The Most Popular Christmas Cookie in Every State

Nothing radiates holiday cheer quite like the smell of freshly baked Christmas cookies. As families across America prepare for the festive season, the debate over the best Christmas cookie recipe is as heated as ever. We conducted a nationwide survey, asking over 4,500 Americans about their preferred holiday treats to help settle the dispute. The results offer a fascinating glimpse into the country’s diverse cookie preferences, revealing both surprising regional variations and enduring classics that unite cookie lovers from coast to coast.

Survey Results: America’s Favorite Christmas Cookies

The survey results paint a picture of a nation united by its love for traditional favorites. While regional specialties certainly have their place, it’s clear that when it comes to holiday cookies, Americans tend to favor the classics.

Sugar Cookies and Chocolate Chip: The Reigning Champions

According to the survey, sugar cookies with frosting emerged as the clear winner, claiming the top spot in 21 out of 50 states. This festive favorite, with its soft, buttery base and colorful decorative icing, captures the spirit of the season for many Americans.

Hot on the heels of sugar cookies were chocolate chip cookies, which took the crown in 18 states. Despite not being a traditional Christmas cookie, the timeless appeal of this American classic appears to transcend seasons, making it a holiday favorite for many families.

Other Popular Contenders

While sugar and chocolate chip cookies dominated the rankings, several other varieties made strong showings:

• Gingerbread cookies won in six states
• Snickerdoodles claimed victory in three states
• Gingersnap cookies topped the list in two states
• Shortbread cookies were the favorite in one state

Despite their strong association with Christmas, gingerbread cookies couldn’t quite compete with the universal appeal of sugar and chocolate chip varieties.

Unexpected Favorites

The survey also revealed some surprising preferences among cookie enthusiasts. About 2.4% of respondents chose seasonal Oreo cookies as their favorite holiday treat, while 1.6% favored Trader Joe’s Peppermint Joe Joe’s. These results highlight the enduring popularity of store-bought options, even during a season traditionally associated with home baking.

Regional Cookie Preferences

While the survey showed clear national favorites, it also revealed interesting regional variations in cookie preferences across the United States.

Midwest Munchies

In the Midwest, gingersnap cookies emerged as a regional favorite. These crisp, spicy cookies resonate with the heartland’s taste for bold flavors and traditional recipes.

Southern Sweetness

Southern states like Tennessee showed a particular fondness for snickerdoodles. These cinnamon-sugar-coated cookies deliver a perfect balance of sweetness and spice that appeals to the region’s culinary richness and hospitable nature.

New England Nosh

In New England, shortbread cookies made a strong showing. The simple buttery taste of these cookies aligns well with the region’s reputation for understated elegance and appreciation for classic recipes.

Western Wonders

On the West Coast, the preferences blended traditional favorites with modern twists. Here, residents indulge in oatmeal raisin cookies, marrying rustic charm with health consciousness.

The Appeal of Christmas Cookies

The appeal of Christmas cookies extends far beyond their taste. For many, these sweet treats are deeply intertwined with cherished holiday traditions and memories.

A Taste of Tradition

Cookies often represent family heritage and passed-down recipes. Many families have specific cookies they make every year, creating a tradition that spans generations.

Bringing People Together

Baking and decorating cookies is a social activity that brings people together. Whether it’s parents baking with children, friends gathering for a cookie exchange, or coworkers sharing treats at the office, cookies play a role in fostering connections during the holiday season.

A Canvas for Creativity

Decorating Christmas cookies allows for creative expression. From intricate royal icing designs to simple sprinkle patterns, cookie decorating offers a fun and accessible way for people of all ages to get into the holiday spirit. It’s a creative outlet that encourages family bonding and enhances the festive mood.

Tips for Baking the Perfect Christmas Cookies

If you’re getting inspired to create your own holiday favorites, here are some essential techniques for cookie-baking success. These tried-and-true methods will help capture the magic of holiday baking and deliver delightful results.

Selecting Ingredients

• Use room temperature ingredients: This simple step aids in better mixing and even cooking, allowing flavors to meld perfectly.
• Go for quality: Opt for high-quality butter and pure vanilla extract for a better taste and texture.

Preparation and Baking

• Chill the dough: Letting your dough rest in the refrigerator prevents over-spreading and helps retain shape for intricate cookies.
• Opt for good cookware: Invest in premium baking sheets and parchment paper to ensure even baking and achieve that perfect consistency.
• Timing is critical: Avoid overbaking by removing cookies just before they’re done. They’ll continue to set after being removed from the oven.

Decorating Tips

• Cool completely before adorning: Ensure that cookies are fully cooled to prevent icing from melting.
• Play with textures: Use varied sprinkles, edible glitter, and colored sugars to create visually appealing cookies that are as delightful to look at as they are to eat.

Storing and Preserving Christmas Cookies

Store cookies properly to keep them fresh and delicious throughout the holiday season.

Short-Term Storage

For cookies that will be consumed within a week or two, store them in an airtight container at room temperature. Line separate layers with parchment paper to prevent sticking and keep their taste and texture consistent.

Long-Term Storage

For longer storage, many types of cookies can be frozen for up to three months. Place cooled cookies in a freezer-safe container, separating layered treats with parchment paper. When ready to indulge, simply thaw at room temperature.

Keeping Cookies Fresh

To help maintain freshness, add a slice of bread to the storage container. The bread absorbs excess moisture, keeping crisp cookies crunchy.

Creative Ways to Share Christmas Cookies

Sharing cookies is a beloved holiday tradition. Here are some creative ideas to share holiday cookies with more friends and loved ones this season.

Hosting Fun Gatherings

• Host a virtual cookie exchange: Even from afar, friends and family can celebrate together by swapping recipes and enjoying virtual tastings.
• Organize cookie decorating parties: Get-togethers focused on decorating, with cookies as beautiful souvenirs of the day.

Crafting Thoughtful Gifts

• Create personal cookie gift baskets: Tailor these for neighbors or coworkers by including a mix of favorites with a handwritten card.
• Bake for a cause: Participate in charity bake sales and cookie drives, turning your kitchen creations into avenues for goodwill and support.

Fostering Community Spirit

• Arrange a neighborhood cookie drop-off: Brighten someone’s day by leaving a batch on their porch with a note of kindness.
• Decorate public spaces with cookie treats: Share wrapped cookie bundles with community centers or local establishments to share holiday joy.

Methodology

We surveyed 4,580 Americans in mid-November 2019 and asked them to select their favorite Christmas cookie. Respondents were not limited to specific demographics. We estimate the margin of error at 1%.