When it comes to constructing a building, light framing plays a crucial role in strength and stability. Choosing the right material for studs is a decision that can make or break your project’s final outcome.

Two of the best materials for studs are wood and metal, and each has its own set of advantages and disadvantages. Understanding the pros and cons of both metal and wood studs can help you figure out which works best for your construction project.

Read on for a breakdown of how they stack up against each other, as well as an alternative that could also be the ideal choice.

Benefits and Drawbacks of Metal Studs

The main advantage of metal studs is their low cost. They also stand up well in extreme weather. However, metal studs come up short in other areas. For instance, they aren’t as durable as you may think in high-heat conditions like fires. The lightweight steel weakens and breaks easily when exposed to flames. Metal screws are also prone to failure if you install them improperly or if they rust.

Metal Stud
Image Credit: Canva

Constructing a fire-rated building with metal studs requires adding extra layers of fire-resistant materials. Steel stud walls enable flames and smoke to spread faster. In a fire, sprinklers can’t reach past metal stud wall voids. Firefighters know that steel studs tend to collapse quicker than wood ones.

Metal studs are also inefficient at conserving energy — thermal bridging through steel results in over 50% more energy loss than other framing.

While metal studs are inexpensive up-front, you’ll pay more down the road to insulate your building to an acceptable level.

In rare cases, exposed sharp metal edges can wear down wire insulation over time. If bare wires contact the metal frame, it could electrify the structure and pose a hazard.

Benefits and Drawbacks of Wood Studs

The biggest advantage of wood is its strength, as it can support more weight without bending or breaking compared to metal. Additionally, wood is easier to cut and manipulate, making it a user-friendly option. It also provides better insulation for your home, which can lead to significant energy savings.

On the other hand, wood studs cost more up-front. Installation takes more time and requires additional tools. Rotting and warping from moisture are big risks that can potentially compromise your home’s structural integrity.

Wood isn’t a good fire performer as it tends to burn easily. Even though wood studs may take longer to collapse compared to metal studs, they will eventually fail without proper fireproofing.

With time, changes in temperature and humidity can result in expansion and contraction issues. However, proper construction techniques, such as leaving a small gap between the studs, can help address these issues.

ICF Blocks Are an Excellent Alternative

If you want to avoid the drawbacks of metal and wood studs, consider insulated concrete form (ICF) blocks. ICF is a complete wall system combining structure, insulation, and vapor barrier into one product. It offers builders faster installation, lower long-term costs, and better performance.

ICF blocks achieve the highest fire resistance rating. They’re also much more energy efficient than metal or wood framing. The interlocking block design is water and moisture-resistant as well as termite-proof.

Each block forms a grid to pour concrete into. The cured concrete core provides strength while the foam insulation surrounding it insulates your home. ICF is durable enough to withstand extreme weather and natural disasters. ICF deserves a close look if you value resilience, safety, and efficiency. You can find various ICF house plans available, too.

Key Takeaways When Comparing Stud Materials

These are the things to consider when it’s time to choose studs for your construction project.

  • Both metal and wood have tradeoffs to weigh for each project
  • Consider climate, budget, and timeline when choosing stud material
  • ICF blocks offer durability, fire resistance, and fast installation
  • Metal studs are inexpensive but prone to failure in fires and inefficient at insulating
  • Wood studs are strong but can warp and rot over time

So, Is One Stud Material Better Than the Other?

There is no one-size-fits-all solution for choosing the best stud material for your building. Both metal and wood studs have their own advantages and disadvantages that make them more suitable for certain uses.

Several factors, such as your climate, budget, timeline, and personal preferences, should be considered when making a decision. In areas that experience extreme weather conditions, metal studs may be more durable and preferable. If you’re on a tight budget, metal studs are also a more cost-effective option.

On the other hand, wood is known for its strength and insulation properties, but it comes with greater risks of rot, warping, and burning. Ultimately, you should evaluate each project independently to choose the type of stud that best fits your needs and limitations. It’s also worth considering ICF blocks, which are an emerging alternative that can address common stud issues.

FAQs About Metal and Wood Studs

What are the main differences between metal and wood studs?

The main differences are that metal studs are cheaper but weaker, while wood studs cost more but can bear heavier loads. Wood also insulates better. Metal won’t burn, but wood is combustible.

What gives steel studs their strength?

Steel studs’ C-shaped or U-shaped channel design increases their strength and rigidity. The open section allows you to run the utilities inside while still supporting structural loads. The thickness of the steel gauge also impacts strength.

Can you secure wood boards onto metal studs?

Yes, you can use self-tapping metal screws to secure wood boards, panels, or backers onto metal studs. Avoid splitting the wood by pre-drilling. Construction adhesive can also adhere wood to metal studs.

How far apart should exterior wall studs be spaced?

Building codes typically require studs spaced 16 inches on the center for exterior walls. This spacing provides sufficient structural integrity to handle wind loads, address insulation needs, and prevent bowing or sagging.

Why is moisture bad for wood studs?

Excess moisture causes wood studs to swell, warp, twist, bow, and split as they expand and contract. It also promotes rot and decay, inviting pests and compromising strength. Proper moisture barriers and ventilation alleviate these risks.

What gauge metal is used for 20-foot studs?

According to standards, 20-foot metal studs require a minimum thickness of 20 gauge steel for sufficient strength and rigidity. The higher the gauge number, the thinner the metal. We recommend using thicker 18- or 16-gauge for added durability.

Editorial Contributors
avatar for Abbie Clark

Abbie Clark


Abbie Clark is a writer and blogger. She is the founder of "Hey She Thrives", where she writes about all things motherhood, coupled with expert cleaning tips that echo the warmth and order of a loving home. She is also the co founder of "RideRambler." There, you can find all of the info you'll ever need on DIY car fixes and Auto news.When not writing, you can find Abbie chasing her toddler, trying a new cookie recipe, or fishing with her husband.

Learn More

photo of Lori Zaino

Lori Zaino

Lori Zaino is a freelance writer and editor based in Madrid, Spain. With nearly two decades of editorial experience, she’s written and edited for publications like Forbes, CNN, Insider, NBC, Newsweek, The Points Guy, The Infatuation, and many others. Having just completed her first home renovation, she’s more interested in home improvements than ever, dedicated to bringing you fresh and accurate content to help you update your living spaces.

Learn More