7 Essential Questions to Ask Before Replacing Your Roof

Three-story home with metal roof
Asking an installer the right questions can lead to a great-looking roof replacement that will last for many decades. (Photo courtesy of Classic Metal Roofing Systems)

The last thing homeowners need is anything else that adds to their stress. And because of extreme weather events in many regions, having to worry about the roof is especially unwelcome these days.

As homeowners begin to prioritize their spring home improvement projects, the experts at the Metal Roofing Alliance say the best method for ensuring peace of mind and long-term satisfaction starts with asking installers the right questions, well in advance of when a replacement project starts.

“Replacing a roof is a major expense and it has a big impact on how a home looks and performs,” said Renee Ramey, MRA executive director. “Because there are so many variables, it can be stressful and anxiety-producing, causing homeowners to feel uneasy about whether they are making the right choices.

“But it doesn’t have to be that way: asking good questions goes a long way towards making a worry- and hassle-free decision.”

According to MRA, the first step is finding a reputable, qualified pro who will conduct a thorough and honest evaluation of your roof’s current condition and determine whether replacement is necessary.

From there, key questions before making a roof replacement investment include:

1. Which Options Will Protect Your Home?

To get the best roof, plan for the worst. Hurricanes, tornadoes, wildfires, snow, hail, ice, driving rain and winds: consider the challenges in your region and make sure your roof is designed to withstand them.

The ultimate security comes from knowing your roof offers maximum protection for whatever Mother Nature throws at it, not just hoping it will.

Consider needed accessories such as snow guards, heavy-duty gutters and waterproof underlayment that can provide extra security and avoid added hassles and expenses later on.

2. What are the Maintenance Needs?

No matter what the material, all roofs typically look great when they are brand new. But certain materials such as asphalt, shake and clay can be particularly prone to maintenance issues such as moss, algae and fungus, especially in wet and humid climates.

Left unchecked, these issues are at best unsightly and at worst, shorten the lifespan and cause serious damage to a roof. Regular, professional treatments can be expensive and environmentally harmful.

Ask about low-maintenance options such as metal roofing that often require just plain water and gentle soap to keep looking great.

3. How Can You Verify a Roof’s Performance?

Warranties for both material and labor are very important. Beyond that, make sure a roof is rated by independent, credible sources for fire and hail resistance, as well as energy efficiency.

Roofs that carry a Class A fire rating and are an Energy Star qualified “Cool Roof” add up to great peace of mind when it comes to wildfire protection and maximizing efficiency in both cold and hot weather.

Be sure to ask your installer about proper insulation and underlayment designed to meet or exceed regional building codes for ongoing savings and protection.

4. Which Roofing Choices Are Structurally Sound?

There are lots of strong roofing options out there, including slate and clay, but these heavyweights may require additional reinforcement (and expense) of a roof’s underlying structure.

Snow and ice loads can add significantly to that weight, so homeowners who want a similar look may want to opt for metal roofing that can mimic those materials.

Metal offers superior strength under the most severe conditions, yet is much lighter per square foot, so additional structural reinforcements typically aren’t necessary.

5. What is the Manufacturer’s Reputation?

For roofs designed to last and deliver carefree performance and protection, quality matters. The cheapest bid is often not the best deal.

Learn more about the material being proposed, where it is sourced and whether the manufacturer has a solid reputation and will stand behind their products.

Be sure they use high-quality techniques and materials, too. For example, high-tech paint and coatings can make a huge difference in the durability, performance and ongoing maintenance of a roof.

Ask for details and verification from your installer regarding the material specs being proposed.

6. How Can You Choose the Right Style?

Ideally, a new roof will last a very long time, so choosing the right look matters. Again, it is important to consider regional conditions and never prioritize design over performance.

For example, even if you love the look of wood shake, do not use it in a wildfire-prone area. Instead, choose a material like metal that can mimic the look but won’t compromise on protection.

Try on colors and different designs before deciding: use online tools such as the MRA visualizer to see how a new roof will actually look on a home.

7. Which Roofing Choices Are Sustainable?

Consider the lifecycle of a roof, from tear-off to manufacturing to longevity. Some materials, like metal roofing, can be installed right over an older asphalt roof to avoid tear-off and landfill waste.

They also can be 100% recycled at the end of their long life and last up to three times longer than other roofing types.

In addition, quality metal roofs with high-performance coatings offer among the best energy efficiency of any roofing material.

For more information and a comprehensive Buyer’s Guide available as a free download, visit www.metalroofing.com.

About Metal Roofing Alliance

Representing the residential metal roofing industry in the United States and Canada, the Metal Roofing Alliance was formed to help educate consumers about the many benefits of metal roofing.

The main objective of MRA is to increase awareness of the beauty, durability and money-saving advantages of quality metal roofing among homeowners, as well as to provide support to the residential metal roofing industry.

For more information, visit MRA at www.metalroofing.com.


  1. what is the deal?? I know that I am not that dumb. I have clicked on your metal roofs for the house that you have a picture of and the house disappears. why recommend it if you can’t go to see what you are recommending.

    • This article displays correctly on our end, Robert.
      These are questions to consider before replacing your roof, not recommendations for specific metal roofing alloys.
      Thanks for reading!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here