse.

Is a Home Warranty Worth it in Lancaster?


Benefits of a Home Warranty

Since temperatures in Lancaster can hit the negatives in the winter, the extreme weather can put a lot of strain on your heating system. Having a home warranty plan can help homeowners save money if one of these systems or appliances stops working all of a sudden.

Not only can a Lancaster home warranty save you money on repairs and replacements, it saves you time too. Instead of vetting contractors yourself, home warranty companies do the work for you and send a contractor from their network right to your door when you need them.

Downsides of a Home Warranty

One of the major drawbacks of a home warranty is not every home system and appliance may be covered. It's important to compare the different plans and opt for one that covers all the appliances, systems, and add-ons you need.

Another thing to keep in mind is that some companies don't cover pre-existing issues and may require an inspection before coverage begins. Ask the home warranty provider for clarification about it if you aren't sure or if this is a problem for you.

Home Warranty Tips


Deciding on the right home warranty in Lancaster for you depends on the coverage you need, the home warranty provider you go with, and where you live, among other factors. Below is a list of some factors to consider when looking for a home warranty in Lancaster:

  • Read the contract carefully: Be certain you understand what's covered under the warranty, and the coverage limits so that you know what to expect when filing claims.
  • Service call fee: How much will it cost to have a repair person come and repair or replace the item in question?
  • Customer service: Some companies send a contractor within 48 hours after making a claim, whereas others can take up to 72 hours. If you want quick service, look for a company that sends someone to your home right away.
  • Reputation: How long has the home warranty company been in business? Do they have a good rating on the Better Business Bureau (BBB)?

Preferred Providers

Best Overall
4.5/5
  • Over 10 years of experience
  • 24/7 customer service team
  • Home inspections aren’t required
4.5/5
  • Low service fees compared to other home warranty providers
  • Two months of free coverage
  • Has an appliance-only, systems-only, and combo plan option
4.5/5
  • The oldest and most trusted company in the industry
  • Allows customers to build their own plans
  • Ability to choose the service fee you want to pay

Frequently Asked Questions About Home Warranties in Lancaster, NY

The best home warranty company in Lancaster is Choice Home Warranty. Choice Home Warranty has an expansive network of professional service technicians and a great reputation in the Lancaster area.

A home warranty is a service contract that gives homeowners extra coverage for their household systems and appliances. These include garbage disposals, dryers, refrigerators, washing machines, dishwashers, electrical systems, plumbing, heating and cooling systems, water heaters, and sump pumps, among others. Some companies also offer coverage for garage door openers, pools, ceiling fans, and roofs. A home warranty can help you save money if these appliances and systems fail unexpectedly.

Home warranties cover issues related to systems and appliances that need repairs or replacements due to normal wear and tear. A homeowner's insurance policy is a different insurance that protects the entire home from natural disasters, which might not be too much of a concern in Lancaster. It doesn't cover a normal appliance or system repairs.

A home warranty plan can cover either the home appliances and systems, or both. Combination plans are beneficial if you need more coverage for your home, but a systems or appliance only plan can be useful too if you're concerned about one more than the other.

Many homeowners think a home warranty is worth it since it helps protect against unforeseen expenses, and saving money is important with the cost of living going up in Lancaster. If you're worried about your budget and your ability to keep your home in good working order, getting a home warranty can help. One of the big advantages of a home warranty is that it can provide you some financial peace of mind.

A Lancaster home warranty can cost between $40 and $80 a month. The higher-priced plans typically have higher coverage limits, a lower service fee, and more coverage.

The systems and appliances in a home are covered under a home warranty policy in Lancaster. Everything from a fridge to a pool can be covered under a home warranty depending on the plan.

Other Lancaster, NY Home Services