10 Best Roofers in Geneseo, NY

More than 250 people have received a free quote in the last 60 days.

Last Updated: February 25, 2025

Maintaining the health of your roof, although important, isn't always simple. The snow in Geneseo can sit heavily on a roof and lead to water damage.

No matter your circumstances, there's a local roofing pro who understands and can help. Follow our guide to discover the right roofers in Geneseo.

Top 10 Best Roofers in Geneseo

Advertisement This site receives compensation from some of the companies featured in this listing, which may impact where and how products appear. When you click "Get Quote," you will be connected with partners who may contact you with information related to your inquiry. This listing doesn't feature all companies, products, or offers that may be available.

Oaks Construction

Oaks Construction Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

415 S Union St, Spencerport, NY 14559 (585) 247-6257 oaks-construction.com

Transparent project updates

Transparent pricing

Honors appointment windows

Quality customer service

Preventive services

Free inspections

Customer education

Services Offered

Roof repair
Metal roofs
Skylights
Replacement
Mold remediation
Solar panel installation
Flat roofs
Asphalt roofs

Stellar Roofing in New York - Roof Replacement

Stellar Roofing in New York - Roof Replacement Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

1742 Long Pond Rd Suite 2, Rochester, NY 14606 (585) 888-7663 stellarroofing.com

Preventive services

Reputation for timeliness

Quality customer service

Locally owned

Transparent pricing

Transparent project updates

Free inspections

Services Offered

Ventilation
Roof repair
Metal roofs
Quality inspection
Replacement

Giordano Roof Replacement & Roof Restoration

Giordano Roof Replacement & Roof Restoration Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

115 Fairfax Rd, Rochester, NY 14609 (585) 467-6767 bestroofingcompanyofrochester.com

Free inspections

Quality customer service

Preventive services

Transparent pricing

Honors appointment windows

Services Offered

Replacement
Flat roofs
Asphalt roofs
Roof repair
Quality inspection

Graves Brothers Home Improvement

Graves Brothers Home Improvement Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

6814 Main St Suite 104, Williamsville, NY 14221 (716) 875-7663 gravesbros.com

Customer education

Honors appointment windows

Quality customer service

Free inspections

Preventive services

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Roof repair
Replacement
Rubber roofs
Solar panel installation
Wood roofs
Asphalt roofs

Fiddler Roofing Inc

Fiddler Roofing Inc Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

2335 Niagara Falls Blvd, Niagara Falls, NY 14304 (716) 284-1322 fiddlerroofing.com

Transparent pricing

Preventive services

Free inspections

Honors appointment windows

Services Offered

Roof repair
Replacement
Quality inspection
Metal roofs
Flat roofs
Skylights
Ventilation

Northside Company

Northside Company Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

541 Whitney Rd, Fairport, NY 14450 (585) 381-1050 northsidecompany.com

Quality customer service

Reputation for timeliness

Transparent pricing

Customer education

Free inspections

Preventive services

Services Offered

Roof repair
Attic insulation
Quality inspection
Replacement
Flat roofs
Skylights
Wood roofs

Morreall and Company - Roofing, Siding & Gutters Services

Morreall and Company - Roofing, Siding & Gutters Services Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

485 Titus Ave Suite F2, Rochester, NY 14617 (585) 204-2005 morreallandcompany.com

Transparent project updates

Quality customer service

Free inspections

Preventive services

Customer education

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Replacement
Roof repair
Skylights
Quality inspection

G Roofing LLC

G Roofing LLC Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

1970 Sturgeon Point Rd, Derby, NY 14047 (716) 290-0433 groofingllc.com

Preventive services

Quality customer service

Free inspections

Customer education

Transparent pricing

Locally owned

Services Offered

Quality inspection
Roof repair
Skylights
Asphalt roofs
Ventilation
Replacement

Highland Contractors

Highland Contractors Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

620 S Clinton Ave, Rochester, NY 14620 (585) 507-3658 highlandcontractors.net

Transparent pricing

Transparent project updates

Preventive services

Customer education

Free inspections

Quality customer service

Services Offered

Flat roofs
Roof repair
Quality inspection
Replacement
Solar panel installation
Skylights

Five Star Improvements

Five Star Improvements Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

145 Norris Dr, Rochester, NY 14610 (585) 256-1844 fivestarimprovements.com

Free inspections

Transparent pricing

Quality customer service

Customer education

Services Offered

Replacement
Metal roofs
Wood roofs
Rubber roofs
Asphalt roofs
Roof repair
Ventilation
Skylights
Today's Homeowner Ranking Methodology

Today's Homeowner looks at dozens of datapoints on roofers to come up with our data-driven rankings. It's not possible for a company to pay for preferential treatment in our rankings. We look at the following key factors in determining who should top our list:

  • Company Experience
  • Real User Reviews
  • Company Reputation
  • Accreditations and Licenses
  • Service Area
  • Customer Service
Have questions about our methodology or company ratings? Reach out to FindAPro@TodaysHomeowner.com.

