Gutters are an integral part of a roofing system. If they don’t perform, poorly diverted rainwater can damage your roof and home. One way to ensure proper functionality is to keep gutters free of debris. Investing in gutter guards can help.

But not all gutter guards are alike. We’ve curated this comprehensive review of All American Gutter Protection through our extensive research of the top gutter guard companies.

Read our All American Gutter Protection review to learn more about this company before you commit.

4.1

Our Rating

Based on our 23 point rating system.
GET QUOTE
Exclusive Offer:
Save $300 on full-home installations
BBB Rating:
A
Year Founded:
2015
States Covered:
15 states
Avg. Cost:
$15-$20 per linear foot

Our Preferred Gutter Guard Brands

If you need a whole new set of gutters read our article on our top-rated gutter installers and get a free quote below.

Top Pick

275-micron stainless steel mesh design

Lifetime installation warranty

Offers new gutter installation services

GET QUOTE
Limited Time:
Get 15% Off Your Full-Service Gutter Installation
Most Durable

Manufactured to match your home

One-piece system includes a guard and gutter

Guaranteed not to clog

GET QUOTE
Limited Time:
75% Off Installation
Best Customer Service
gutter guards america logo

Sturdy aluminum frame and steel screens

Offers 0% financing

Provides gutter repair & installation

GET QUOTE
Limited Time:
Get $500 off in select locations!
Highlights
  • All American Gutter Protection ranks well in our overall review, particularly for its excellent customer service and warranty protections.
  • The company has an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, meaning it can be trusted to address any complaints seriously
  • A range of services is offered to customers, including cleaning and repair

What’s Our Review of All American Gutter Protection?

All American Gutter Protection is a full-service company that sells gutter guards and does gutter guard installation for residential and commercial buildings. The company provides rainwater management for homeowners in 16 states, mostly in the East and Midwest.

Pros and Cons of Choosing All-American Gutter Protection

The tabs below display high-level pros and cons of All American Gutter Protection. We suggest keeping these points in mind as you read the rest of the review.

Significant discounts are available
30 gutter guard colors are available
Estimates are honored for one year
Only operates in 16 states
No DIY option is available

What We Do and Don’t Like About All American Gutter Protection

Now, navigate the tabs below to see some more in-depth benefits and drawbacks of this popular gutter guard company.

We like that All American Gutter Protection offers a range of gutter services and products. Other companies have a limited color selection when it comes to their gutter guards, and some only offer one color. All American Gutter Protection offers a palette of 30 colors, ensuring you’ll find one to match your home’s exterior paint and roof color.

Customers who want to install gutter guards across their entire home can also take advantage of a 20% or $300 discount. These promotions can be combined with a 10% discount for seniors or the military — significant savings per industry standards.

We like the fact that All American Gutter Protection honors its estimates for an extended period because not many competitors do this. It gives you time to consider your investment.

Lastly, we really like that the company has many positive customer reviews that mention friendly and prompt service.

We don’t like that unless you live in the company’s limited service area, you must consider other options. Most gutter guard companies operate nationwide.

Unfortunately, you can’t save money by installing All American Gutter Protection gutter guards on your own because it doesn’t have a DIY option like some competitors.

Although we like that All American Gutter Protection backs its products with a performance warranty for the life of your home, the language of the warranty is vague. For customers who want reassurance that a company will honor a warranty without issue, unspecific language in its lifetime warranty offer may be a drawback.


Where Are All American Gutter Protection Gutter Guards Available?

All American Gutter Protection operates in 16 states, primarily along the East Coast and the Midwest. Although we believe the company will expand, it’s limited to the following service area:


Video Overview of All American Gutter Protection

The video below provides insight into All American’s installation process. It also provides a visual demonstration of how its gutter guards work to keep your gutter clean and debris-free.


Compare All American Gutter Protection to Competitors

Comparing the best gutter guard companies is a great way to determine the best choice for your home. The table below shows how All American Gutter Protection stacks up to its top competitors:

CompanyLogoProduct ImageOur RatingBBB RatingLink

A+

A+

B

A

gutter guards america logo

A+

A+

F

NR

CompanyOur RatingBBB RatingBest For
GET QUOTE

A+

Best Professional Installation & Cost

GET QUOTE

A+

Most Durable

GET QUOTE

B

Best-Designed Gutter Guards

GET QUOTE

A

Best Performance Warranty

gutter guards america logo
GET QUOTE

A+

Best Customer Service

GET QUOTE

A+

Best DIY Option

GET QUOTE

F

Best Mesh Gutter Guard

GET QUOTE

NR

Best Brush Option


How Do All American Gutter Protection Gutter Guards Work?

