10 Best Roofers in Arcadia, NY

More than 250 people have received a free quote in the last 60 days.

Last Updated: February 25, 2025

Your roof serves many important functions, from keeping your heat in to keeping water out. However, caring for your roof isn't always simple. In Arcadia, snowstorms can lead to cracks or water damage if left to sit and melt on your roof.

For all problems, big or small, there's a local roofing contractor who can help. Use our guide to connect with one of the best roofers in Arcadia.

Top 10 Best Roofers in Arcadia

Advertisement This site receives compensation from some of the companies featured in this listing, which may impact where and how products appear. When you click "Get Quote," you will be connected with partners who may contact you with information related to your inquiry. This listing doesn't feature all companies, products, or offers that may be available.

Erie Home

Erie Home Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

6057 Corporate Dr Suite 1E, Syracuse, NY 13057 (315) 214-8011 eriehome.com

Free inspections

Quality customer service

Transparent project updates

Services Offered

Roof repair
Metal roofs
Replacement
Asphalt roofs

Oaks Construction

Oaks Construction Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

415 S Union St, Spencerport, NY 14559 (585) 247-6257 oaks-construction.com

Quality customer service

Preventive services

Reputation for timeliness

Transparent project updates

Free inspections

Customer education

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Replacement
Metal roofs
Solar panel installation
Roof repair
Asphalt roofs
Skylights
Flat roofs
Mold remediation

Melo Roofing Inc

Melo Roofing Inc Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

209 Factory Ave, Syracuse, NY 13208 (315) 741-7049 meloroofing.com

Customer education

Quality customer service

Free inspections

Reputation for timeliness

Transparent pricing

Preventive services

Locally owned

Services Offered

Replacement
Quality inspection
Terra cotta
Asphalt roofs
Skylights
Roof repair

Giordano Roof Replacement & Roof Restoration

Giordano Roof Replacement & Roof Restoration Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

115 Fairfax Rd, Rochester, NY 14609 (585) 467-6767 bestroofingcompanyofrochester.com

Transparent pricing

Quality customer service

Honors appointment windows

Free inspections

Preventive services

Services Offered

Replacement
Roof repair
Flat roofs
Asphalt roofs
Quality inspection

Stellar Roofing in New York - Roof Replacement

Stellar Roofing in New York - Roof Replacement Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

1742 Long Pond Rd Suite 2, Rochester, NY 14606 (585) 888-7663 stellarroofing.com

Quality customer service

Reputation for timeliness

Preventive services

Transparent project updates

Transparent pricing

Free inspections

Locally owned

Services Offered

Metal roofs
Roof repair
Ventilation
Replacement
Quality inspection

Northside Company

Northside Company Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

541 Whitney Rd, Fairport, NY 14450 (585) 381-1050 northsidecompany.com

Free inspections

Honors appointment windows

Transparent pricing

Preventive services

Quality customer service

Customer education

Services Offered

Quality inspection
Skylights
Roof repair
Replacement
Flat roofs
Wood roofs
Attic insulation

Graves Brothers Home Improvement

Graves Brothers Home Improvement Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

755 Winton Rd N, Rochester, NY 14609 (585) 288-3390 gravesbros.com

Quality customer service

Preventive services

Reputation for timeliness

Customer education

Transparent pricing

Free inspections

Services Offered

Replacement
Rubber roofs
Solar panel installation
Asphalt roofs
Wood roofs
Roof repair

CNY Commercial & Residential Construction Inc.

CNY Commercial & Residential Construction Inc. Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

817 Fyler Rd, Kirkville, NY 13082 (315) 901-1924 constructioncny.com

Free inspections

Customer education

Locally owned

Quality customer service

Transparent pricing

Transparent project updates

Preventive services

Services Offered

Roof repair
Replacement
Metal roofs

Morreall and Company - Roofing, Siding & Gutters Services

Morreall and Company - Roofing, Siding & Gutters Services Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

485 Titus Ave Suite F2, Rochester, NY 14617 (585) 204-2005 morreallandcompany.com

Preventive services

Free inspections

Quality customer service

Transparent pricing

Customer education

Transparent project updates

Services Offered

Replacement
Quality inspection
Skylights
Roof repair

Highland Contractors

Highland Contractors Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

620 S Clinton Ave, Rochester, NY 14620 (585) 507-3658 highlandcontractors.net

Preventive services

Transparent pricing

Transparent project updates

Customer education

Free inspections

Quality customer service

Services Offered

Quality inspection
Solar panel installation
Skylights
Roof repair
Replacement
Flat roofs
Today's Homeowner Ranking Methodology

Today's Homeowner looks at dozens of datapoints on roofers to come up with our data-driven rankings. It's not possible for a company to pay for preferential treatment in our rankings. We look at the following key factors in determining who should top our list:

  • Company Experience
  • Real User Reviews
  • Company Reputation
  • Accreditations and Licenses
  • Service Area
  • Customer Service
Have questions about our methodology or company ratings? Reach out to FindAPro@TodaysHomeowner.com.

