Expert Advice On Improving Your Home

10 Best Roofers in Arcadia, NY

Get matched with a top local pro.
Join more than 640 people who have gotten a free quote in the past week.

Written By David Cusick

Last Updated April 2024

Your roof serves many important functions, from keeping your heat in to keeping water out. However, caring for your roof isn't always simple. In Arcadia, snowfall can lead to cracks or water damage if left to sit and melt on your roof.

For all issues, big or small, there's a local roofing contractor who can help. Our guide can help connect you with one of the top roofers in Arcadia.

Top 10 Best Roofers in Arcadia

Erie Home

Erie Home Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
6057 Corporate Dr Suite 1E, Syracuse, NY 13057 (315) 214-8011 eriehome.com

Transparent project updates

Quality customer service

Free inspections

Services Offered

Replacement
Roof repair
Metal roofs
Asphalt roofs

Marshall Exteriors, LLC

Marshall Exteriors, LLC Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
135 E Union St, Newark, NY 14513 (315) 331-6462 marshallexteriorsny.com

Customer education

Quality customer service

Locally owned

Free inspections

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Roof repair
Solar panel installation
Replacement
Ventilation
Metal roofs

Secore Contracting Services

Secore Contracting Services Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
2131 Daansen Rd, Palmyra, NY 14522 (315) 597-6286 secorecontracting.com

Free inspections

Transparent pricing

Reputation for timeliness

Quality customer service

Services Offered

Roof repair
Replacement

Testa Roofing LLC

Testa Roofing LLC Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
515 Cline Rd, Victor, NY 14564 (585) 468-7663 testaroofingllc.com

Quality customer service

Transparent project updates

Free inspections

Preventive services

Transparent pricing

Customer education

Services Offered

Roof repair
Replacement

The Roof Rangers

The Roof Rangers Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
6004 Co Rd 41, Farmington, NY 14425 (585) 296-4050 theroofrangers.com

Customer education

Quality customer service

Transparent pricing

Free inspections

Services Offered

Solar panel installation
Roof repair
Replacement
Ventilation
Quality inspection
Roof cleaning

Dayton Enterprises LLC Formerly Victor Roofing & Siding Inc

Dayton Enterprises LLC Formerly Victor Roofing & Siding Inc Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
1304 Co Rd 8, Farmington, NY 14425 (585) 924-2570 daytonenterprises.com

Reputation for timeliness

Customer education

Transparent pricing

Quality customer service

Services Offered

Roof repair
Replacement

Five Star Improvements of Syracuse

Five Star Improvements of Syracuse Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
470 N Main St, Canandaigua, NY 14424 (585) 434-4021 fivestarimprovements.com

Customer education

Free inspections

Transparent pricing

Quality customer service

Services Offered

Wood roofs
Rubber roofs
Skylights
Metal roofs
Ventilation
Asphalt roofs
Roof repair
Replacement

Northside Company

Northside Company Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
541 Whitney Rd, Fairport, NY 14450 (585) 381-1050 northsidecompany.com

Customer education

Honors appointment windows

Free inspections

Quality customer service

Preventive services

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Quality inspection
Flat roofs
Skylights
Attic insulation
Roof repair
Wood roofs
Replacement
Mold remediation

City Wide Roofing & Siding Rochester

City Wide Roofing & Siding Rochester Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
1579 Hermance Rd, Webster, NY 14580 (585) 265-4881 citywideroofingrochester.com

Free inspections

Transparent pricing

Customer education

Transparent project updates

Quality customer service

Services Offered

Quality inspection
Replacement
Roof repair

Best Construction

Best Construction Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
7026 Slocum Rd, Ontario, NY 14519 (315) 524-2456 bestconstruction.biz

Honors appointment windows

Free inspections

Quality customer service

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Replacement
Today's Homeowner Ranking Methodology

Today's Homeowner looks at dozens of datapoints on roofers to come up with our data-driven rankings. It's not possible for a company to pay for preferential treatment in our rankings. We look at the following key factors in determining who should top our list:

  • Company Experience
  • Real User Reviews
  • Company Reputation
  • Accreditations and Licenses
  • Service Area
  • Customer Service
Have questions about our methodology or company ratings? Reach out to FindAPro@TodaysHomeowner.com.

How Much Does a New Roof Cost in Arcadia?