How Much Does a New Roof Cost in Geneseo?

For a project as substantial as roof replacement, cost matters. Below is the usual price range to replace a roof on a 1,500 square foot home in Geneseo. We also compare prices for popular roofing materials.

How To Choose a Roofing Company

Installing a new roof is a major home renovation that can cost tens of thousands of dollars when finished. It's crucial to research thoroughly to find the most qualified and trustworthy roofing company for the job. Here are some important considerations when hiring a roofer.

  • References and reviews: Vet companies by reviewing their most recent online feedback on sites such as Google, Yelp, or the Better Business Bureau (BBB). Look for a history of consistently positive reviews. Requesting local references is another great way to learn more about the customer experience.
  • Warranties and guarantees: Reputable roofing companies provide strong guarantees that cover your roof. Look for coverage on shingles lasting 30+ years and at least a 5-year labor warranty. Stay away from companies that have shorter warranties.
  • Experience and credentials: Providers with a decade or more of experience show consistent quality and customer satisfaction. Before hiring, make sure the company has appropriate licenses, bonding, and insurance. Inquire about professional certifications, such as those from the National Roofing Contractors Association.
  • Roofing materials and products: Quality roofing materials from leading manufacturers are able to withstand Geneseo's weather and last for decades. Beware of contractors who offer extremely low-cost or generic products. Review shingle samples before making a decision.
  • Detailed written estimate: Trustworthy roofing companies will offer a comprehensive written estimate that outlines the scope of the work, materials requirements, and total cost with no hidden fees. Avoid vague quotes or ones that seem dramatically high or low.
  • Responsiveness and communication: From estimate to project completion, the company should maintain ongoing communication with you, answer all questions, and resolve any concerns.

Signs Your Roof Needs Repair or Replacement

Though it likely doesn't cross homeowners' minds daily, your roof plays a key role in protecting your home. Be attentive to these common signs that your roof may need an inspection and repairs from a professional roofer.

Roof Age

The age and material of your roof are important. Asphalt shingles, the most common residential roofing material, typically last around 20–25 years before needing to be replaced. If your roof is nearing or past this lifespan, get a professional inspection to determine if full replacement is needed.

Leaks or Water Stains in Your Home

One of the most obvious signs of roof trouble is water leaks. Stains on your walls, insulation, or ceilings, or in your attic likely indicate water seeping through damaged or worn shingles. Even small leaks should not be ignored, as they can facilitate mold growth and further damage your roof.

Exposed Roof Decking Underneath Shingles

If you can see roof deck boards or sheathing under shingles, it indicates that those shingles are severely curling or losing their seal. This means it's time for replacement. Shingles need to lie flat to prevent water from entering your home.

Cracked, Broken, or Missing Shingles

Inspect your shingles thoroughly from ground level or a steady ladder. Look for ones that have cracks or that no longer have their protective coating. Over time, storms can cause surface damage. To keep your roof in good shape, replace any missing shingles or ones that have gaping holes.

Flashing Deterioration Around Roof Penetrations

Roof flashing provides a weatherproof seal around chimneys, valleys, vents, and other areas that penetrate your roof. If this metal flashing is coming loose, cracked open, or worn down, it can allow leaks. Problems with roof flashing should be addressed promptly.

Sagging Roof Line

If you notice your roofline sagging or sloping unevenly, it could signal a problem with the structure that requires further inspection by a roofer. A sagging roof deck will worsen over time if not given proper reinforcement or replaced entirely.

Frequently Asked Questions About Roofing in Geneseo, NY

The best type of roofing material for your home in Geneseo will depend on a number of factors, such as your budget and how often you're willing to do maintenance.

Asphalt is less costly, while options like metal cost more but last longer. Even if you don't need to worry about sun reflectivity, you may choose something like a clay roof for the aesthetic value and protection from fire and pests. You also might choose a material like wood for its environmentally friendly nature.

Roofing contractors do not require a license from the state of New York, but there may be local requirements. Be sure to verify that your contractor meets any local licensing requirements before signing a contract.

Generally, the fall or the spring is the best time of year to have your roof replaced. In Geneseo, we highly recommend avoiding the wintertime if you can, as cold temperatures can negatively affect the project's timeline – not to mention you may be cold while contractors are working.

Your roof can impact how energy-efficient your home is. For example, a good roof helps you spend less energy heating your home during the winter months. Some materials (like metal) are more energy-efficient than others.

The best color for your roof is based on a few factors like the color and style of your house and the local climate. For example, if you have a Spanish style home, then you'll probably want a terracotta roof to match the style. Also, those in a hot climate may want to avoid darker colors because they absorb heat, which makes your home harder to keep cool.

Roofs should normally be cleaned about once a year. You may need to clean your roof more often if there's a buildup of leaves, mold, mildew, or moss.

Other Geneseo, NY Home Services

Loading map...