Sean Donnelly

Written By

Sean Donnelly

Sean Donnelly

Written By

Staff Writer

Sean Donnelly works to inform, engage, and motivate homeowners to take the reigns in making key decisions concerning homeownership and relocation. He is a content producer covering provider reviews, the homeownership and rental experience, real estate, and all things moving for Today’s Homeowner. Sean leverages his own experience within the moving industry to improve the consumer experience. He studied English literature and creative writing at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst.

Reviewed By

Lora Novak

Reviewed By

Lora Novak

Senior Editor

Lora Novak meticulously proofreads and edits all commercial content for Today’s Homeowner to guarantee that it contains the most up-to-date information. Lora brings over 12 years of writing, editing, and digital marketing expertise. She’s worked on thousands of articles related to heating, air conditioning, ventilation, roofing, plumbing, lawn/garden, pest control, insurance, and other general homeownership topics.

Updated On

May 18, 2023

Why You Can Trust Us

Today’s Homeowner exists to help you maintain or improve your home safely and effectively. We uphold strict editorial standards and carefully vet the advice and resources referenced in our articles. Click below to learn more about our review process and how we earn money.

Learn More

    As a homeowner, gutter installation and upkeep may not rate highly on your list of urgent tasks. However, a top-notch gutter system will go a long way toward preventing damage to your roof, foundation, and landscaping on your property. Here, we’ve outlined our picks for the industry’s best repair and installation companies. Read on to learn more about:

    • What to expect when planning for gutter installation
    • How to plan for such a large-scale project
    • How much gutter installation should cost

    If you feel that you already have a functional system, and are just looking for an upgrade, then our review of the best gutter guards may interest you.

    Our Top Gutter Installers

    1. LeafFilter Gutter Guards: Best Professional Installation
    2. HomeCraft Gutter Protection: Best Design
    3. All American Gutter Protection: Most Customizable
    4. LeafGuard: Best Seamless Gutters
    5. Mr. Handyman: Most Gutter Services Offered

    1. LeafFilter Gutter Guards

    LeafFilter was founded in 2005 and was initially run out of founder Matt Kaulig’s home. Now, more than 15 years later, it is one of the leading options for all gutter protection needs. Although it is a nationwide provider, LeafFilter operates from a single corporate office to ensure quality in all locations.

    The three-piece construction this provider offers can be installed on most existing gutters and is designed to keep even the smallest debris out of your system. With high-quality hangers and a micro-mesh screen that won’t corrode, this system ensures minimal clean-up for the life of your gutters.

    Key Features

    • 275-micron micromesh filter keeps everything out of your gutters, including shingle grit and pollen.
    • Lifetime warranty provided with purchase
    • Full-gutter installation service available
    • All quotes are good for an entire year after they’ve been given

    What Customers are Saying

    LeafFilter averages a 4.4 across more than 87,000 reviews on Trustpilot. It has been accredited by the Better Business Bureau since 2005 and now carries an A+ rating. Customers rate the professional conduct and general quality of the workers reasonably well.

    The quote process is usually fairly quick, with few hiccups. Some common complaints we were able to find remarked upon LeafFilter’s highball initial pricing offers. However, clients could negotiate these down to a reasonable figure in most cases.

    To get a free quote from LeafFilter, fill out this form or call 1-800-290-6106

    Read our LeafFilter review to learn more.

    2. HomeCraft Gutter Protection

    HomeCraft Gutter Protection is a family-owned business that was founded in 2016. Since then, it has provided leading service to clients across 12 states and has become one of the best all-around options for gutter guards.

    HomeCraft has helped more than 20,000 homeowners improve their gutter systems in just over six years with its unique raised-screen technology. 304 marine-grade micro-mesh with raised diamonds aims to keep even the smallest bits of debris away from your existing gutters and prevent clogs.

    Key Features

    • Patented raised-screen design keeps debris out of your gutters
    • Quality labor ensures that gutters guards remain fastened to the gutters themselves
    • Seven color options to choose from
    • Can be installed on homes with metal roofs
    • Lifetime transferable warranty included with gutter guards and gutters

    What Customers are Saying

    HomeCraft Gutter Protection currently holds a B rating with the Better Business Bureau. Along with this, many of its local affiliates across its ten-state operating area maintain excellent ratings. Common praise for this provider mentions fast service and turnaround time between the quote period and installation.