As an integral part of your roofing system, gutters collect rainwater from the roof and divert it away from your home. But gutters won’t function properly when they get clogged with leaves, twigs, fallen pine and magnolia cones, and other debris. If clogged, they can’t channel water into a nearby downspout. Instead, water will overflow the gutters, causing potential water damage to the fascia or foundation of your home. Excess water can damage landscaping and walkways.

Gutter guard systems keep debris out of gutters and let water flow correctly. They sit on top of your gutter or snap into place within the frame of the gutter. All American Gutter Protection gutter guards fit seamlessly into gutters, ensuring proper gutter performance.

All American Gutter Protection gutter guards use the highest quality stainless steel micro-mesh and aluminum body. This micro-mesh catches debris as small as shingle granules, preventing gutter clogs.

The company’s gutter guards also deter pests, such as insects and squirrels, from nesting in your gutters. In all, these high-quality gutter guards protect your home.

Credit: All American Gutter Protection
Today’s Homeowner Tips
Gutter guards are a solid investment if you want to save money on annual maintenance costs. Although some gutter guards have a high price tag, the cost of installing them will be recouped quickly without a need for frequent gutter maintenance.

What Services Does All American Gutter Protection Offer?

A full-service provider, All American Gutter Protection is well-equipped to tackle any gutter-related needs. Whether your old gutters need replacing or the fascia needs repair, All American Gutter Protection can take care of it. Here are the services the company offers:

  • Gutter guard installation
  • Downspout installation
  • Gutter cleaning
  • Gutter repair
  • New gutter installation
  • Removal and disposal of old gutters

Not all gutter guard companies offer such comprehensive services. All American Gutter Protection makes its guards from warp- and crack-resistant aluminum, delivering a long-lasting product that withstands harsh winter and summer weather. 

Top Pick

275-micron stainless steel mesh design

Lifetime installation warranty

Offers new gutter installation services

GET QUOTE
Limited Time:
Get 15% Off Your Full-Service Gutter Installation
Most Durable

Manufactured to match your home

One-piece system includes a guard and gutter

Guaranteed not to clog

GET QUOTE
Limited Time:
75% Off Installation
Best Customer Service
gutter guards america logo

Sturdy aluminum frame and steel screens

Offers 0% financing

Provides gutter repair & installation

GET QUOTE
Limited Time:
Get $500 off in select locations!

How Much Do All American Gutter Protection Gutter Guards Cost?

All American Gutter Protection doesn’t publish its prices online — typical for industry providers. But the cost of your system depends on the condition of your existing gutters, the length of your gutter system, and the complexity of your roof.

While prices vary, All American Gutter Protection offers several discounts. Among them:

  • 10% discount for United States military personnel, active duty, reserve, or retire
  • 10% discounts for seniors aged 60 or older
  • 20% off an entire-home gutter guard system
  • $300 offan entire-home gutter guard system

The military and senior discounts can be combined with the other offers. These promotions can equate to major savings on your project overall.

What’s All American Gutter Protection’s Gutter Guard Estimate Process?

To get a free quote from All American Gutter Protection, schedule an on-site home inspection. A representative will visit your home, inspect your gutters, and take measurements. After that, the company will make recommendations and send you an estimate, which will include costs.

all american gutters on a shingled roof

Do All American Gutter Protection Gutter Guards Save You Money?

Installing gutter guards has multiple long-term benefits, all of which can save you money. All American Gutter Protection guards can help you save time and money on regular gutter maintenance and home repairs.

Home repair specialists recommended you clean up your gutters at least twice a year. Gutter guards from All American Gutter Protection help keep leaves and debris out of your gutters, practically eliminating the cost of having your gutters cleaned multiple times a year and saving you hundreds of dollars in expenses. Gutter guards help your gutters perform better, saving you money by reducing the risk of rot or damage to your fascia and other parts of your home.

Buying gutter guards from All American Gutter Protection is an investment in a quality product and can extend the life of your gutters. With less debris buildup and protection from misdirected water, you won’t need to replace your gutters as frequently, resulting in long-term savings.


Will All American Gutter Protection Gutter Guards Eliminate the Need for Gutter Cleaning?

Regardless of their quality, gutter guards won’t eliminate the need for gutter cleaning. But installing them will reduce the frequency of needed cleaning. All American Gutter Protection gutter guards are made with micro-mesh, which helps prevent even small debris from getting into your gutter.

Although cleanings will be required less frequently, you should inspect your gutters once a year to ensure everything is working as it should. We recommend doing this in early spring. Springtime brings heavy rains, and ensuring you have no issues with rainwater is essential. If you discover a collection of debris, remove it to prepare for rainy weather.


All American Gutter Protection Reviews

All American Gutter Protection has an accreditation from the Better Business Bureau (BBB). The company holds an A+ rating from the BBB, meaning the company takes complaints seriously and handles them in a way that customers appreciate.

