Expert Advice On Improving Your Home

10 Best Pest Control Companies in New Castle, IN

Get matched with a top local pro.
Join more than 640 people who have gotten a free quote in the past week.

Written By David Cusick

Last Updated April 2024

Regardless of where you live, pests are a fact of life and encountering them is a headache. Homeowners and apartment dwellers who have a routine pest control plan in place can avoid encounters with these uninvited guests. Luckily, pest control companies can help take care of this for you.

There are many exterminators to choose from, which can make hard for homeowners to know which is best for them. That’s why we've reviewed plenty of options to find the best pest control companies in New Castle. Keep reading to learn more about each exterminator.

Our Recommended Providers

Top Pick
4.8/5
  • Covers 13 common pests in general plan
  • Offers wildlife removal
  • Extra treatments as needed at no extra cost
Comprehensive Service
4.7/5
  • Pest control guarantee
  • Treats over 15 common pests
  • Offers instant online quotes

Top 10 Best Pest Control Companies in New Castle

Terminix

Terminix Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
9855 Crosspoint Blvd Suite 106, Indianapolis, IN 46256 (317) 216-6234 terminix.com

No-cost inspections

Transparent pricing

Commitment to customer education

Services Offered

Mice
Ants
Bed bugs
Green pest control
Moths
Wildlife
General pest control
Flies
Ticks
Cockroaches
Wasps
Termites
Mosquitos
Prevention
Spiders
Silverfish

Orkin

Orkin Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
12690 W County Rd 550 S, Daleville, IN 47334 (765) 999-7001 orkin.com

Positive customer service reviews

Educational web content

Lack of hidden fees

Free inspection policy

Services Offered

Mosquitos
Bed bugs
Termites
Ants
Baiting
Green pest control
Fumigation
Wasps
Spiders
Cockroaches
Prevention
Wildlife
General pest control
Mice
Ticks

Tri-County Pest Control and Wildlife Services

Tri-County Pest Control and Wildlife Services Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
2513 IN-1, Cambridge City, IN 47327 (765) 478-5800 tri-countypestcontrolservices.com

Free inspections

Reviews praise customer service

Educational web content

Transparent pricing

Services Offered

Wasps
Wildlife
Bed bugs
Ants
Cockroaches
Fleas
Spiders
General pest control
Mosquitos
Bees

Bug-Out Pest Control LLC

Bug-Out Pest Control LLC Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
4500 W Kenn Dr, Muncie, IN 47302 (765) 716-0064 bug-outpestcontrol.com

Commitment to customer education

Free inspection policy

Services Offered

Bed bugs
Mice
Ants
General pest control
Cockroaches
Fleas
Spiders
Termites

Operation Kills Pest Control

Operation Kills Pest Control Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
3821 S Co Rd 900 W, Daleville, IN 47334 (765) 759-9232 operationkills.com

Transparent pricing

Positive customer service reviews

Educational web content

Services Offered

Spiders
General pest control
Ants
Cockroaches
Wildlife
Prevention
Termites
Bees
Ethical pest control
Green pest control

Pest Regulators

Pest Regulators Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
1801 W Glenn Ellyn Dr, Muncie, IN 47304 (765) 713-9886 pestregulators.com

Reviews praise customer service

Helpful homeowner content on its website

Transparent pricing

Free inspections

Services Offered

Ticks
Wildlife
Mosquitos
General pest control
Mice
Cockroaches
Bed bugs
Fleas
Baiting
Bees

American Pest Professionals

American Pest Professionals Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
2130 Doctor M.L.K. Jr Blvd, Muncie, IN 47303 (765) 288-7779 americanpestpros.com

Commitment to customer education

Free inspection policy

Positive customer service reviews

Lack of hidden fees

Services Offered

Green pest control
Bed bugs
Termites
Prevention
Mice
General pest control
Mosquitos

Baxter Pest Professionals

Baxter Pest Professionals Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
2130 Doctor M.L.K. Jr Blvd, Muncie, IN 47303 (765) 644-2533 pestprosfamily.com

Reviews praise customer service

No-cost inspections

Lack of hidden fees

Educational web content

Services Offered

Mosquitos
Bed bugs
Mice
Green pest control
General pest control
Prevention
Termites

Atlas Pest Solutions

Atlas Pest Solutions Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
810 Western Ave W, Connersville, IN 47331 (765) 825-3537 atlaspestandtermites.com

Transparent pricing

No-cost inspections

Continuous highly praised customer service reports

Commitment to customer education

Services Offered

Termites
Bed bugs
General pest control

AAA Exterminating Inc

AAA Exterminating Inc Logo

Our Rating

User Rating

Write a Review
4412 Conner St, Noblesville, IN 46060 (317) 773-3797 aaapests.com

Transparent pricing

Helpful homeowner content on its website

Positive customer service reviews

Free inspection policy

Preventative pest control services

Services Offered

Garden protection
Termites
Fleas
Mice
General pest control
Beetles
Cockroaches
Bees
Bed bugs
Ants
Spiders
Green pest control
Wasps
Prevention
Today's Homeowner Ranking Methodology

Today's Homeowner looks at dozens of datapoints on pest control companies to come up with our data-driven rankings. It's not possible for a company to pay for preferential treatment in our rankings. We look at the following key factors in determining who should top our list:

  • Company Experience
  • Real User Reviews
  • Company Reputation
  • Accreditations and Licenses
  • Service Area
  • Customer Service
Have questions about our methodology or company ratings? Reach out to FindAPro@TodaysHomeowner.com.