    However, the 3.5-star rating it currently has on BBB does include some negative feedback. Many customer complaints have arisen from confusion, overestimates, and what work should be included under a given contract. The best way to avoid this is to obtain copies of any contracts or estimates you’re given and by getting in-person quotes.

    For a free quote from HomeCraft, follow this link or call 1-855-275-1170.

    Read our HomeCraft review to learn more.

    3. All American Gutter Protection

    All American Gutter Protection was founded in 2015 and has already become one of the leaders in the industry. The consistently great reviews it has received are a product of its quality service offerings and product, all backed by its lifetime performance guarantee.

    This is a true full-service gutter installer that can provide equal service, whether you just want gutter guards on your current system or need a complete gutter system with fascia replacement. The only downside to this provider is its relatively limited service area.

    Key Features

    • More than 30 color options to choose from
    • Offers veteran and senior discounts for service
    • Can replace and install gutters, gutter guards, and fascia
    • Provides service to Alabama, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Indiana, Kentucky, Michigan, New Jersey, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, Virginia, and West Virginia

    What Customers are Saying

    All American Gutter Protection has been a BBB-accredited business since its second year in business and now has an A+ rating with a 4+ star rating. Beyond this, Yelp and Google reviews will depend entirely on your location. With any national or regional company, you’ll have to find reviews from your area to get a complete picture of how your service should turn out.

    All American’s seamless aluminum gutters are among the best around, and customer reviews reflect that. This company promises on-site estimates within two to three days and quick installation. The most common issues seem to arise from warranty disputes and subpar quality of work. These can be avoided by looking up location-specific reviews and reviewing your warranty terms so you know what’s covered.

    To get a free quote from All American, follow this link or call 1-888-305-8759.

    Read our All American review to learn more.

    4. LeafGuard

    LeafGuard is one of the best options for seamless gutters and gutter guards and has been since 1993. Nearly 30 years later, they’ve earned a reputation for quality with consumers and from industry peers.

    Take a look at our full LeafGuard review for more information.

    LeafGuard gutter systems are an option that is fully geared towards professional installation. When you book with the experts at this company, you’ll be treated to a custom seamless gutter system. All will be measured and assembled on-site, with thicker gutter material, large downspouts, and a unique one-piece gutter and gutter guard construction. The warranties are offered to ensure you’ll never have to worry about clogs or too much maintenance.

    Key Features

    • Lifetime clog-free guarantee (or cleaning is free)
    • One-piece system minimizes gaps and clogs
    • Aluminum construction is 20% thicker than industry standards

    What Customers are Saying

    LeafGuard currently has an A+ rating on Better Business Bureau, although its overall rating with that site is fairly low at 1.5 stars. This shouldn’t be a total red flag to potential clients, as single sites can sometimes become de facto message boards for companies in any industry to deal with complaints. LeafGuard still has many excellent reviews on third-party sites for its smaller locations.

    Common complaints stem from steep pricing and shoddy installation practices. Gutters and downspouts not adhering to the fascia or siding are far more an issue of quality of the individual location you book with than the product itself.

    Click this link to get a free quote from LeafGuard, or call 1-800-LEAF-GUARD.

    For more information, read our LeafGuard vs. LeafFilter Review.

    5. Mr. Handyman

    Mr. Handyman is less a gutter expert than it is a full-scale home maintenance vendor. They provide a full suite of home maintenance services designed to make your homeownership experience far more manageable. For your gutter installation needs, they’ll be able to assist in all phases, including gutter cleaning, roof repairs, fascia replacement, and more.

    Key Features

    • Provides numerous exterior and interior home services, including electrical and plumbing
    • More than 200 franchises throughout the U.S.
    • Offers gutter and gutter guard installation, as well as fascia and roofing repairs

    What Customers are Saying

    Mr. Handyman maintains an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau and has gotten high marks across social media, Yelp, Google, and numerous other platforms. Due to the large area this home improvement and renovation expert covers, average scores across these sites are tough to come by.