While some customers have noted issues with their gutters post-installation, the company resolved them by correcting the problems. Other customers rave about their positive experiences with the company, citing a quick installation process and the company honoring an old quote even though the prices had increased.

We would recommend All American Gutter Protection for your gutter guard needs based on our customer experience research. The company honors its word and takes responsibility for any errors.


So, Are All American Gutter Protection Gutter Guards Worth It?

In our opinion, All American Gutter Protection gutter covers are worth the financial investment. They can reduce the annual maintenance costs of your home, saving you valuable time and money. The company’s vast color selection is unique to the industry, making it easy to fit your gutter guards seamlessly into your home’s aesthetic.

We also like that the company is positively reviewed. Even though the Lifetime Performance Warranty is slightly vague, based on other customers’ experiences, the company works hard to resolve any issues with a gutter system and stands by its workmanship.

Below are a few of our top recommendations:

Top Pick

275-micron stainless steel mesh design

Lifetime installation warranty

Offers new gutter installation services

GET QUOTE
Limited Time:
Get 15% Off Your Full-Service Gutter Installation
Most Durable

Manufactured to match your home

One-piece system includes a guard and gutter

Guaranteed not to clog

GET QUOTE
Limited Time:
75% Off Installation
Best Customer Service
gutter guards america logo

Sturdy aluminum frame and steel screens

Offers 0% financing

Provides gutter repair & installation

GET QUOTE
Limited Time:
Get $500 off in select locations!

FAQs About All American Gutter Protection

What is the difference between leaf guards and gutter guards?

Gutter guards are installed inside or on top of your gutters. Leaf guards are mounted away from your roof and shingles.


Is there a gutter guard that really works?

In short, yes. While gutter guards don’t eliminate the need to clean your gutters, they significantly reduce the effort to maintain them.


What is the most durable gutter guard?

The most durable gutter guards are made from stainless steel. All American Gutter Protection uses high-quality stainless steel in its products, ensuring durable gutter guards.


What are the disadvantages of gutter guards?

Gutter guards are not without drawbacks. While cleaning your gutters becomes less frequent, you’ll still need to clean them, and having gutter guards can make the task more difficult.



Methodology: How We Ranked All American Gutter Protection Among Gutter Guard Companies

At Today’s Homeowner, we strive to bring you the most transparent, accurate information for your home improvement projects. Our gutter guard ratings emphasize what matters most to you — keeping your gutters debris-free for years to come.

Our ratings are based on publicly available information about each company, secret shopping online and over the phone, customer-review analysis, and interviews with former and current home improvement experts.

A company can earn a maximum of 100 points across six categories, converted to a five-star scale. We researched and analyzed over 50 gutter guards and developed the following formula:

  • Product Overview (15 points): Micro-mesh gutter guards are the best on the market. They screen even the smallest debris from your gutters and typically have the structural integrity to withstand heavy rainfall and accumulated debris from trees and surrounding foliage. We also curated a rating based on customer testimonials and our in-house testing to determine debris resistance. Guards with multiple color and sizing options also rated well in this category.
  • Services Offered (35 points): Gutter guard providers who offer a full range of services are rated highly here — gutter installation and removal, maintenance, and more factored into this rating.
  • Affordability (15 points): Though getting cost estimates for gutter guards typically require home visits, we ranked companies based on factors such as discount and financing programs, multiple easy payment options, and the increased value of service offerings.
  • Warranties (10 points): A company that stands behind its products and services will offer comprehensive warranties. We evaluated companies based on how extensive these warranties are.
  • Customer Service (10 points): We considered customer service availability and ease of communication.
  • Company Reputation (15 points): We looked into each company’s service record to determine how they treated clients and how they responded to customer complaints. Better Business Bureau (BBB) rating and complaint response rate were our primary metrics for this category.

We monitor company data on an ongoing basis to keep rankings and information up to date.


Editorial Contributors
avatar for Dani Straughan

Dani Straughan

Contributor

Dani Straughan is a content producer for Today’s Homeowner from Durham, North Carolina, with an extensive writing background across multiple industries, ranging from coffee to automotive parts. Dani specializes in creating empathetic content that helps readers make informed decisions about home products and services. When they’re not writing about DIY projects and roof care, you will likely find Dani building custom handcrafted furniture or going on nature walks with friends.

Learn More

photo of Lora Novak

Lora Novak

Senior Editor

Lora Novak meticulously proofreads and edits all commercial content for Today’s Homeowner to guarantee that it contains the most up-to-date information. Lora brings over 12 years of writing, editing, and digital marketing expertise. She’s worked on thousands of articles related to heating, air conditioning, ventilation, roofing, plumbing, lawn/garden, pest control, insurance, and other general homeownership topics.

Learn More

Read About Top Gutter Installers Near You