Cost is a major consideration when replacing your roof. Below is the average price range to replace a roof on a 1,500 square foot home in Arcadia. We also compare prices for common roofing materials.

How To Choose a Roofing Company

A new roof installation is a major home renovation that can run tens of thousands of dollars. It's crucial to research and find a highly reviewed and recommended roofing company for the job. Here are some important considerations for hiring a roofer.

  • Experience and credentials: Seek out providers that have been operating for at least 10 years. These companies' extensive experience and time in operation reflects consistent work, knowledgeable teams, and happy former customers. Confirm that a provider has appropriate licenses, bonds, and insurance before hiring. Also ask about professional certifications, such as those from the National Roofing Contractors Association.
  • Warranties and guarantees: Reputable roofers provide strong manufacturer warranties covering shingles for 30+ years and workmanship warranties for five or more years. Use caution with roofers offering shorter warranties.
  • References and reviews: Research companies carefully by checking reviews on sites like Google, Yelp, or the Better Business Bureau (BBB). Look for years of consistently positive feedback. You can also request recent local references.
  • Roofing materials and products: Leading manufacturers produce durable roofing materials that can endure Arcadia's weather for years. Steer clear of contractors pushing low-cost or generic products. Review shingle samples before making a decision.
  • Detailed written estimate: Trustworthy roofing companies will offer a comprehensive written quote. This estimate should outline the complete work plan, materials, and total price with no hidden fees. Steer clear of unclear bids, or ones that seem much too low or high.
  • Responsiveness and communication: From quote to project completion, your contractor should maintain ongoing communication with you, respond to all questions, and handle any concerns.

Signs Your Roof Needs Repair or Replacement

Though most homeowners don't think about their roof every day, it provides critical protections for your home. Keep watch for these common signs that your roof may need inspection and repairs from a professional roofer.

Roof Age

The age and material of your roof are key factors. Asphalt shingles, the most popular residential roofing material, typically last 20–25 years before needing replacement. If your roof is approaching or past this lifespan, get a professional inspection to determine if full replacement is needed.

Leaks or Water Stains in Your Home

Leaks are a definite sign that your roof requires repairs. Stains on walls, ceilings, or insulation, or in your attic often signal that water is getting through deteriorating shingles. Even small leaks need to be taken care of promptly, as they can result in mold and more harm over time.

Exposed Roof Decking Underneath Shingles

Visible roof decking or sheathing under your shingles indicates that those shingles are severely curling or losing their seal. This means the shingles likely need replacement. Shingles need to lie flat to stop water from leaking into your home.

Cracked, Broken, or Missing Shingles

Examine your shingles closely from a safe ladder or while on the ground. Look for shingles that have cracked or no longer have their protective granule layer. Storms can cause roof damage over time. To keep your roof in good condition, replace any shingles that are no longer attached or are openly gaping.

Flashing Deterioration Around Roof Penetrations

Roof flashing creates a watertight seal around valleys, vents, chimneys, and other areas where water can penetrate your roof. Peeling, cracked, or deteriorated flashing can allow leaks. We recommend promptly resolving any problems with the roof flashing that come up.

Sagging Roof Line

If your roof shows signs of sagging or unevenness, it's time to call a professional roofer. These issues could indicate a structural problem. A sagging roof that's not reinforced or replaced will worsen over time.

Frequently Asked Questions About Roofing in Arcadia, NY

The best type of roofing material for your home in Arcadia will depend on things like your budget and how often you want to do maintenance.

Metal is more expensive but is more durable, while asphalt will be cheaper up front but will require more maintenance. Wood roofs have better insulation than many other materials, which can be very beneficial in the winter.

Roofing contractors do not require a license from the state of New York, but there may be local requirements. Be sure to verify that your contractor meets any local licensing requirements before signing a contract.

The best time of year for a roof replacement is spring or fall. In the winter, Arcadia's cold temperatures can impede progress.

Your roof absolutely impacts the energy efficiency of your home. For example, in the winter a good roof allows you to spend less energy heating your home. Certain roofing materials, such as metal, provide better insulation than other types.

The best color for your roof is based on several factors like the style and color of your house and the local climate. For example, if you have a Spanish style home, then you'll probably want a terracotta roof to match the style. Also, those in a hot climate may want to avoid darker colors because they absorb heat, which makes cooling your home more difficult.

Other Arcadia, NY Home Services