    Positive experiences with Mr. Handyman result from a speedy quote process and quality labor. Negative reviews have reported everything from inconsistent estimates to fees charged for quotes and unprofessional work crews. Your experience will hinge on the quality of the location that you book with. As is the case with many nationally-known providers, there is no guarantee of uniform service in all branches.

    To get a free quote from Mr. Handyman, follow this link or call 877-685-1377.

    Buying Guide for Gutters

    Below, we’ve listed some key factors you’ll absolutely have to consider before hiring gutter replacement services or a general contractor. Shopping around is important when preparing for any home repair task. If you evaluate your options using the criteria here, then you’ll be able to hire the best provider for your needs.


    Of course, overall quality and workmanship should be at the top of your list when vetting different options to install gutters. Customer reviews will be the best single tool for evaluating this. Looking into Google, Yelp, BBB, and social media reviews should help in this area. When you do this, look for client opinions on a given provider’s customer care, gutter expertise, product quality, and cost fairness.


    New gutters are priced per linear foot of material. The cheapest option is vinyl gutters, followed by aluminum, steel, and copper gutters. If you’re paying for a professional installation service, then the nominal fees will include material and labor costs. Also included will be fees for any other parts in your gutter system, such as hangers, flashing, brackets, gutter covers, and more.

    To get an idea of the material costs, review the following table:

    Gutters$3 – $6/ foot$5 – $12/ foot$8 – $15/ foot$25 – $40/ foot
    Hangers$1.50 – $3$2 – $4$3 – $5$18 – $22
    Endcaps$5 – $12$8 – $14$9 – $14$8 – $20
    Downspouts$4 – $8/ foot$5 – $9/ foot$8 – $12/ foot$15 – $25/ foot
    Elbows$3 – $5$4 – $13$12 – $15$15 – $20
    Splash blocks$8 – $12$8 – $12$8 – $12$8 – $12
    Flashing$4 – $25/ 10 feet$4 – $25/ 10 feet$4 – $25/ 10 feet$4 – $25/ 10 feet
    Total gutter installation cost$900 – $2,000$1,400 – $7,000$3,000 – $7,500$8,000 – $11,500


    If you’re considering hiring a handyman or gutter installer, then you’ve probably at least considered the logistics of a DIY repair or replacement. Gutter maintenance can be tricky, as can any labor that involves heights and extension ladders. Generally, you should opt for professional assistance for any multi-story home. DIY fixes for vinyl or aluminum gutters or downspouts on a one-story home are doable with the right tools and knowledge. However, we would still recommend at least getting a consultation from a gutter or roofing company.


    Of course, curb appeal is a big plus for any visible home improvement projects or upgrades. Many high-quality companies will offer a range of gutter colors and design features that can fit the profile of most homes. The look of your rain gutters should come second to quality, but some companies offer enough options for you to have both.

    Size Options

    Another factor to keep in mind is gutter size. Apart from gutter style (k-style, half-round, etc.), gutters come in a few different widths. The most commonly used is a six-inch width. This will work well for most homes. If you have a larger tile or metal roof, then you’ll have to go with seven-inch gutters.


    Most gutter services will come with warranties. These will include gutter repair for water damage caused by holes or leaks in your gutter system. Some warranties will be for the lifetime of the product and will include cleaning services, which can save you money on gutter cleaning costs. You’ll have to ask about this during the quote process to be sure of your exact coverage.

    The Top Gutter Installer Comparison

    Here, we’ve included a quick comparison of our top providers for gutter installation services. No matter the type of gutters or kind of service you’re in the market for, you’ll be able to find an excellent option here.

    ProviderCostStates CoveredNotable feature
    LeafFilter Gutter Guards$2,600 – $6,300*43 statesThree-piece gutter guard system keeps all debris away, including pollen and shingle grit.
    All American Gutter ProtectionContact for a quote13 statesGutter guards are available in more than 30 different colors and can match most homes.
    HomeCraft Gutter Protection$4.50 to $8 per linear foot12 statesPatented raised diamond screens ensure proper water flow to gutters.
    LeafGuard$2,400 – $7,500*36 states Seamless unified construction uses liquid adhesion to separate rainwater from debris.
    Mr. HandymanContact for a quote38 states Offers a wide range of gutter and home services.

