Expert Advice On Improving Your Home

10 Best Roofers in New Castle, IN

Get matched with a top local pro.
Join more than 640 people who have gotten a free quote in the past week.

Written By David Cusick

Last Updated April 2024

Your roof serves many important functions, from keeping your heat in to keeping water out. However, caring for your roof isn't always simple. It's crucial that the roof of your New Castle home stands up to all sorts of weather without failing.

Whatever your circumstances are, there's a local roofing professional who understands and can help solve the problem. Follow our guide to discover the right roofers in New Castle.

Top 10 Best Roofers in New Castle

Erie Home

Erie Home Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
6925 Corporate Cir, Indianapolis, IN 46278 (317) 991-4779 eriehome.com

Free inspections

Transparent project updates

Quality customer service

Services Offered

Metal roofs
Roof repair
Replacement
Asphalt roofs

Regal Roofing & Construction

Regal Roofing & Construction Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
1701 Shopp Ave, New Castle, IN 47362 (765) 575-4763 regal911.com

Customer education

Preventive services

Transparent project updates

Free inspections

Transparent pricing

Quality customer service

Services Offered

Replacement
Roof repair

M L Taylor Construction

M L Taylor Construction Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
1851 Troy Ave, New Castle, IN 47362 (765) 529-8011 mltaylorconstruction.com

Quality customer service

Services Offered

Replacement

Clemens Home Solutions

Clemens Home Solutions Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
2222 S Madison St, Muncie, IN 47302 (765) 741-8214 clemenshomesolutions.com

Transparent project updates

Transparent pricing

Customer education

Quality customer service

Free inspections

Services Offered

Quality inspection
Replacement
Asphalt roofs
Rubber roofs
Roof repair

Rodeffer Roofing

Rodeffer Roofing Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
1415 S Meeker Ave, Muncie, IN 47302 (765) 729-5622 rodefferroofing.com

Quality customer service

Reputation for timeliness

Free inspections

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Flat roofs
Roof repair
Replacement
Quality inspection
Asphalt roofs
Metal roofs

Sherriff Goslin Roofing Muncie

Sherriff Goslin Roofing Muncie Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
205 W Ontario Dr, Muncie, IN 47303 (765) 286-0346 sherriffgoslin.com

Customer education

Free inspections

Preventive services

Quality customer service

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Mold remediation
Flat roofs
Quality inspection
Roof repair
Asphalt roofs
Replacement
Metal roofs

Superior Contracting

Superior Contracting Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
4109 Columbus Ave, Anderson, IN 46013 (317) 507-7663 507roof.com

Free inspections

Customer education

Transparent pricing

Transparent project updates

Quality customer service

Services Offered

Slate
Replacement

C & M Roofing, LLC

C & M Roofing, LLC Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
648 E 1000 N, Fortville, IN 46040 (317) 485-0316 cmroofingllc.com

Locally owned

Preventive services

Reputation for timeliness

Quality customer service

Transparent pricing

Free inspections

Customer education

Services Offered

Replacement
Quality inspection
Roof repair
Rubber roofs
Metal roofs

Ace Construction & Remodeling, Inc.

Ace Construction & Remodeling, Inc. Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
2700 Wheeling Ave # 7, Muncie, IN 47303 (765) 282-6030 aceconstructiononline.com

Free inspections

Quality customer service

Transparent pricing

Customer education

Services Offered

Replacement
Roof repair

Custom Metal Industries

Custom Metal Industries Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
2042 E Main St, Greenfield, IN 46140 (317) 462-9451 custommetalindustries.com

Preventive services

Transparent pricing

Free inspections

Customer education

Services Offered

Metal roofs
Replacement
Today's Homeowner Ranking Methodology

Today's Homeowner looks at dozens of datapoints on roofers to come up with our data-driven rankings. It's not possible for a company to pay for preferential treatment in our rankings. We look at the following key factors in determining who should top our list:

  • Company Experience
  • Real User Reviews
  • Company Reputation
  • Accreditations and Licenses
  • Service Area
  • Customer Service
Have questions about our methodology or company ratings? Reach out to FindAPro@TodaysHomeowner.com.

How Much Does a New Roof Cost in New Castle?

For a project as involved as roof replacement, cost matters. Below is the usual price range to replace a roof on a 1,500 square foot home in New Castle. We also compare costs for common roofing materials.

