This content was originally published on and has been republished here as part of a merger between our two businesses. All copy is presented here as it originally appeared there.

Photographs and text by Steve Gross & Susan Daley

The 1846 farmhouse is in an Upstate New York hamlet. Atop the dry-laid stone wall sit a salvaged pair of hand-carved capitals.

I can’t remember a time when I was not collecting something,“ says artist Marilynn Gelfman Karp, who summers with her family at her Greek Revival house high upon a ridge in the northern Catskills. There, an assortment of vintage kitchen implements has been artfully arranged on the wall above the sink, and advertising signs hawking products of long ago cover the walls of a bathroom. Stoneware crocks line the staircase steps. Throughout the house are displayed collections of patchwork quilts, old maps, unusual tools, handmade samplers, and 19th-century paintings. “Every object has a story to tell, and every collection is a biography,“ says Marilynn. Her interior is a kind of tribute to humble rural life, calling attention to the artistry of objects easily overlooked.

In the sitting area, a chestnut country desk still keeps matters of correspondence readily at hand.

The farmhouse was built in 1846 by a Thomas Lamont Sr., who embellished the façade with a fanlight in the gable and a robust portico framed by sturdy pilasters. Lamont also constructed a large barn and several tenement houses to rent to hired hands. “This was a typical hill farm,“ Marilynn explains, “with a shorter growing season than down in the lusher valley, and required much labor to sustain a family.“ Over the decades, the hardscrabble farm yielded dairy products, eggs, cider, and maple syrup, as well as lumber. The main product was butter, churned by a machine run by a large dog and shipped to markets in New York City. All was much the same until 1960, when the farm, no longer active, was sold to hunters who used it in season.

Marilynn and Ivan Karp bought the place in 1964, after searching through several states for “a country house where we could sit on a long porch facing an unspoiled view of mountains.“ The farmhouse was in bad repair, so the Karps immediately set about making it habitable. “The interior was a wreck; 22 layers of wallpaper and newspaper used as insulation hung from the ceiling, and a dismembered piano sat in the kitchen,“ Marilynn says. “The cast iron tub spanned the doorway from bath to bedroom-we had to step into it to cross the threshold.“

With renovations underway, the couple’s focus turned to acquiring objects from the local area to fill the house. Many of the things that attracted them, such as old choppers and washboards, were “just plumb worn-out,“ yet fascinating in their design and often-outmoded utility.

A Windsor high chair, a dark oak trestle table, and two old benches make up the dining area in the big room. Primitive cupboards retain their heavily worn finishes.

They selected things “that brought us a joyful sense of contemplation, in some cases coupled with actual usefulness,“ Marilynn recalls.

On the first floor, the couple created a large, open-plan room comprising a farmhouse kitchen along with dining and sitting areas. The space is furnished with sturdy, functional pieces, including primitive cupboards, Windsor chairs, an antique settle, and a country desk. The original native-wood floors gleam. A century-old worktable sits in the center of the kitchen area, where wine bottles can be uncorked and nuts shelled by devices clamped to the tables.

On part of their extensive acreage, the Karps created a terraced perennial garden bounded by high stone walls. For years the couple rescued architectural fragments from buildings that were being demolished in New York City, and they incorporated some of them in the gardens. Other fragments are displayed in a small private museum the couple created in a former store of the quiet hamlet.

An imposing 19th-century farm table with turned legs is the centerpiece of the working kitchen. It holds an old washboard along with a glass dome from a cheese shop.

For Marilynn Karp, collecting is a calling. She “scans the past, trying to prevent irreversible elimination.“ The finds are less frequent now, but she says she still enjoys the adventure of searching for objects of utility that inspire wonderment, and that share kinship with works of art.

Editorial Contributors
avatar for Old House Journal

Old House Journal

Founded in 1973, Old House Journal is the original authority when it comes to old-house restoration, traditional house styles, period kitchens, bath & kitchen restoration, DIY projects, gardens & landscaping, and more-- from Colonial and Victorian through Arts & Crafts and Mid-century Modern homes.

Learn More