How Much Does a New Roof Cost in Arcadia?

Cost is a major consideration when replacing something as big as your roof. Below, find the average price range for roof replacement on a 1,500 square foot home in Arcadia, as well as comparisons between different popular roofing materials.

How To Choose a Roofing Company

A new roof installation is a major home renovation that can run over twenty thousand dollars total. It's essential to research and find the most qualified and reputable roofing company for the job. Here are the top things to evaluate when selecting a roofer.

  • Experience and credentials: An established roofing company that has been operating for over a decade demonstrates stability, experience, and a proven track record. Ensure the company is fully licensed, bonded, and insured before you hire them. Ask about any professional certifications that relate to your project, such as those from the National Roofing Contractors Association.
  • Warranties and guarantees: The best roofers provide strong guarantees from the shingle makers covering materials for 30+ years, together with at least a 5-year labor guarantee. Stay away from companies with shorter warranty periods.
  • References and reviews: Vet companies by checking the latest online reviews on sites like Google, Yelp, or the Better Business Bureau (BBB). Look for a history of consistently good feedback. Requesting local references is another great way to learn more about the customer experience.
  • Roofing materials and products: Quality roofing materials from top brands can handle Arcadia's weather and last decades. Avoid contractors pushing cheap or generic materials. Review shingle samples before deciding.
  • Detailed written estimate: Reputable roofers will offer a comprehensive written estimate that outlines the scope of the work, specific materials, and total cost without hidden fees. Avoid vague bids or quotes that seem dramatically high or low.
  • Responsiveness and communication: From estimate to project completion, your contractor should maintain ongoing communication with you, respond to all questions, and resolve any concerns.

Signs Your Roof Needs Repair or Replacement

Though most homeowners don't think about their roof every day, it provides critical protections for your home. Be attentive for these common signs that your roof may need inspection and repairs from a professional roofer.

Roof Age

Your roof's age and material are both important. The most popular residential roofing material is asphalt shingles, which generally last 20–25 years before requiring replacement. Have your roof evaluated if it’s approaching this age to determine if a full replacement is needed.

Leaks or Water Stains in Your Home

Leaks are a common sign of roof issues. Water leaking through damaged or worn shingles often leads to water stains on walls, insulation, and ceilings, or in your attic. Don't ignore even small leaks, as they can still lead to mold and other issues.

Exposed Roof Decking Underneath Shingles

If you can see roof decking or sheathing underneath your shingles, it means those shingles are curling substantially or losing their seal, and replacement is required. Shingles should lie flat to prevent water from entering your home.

Cracked, Broken, or Missing Shingles

Examine your shingles closely from a steady ladder or while on the ground. Look for shingles that show cracks or no longer have their protective granule layer. Storms can cause exterior damage over time. To keep your roof in good condition, replace any shingles that are no longer attached or have gaping holes.

Flashing Deterioration Around Roof Penetrations

Roof flashing provides a watertight seal around chimneys, valleys, vents, and other areas where water can penetrate your roof. Cracked, peeling or deteriorated flashing can allow leaks. We recommend quickly addressing any problems with the roof flashing that come up.

Sagging Roof Line

If your roof shows signs of sagging or unevenness, get a roofer to evaluate it. These issues could signal a structural problem. A sagging roof that's not given adequate structural reinforcement or full replacement will continue worsening over time.

Frequently Asked Questions About Roofing in Arcadia, NY

The best type of roofing material for your home in Arcadia will be determined by several factors, including your budget and how often you're willing to do maintenance.

Asphalt is more budget-friendly, while options like metal are more expensive but last longer. You also might choose a material like wood for its environmentally friendly nature.

New York does not require roofing contractors to hold a state-level license, however there may be local requirements. Make sure that you verify that your contractor meets any local licensing requirements before signing a contract.

The best time of year for a roof replacement is spring or fall. In the winter, Arcadia's cold temperatures can impede progress.

Your roof can absolutely impact how energy-efficient your home is. For example, a good roof helps you spend less energy heating your home during the winter months. Some materials (like metal) are more energy-efficient than others.

Insulation is important to think about, because a home with good insulation lowers your energy costs from heating and cooling your home. Spray foam insulation is one of the best types because it is long-lasting and moisture-resistant. It also seals gaps and cracks, preventing leaks. However, it is also more expensive compared to other kinds of insulation.

The best color for your roof is based on several factors like the style and color of your house and the local climate. For example, if you have a Spanish style home, then you'll probably want a terracotta roof to match the style. Also, those in a hot climate may want to avoid darker colors because they absorb heat, which makes cooling your home more difficult.

Other Arcadia, NY Home Services

Loading map...