How To Choose a Roofing Company

Roof installation is a major home improvement project that can cost upwards of twenty thousand dollars in the end. It's essential to research and find the most skilled and reliable roofing professional for the job. Here are some key considerations when choosing a roofing contractor.

  • Responsiveness and communication: From estimate to project completion, your contractor should keep in consistent contact with you, respond to all questions, and handle any concerns.
  • Experience and credentials: Look for companies that have been operating for a decade or more. These companies' longevity and years in business reflects stability, expertise, and satisfied past clients. Confirm that a provider has appropriate licenses, bonds, and insurance before hiring. Also inquire about professional certifications, such as those from the National Roofing Contractors Association.
  • Warranties and guarantees: The best roofers provide strong guarantees from the shingle makers covering materials for 30+ years, together with at least a 5-year labor guarantee. Be cautious of companies with less robust coverage.
  • Detailed written estimate: Trustworthy roofing companies will offer a comprehensive written quote. This estimate should outline the complete work scope, materials, and total price with no surprise costs. Steer clear of unclear quotes, or ones that seem much too low or high.
  • References and reviews: Vet companies thoroughly by looking on Google, Yelp, or the Better Business Bureau (BBB) to see that they have a history of consistently positive feedback. Request recent local references from the company to learn more.
  • Roofing materials and products: Quality roofing companies sell quality materials that can handle New Castle's weather and endure a long time. Be careful of contractors pushing extremely low-cost or generic options. Check out shingle samples before committing.

Signs Your Roof Needs Repair or Replacement

You may not think about your roof every single day, but it protects your home in important ways. Be aware of these common signals that your roof needs to be checked and repaired by a professional roofer.

Roof Age

Your roof's age and material are key factors. Asphalt shingles, the most popular residential roofing material, generally last about 20 to 25 years before needing to be replaced. Have your roof evaluated if it’s nearing or past this lifespan to determine if full replacement is needed.

Leaks or Water Stains in Your Home

Leaks are a definite sign that your roof needs repair. Stains on walls, insulation, or ceilings, or in your attic often signal that water is getting through damaged or worn shingles. Even minor leaks should be taken care of promptly, as they can cause mold and more deterioration over time.

Exposed Roof Decking Underneath Shingles

If you can see roof sheathing or decking under shingles, it indicates that those shingles are considerably curling or losing their seal. This means it's time for replacement. Shingles need to lie flat to prevent water from getting into your home.

Cracked, Broken, or Missing Shingles

Inspect your shingles closely from a safe ladder or while on the ground. Look for shingles that show cracks or are missing granules. Storms can cause exterior damage over time. To keep your roof in working order, replace any missing shingles, or ones that are openly gaping.

Flashing Deterioration Around Roof Penetrations

Metal flashing on your roof seals off chimneys, vents, valleys, and other areas where water can leak in. If the flashing is becoming damaged, loose, or worn down, it may leak. Promptly take care of any flashing issues.

Sagging Roof Line

An uneven roofline may be a sign of a structural issue that requires professional attention. Without taking steps to fix or replace it, a sagging roof will get worse over time.

Frequently Asked Questions About Roofing in New Castle, IN

The best type of roofing material for your home in New Castle will depend on factors such as your budget and how often you want to do maintenance.

Metal costs more but lasts longer, while asphalt will be cheaper up front but won't last as long. Wood roofs have better insulation than many other materials, which can be very beneficial in the winter.

Contractor licensing in Indiana is handled at the municipality rather than the state level. Indiana businesses must have a state business license, but to verify the insurance and licensing requirements for roofing contractors in your area, you will need to contact your local municipality government.

Roof cleaning typically costs around $438 in New Castle. The exact price will depend on the square footage of your roof, its material, how many levels it has, and how thorough the cleaning will need to be.

Your roof can impact how energy-efficient your home is. For example, a good roof helps you spend less energy heating your home during the winter months. Some materials (like metal) are more energy-efficient than others.

Roofs should normally be cleaned about once a year. You may want to clean your roof more often if there's a buildup of mildew, mold, leaves, or moss.

Some roof replacement costs may be covered by your home insurance if you use one of your insurance company's preferred contractors (if it has any). It might be easier to get costs covered if the damage is due to a covered weather event such as a tornado. You should reach out to your home insurance company to find out if either of these situations apply to you.

Other New Castle, IN Home Services