Top Pest Control Brands in New Castle

The team at Today's Homeowner has narrowed down the best pest control companies so you can find the right provider for you. We analyzed costs, customer reviews, state availability, pest control treatments offered, contracts, and more.

Here’s how New Castle’s top providers ranked:

Terminix

Terminix has several hundred branches in more than 22 countries and has been in the pest control industry for almost 100 years. It uses the latest pest control techniques to rid your property of pests no matter where they are.

Terminix helps with many types of pests in New Castle, and it offers a 30-day guarantee. Terminix’s general pest regimen consists of a home inspection and preliminary treatment, with three additional treatments during the year.

Orkin

Founded in 1901 by a rat poison salesman named Otto, the Orkin brand has grown to be one of the most reputable in the pest control industry. It has excellent consumer reviews and qualified exterminators who all complete 160 hours of training.

Orkin offers a professional property inspection to identify potential problems and draw up a suitable treatment plan. Each contract comes with a 30-day guarantee. If your pest problem isn't handled, your exterminator will return for another visit.

Rentokil

Rentokil is a respected name in pest control, with branches across the globe and nearly a century of experience in the industry. The large brand owns the North American pest control providers J.C. Ehrlich, Western Exterminator, and Presto-X.

Rentokil provides integrated pest management (IPM) services, which means your pest control specialist will focus on both getting rid of existing pests and preventing future infestations. Its services consist of preventative maintenance, treatment, and monitoring for pest infestations.

How To Choose a Pest Control Company

Pest control services aren't all the same when it comes to credibility, expertise, and competence. It’s important to research providers to find the right one for your specific circumstance. Here are the key factors to consider when selecting a pest control company:

Services Offered

You should choose a pest control company that can effectively address your specific problem, whether it's roaches, bed bugs, termites, rodents, or something else. The company should clearly describe on their website its expertise with your specific pest.

Expertise

When selecting a pest control provider, look for technicians that have the proper state licensing and are certified in pest control methods by industry associations such as the National Pest Management Association (NPMA). Obtaining these credentials shows that a technician has adequate training. Ask the company about its policies for continuing education and the total training hours required for technicians.

Experience and Reputation

Look through reviews on Google, Yelp, and similar sites prior to booking a pest control appointment. Verify for yourself that the company reliably provides effective service and a positive customer experience. Also check for any Better Business Bureau complaints that have been filed. Ask whether technicians receive ongoing education on the most cutting-edge pest control treatments. When you choose a provider from our list of New Castle's best pest control, you can rest easy knowing you're hiring an expert that meets our quality and review standards.

Green Pest Control

If you prefer more eco-friendly and natural pest control solutions, look for providers that have "green" certifications. If you’re dealing with larger pests, such as mice or squirrels invading your attic, you can also ask about humane catch and release methods. Bear in mind that natural pest control options may be less effective; consider a more traditional route for a more serious infestation. No matter your approach to pest control, any pesticides (besides those classified as minimal risk) are required to be registered with the EPA.

Reservice Guarantee

Reputable pest control professionals usually offer service warranties for continuing plans. The guarantees mean that a company will return to re-treat your home at no cost if pests remain after the first treatment. One-off treatments might not include these reservice warranties.

Questions To Ask Pest Control Companies

Once you have identified a few highly reviewed exterminator services, have conversations with each of them and be prepared to ask these types of questions:

  • How often will you need to treat my property once the initial treatment is complete? Most companies offer regular, semi-regular, or annual service plans to check for reinfestations.
  • What results can I realistically expect to see after the initial and follow-up services? The company should provide a clear timeline for when pests will be eliminated.
  • When can you start the treatment process at? You'll want to begin treatment ASAP before the infestation worsens.
  • Can you provide a complete cost analysis and service plan in writing upfront? This lets you compare exterminator pricing and avoid companies that have unclear terms and conditions or tack on hidden fees.
  • What pest control techniques and approaches does your company use? Make sure the techniques align with your goals for more standard treatment plans versus natural options. Get details about the pesticides or chemicals that the company will use.

Analyze potential pest control providers using these questions. This will help you hire the best provider to safely and effectively get rid of your pest problem at a reasonable price.

Most Common Pests in New Castle

There are a variety of pests in New Castle, ranging from harmless nuisances to ones that can damage your home. For an idea of the most widespread pests in the city, we examined the pests discussed in around 10 million posts on various social media sites.

Below is a brief list of some of the most common pests: <Ul><Li>Spiders</Li><Li>Ticks</Li><Li>Mice</Li><Li>Cockroaches</Li><Li>Bees</Li><Li>Moths</Li></Ul>

Frequently Asked Questions About Pest Control in New Castle, IN

The best pest control companies are Orkin and Terminix. They cover all common pests, service many locations, and have been in the industry for a long time.

Hiring a pest control company and having a professional spray your property once every quarter is the best way to prevent future pest infestations. This deters insects and animals from coming inside your house.

To find the right pest control company for you, the key is to take your time and research your options thoroughly. We recommend getting quotes from several companies and looking at reviews to help figure out which company is the best for you.

Many New Castle homeowners wonder about the cost of pest control. Monthly pest control typically costs $40 to $70 per visit. Quarterly pest control costs about $110 to $250 per visit. To determine exactly how much it will cost for you, we recommend getting in touch with several pest control providers for a quote.

We advise quarterly pest control, or even bi-monthly if needed. For more serious infestations, your exterminator may recommend monthly treatments over the course of the first three to six months.

Other New Castle, IN Home Services