    *Average full-system cost

    Final Thoughts on The Highest Rated Gutter Installers

    Get a Gutter Guard Installation Quote in 30 Seconds

    Enter your zip code

    Installing the best possible gutter system on your home is a huge step toward ensuring long-term easy upkeep. Having sturdy and reliable gutters and gutter guards will prevent clogs, minimize roof cleaning and maintenance, and will prevent water damage to your home and property as a whole.

    When you shop around for companies to handle your gutter work, you should consider the factors we’ve outlined here and take your time to go over your options. Whether you’re in the market for gutter cleaning services, gutter guard installation, or a full system overhaul, you owe it to yourself and your home to make the best possible choice.

    Gutter Installation FAQ

    Are seamless gutters more expensive?

    Generally, you’ll pay more per linear foot for seamless gutters than you would for sectional. You should also be aware of other factors, such as gutter material or type and how many stories your home is, prior to calling a licensed pro. These factors will influence your cost.

    How often should I have my gutters cleaned?

    Whether you choose to make this a DIY project or hire a cleaning service, this will depend on where you live. Climate, seasonal weather, on-property landscaping, and more will all play a part in determining this. If you don’t have gutter guards and live in an area where leaves and pine needles can accumulate, then you may need to do this every couple of months.

    How much does gutter removal cost?

    This is usually folded into the cost of gutter installation services and will be included in the overall quote you’re given. It will amount to around $100 to $200 of your final cost and will include the disposal of your old gutters.

    How we Ranked, Reviewed, and Tested the Best Gutter Guards

    Here, we’ve broken down our rating methodology for gutter guards. You should know that we’ve taken the utmost care to provide the most up-to-date information and to ensure that you make the best choice for your budgetary and home maintenance needs.

    Why Trust Today's Homeowner? Our Gutter Ranking Methodology

    At Today's Homeowner, transparency and trust are our most important values for the reader. We’ve done the homework for you and have researched over 50 gutter guards so you can have the information you need to make the best choice for your home. That’s why we took the time to create an objective rating system and score each gutter guard and gutter guard provider company according to our gutter ranking methodology.

    We also dug into the details of each gutter guard to ensure that you could make the best decisions for your home and keep your gutters debris-free for years to come.

    To make the most of our research, we developed a formula to objectively determine the best gutter guards based on the following criteria:

    • Material: Material durability was the single most important factor that went into our rating methodology for gutter guards. Whether they were stainless steel micro-mesh or plastic screening, we gave an in-depth rating for this criteria.
    • Debris Resistance: Our testing served as the primary evaluator for this factor. We curated a rating based on customer testimonials and our own in-house testing here.
    • Ease of Installation: Most of the gutter guard options listed have some DIY component involved. For this reason, guards that required the fewest specialty tools got the highest rating here.
    • Cost: How reasonable are prices in comparison to the industry average? We compared the costs of each company to competitors.
    • Warranty terms: We looked into the warranty of lifetime warranty terms if it is offered by the provider.
    • Trust: What do customers rate the company? We looked into what customers are saying about their experience with the company.
    • Buying process: if the gutter guard is a DIY installation, how easy is the buying process? We looked for shipping costs and shipping time, as well as where the product can be bought from.

    Editorial Contributors
    Sean Donnelly

    Sean Donnelly

    Staff Writer

    Sean Donnelly works to inform, engage, and motivate homeowners to take the reigns in making key decisions concerning homeownership and relocation. He is a content producer covering provider reviews, the homeownership and rental experience, real estate, and all things moving for Today’s Homeowner. Sean leverages his own experience within the moving industry to improve the consumer experience. He studied English literature and creative writing at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst.

    Learn More

    Lora Novak

    Senior Editor

    Lora Novak meticulously proofreads and edits all commercial content for Today’s Homeowner to guarantee that it contains the most up-to-date information. Lora brings over 12 years of writing, editing, and digital marketing expertise. She’s worked on thousands of articles related to heating, air conditioning, ventilation, roofing, plumbing, lawn/garden, pest control, insurance, and other general homeownership topics.

    Learn More

    Connect With Local Gutter Pros in Your City